Slumdogs, after all
Zeenews
       English        
Saturday, February 11, 2012 
Search
Follwo us on: Facebook Follwo us on: Twiter RSS Mail to us Mail to us Mail to us
Blogs

Slumdogs, after all

Wednesday, May 27, 2009, 08:48 Views 29 Comments 13
Royal Rage
a
I didn’t like Slumdog Millionaire.

Its superficial script, lack of talent in adult star cast, Brit accented chaiwallah, sequences short on time and emotions (gimme a maudlin mamma any day) and an unfriendly host of a game show that once, in fact, touched the heart of this nation so much, it rescued the dipping fortune of Mr. Beard & Baritone- spoiled the chances of the undercooked movie from turning into the sensory experience we like to spend money on Fridays.

That’s not to say I didn’t rejoice in the unprecedented acclaim ‘Slumdog…’ garnered from across the globe. Like you, I got up early morning to catch a glimpse of our own Rahman rub shoulders with Brangelina and win that award, which was the most awaited one in our part of the world for reasons known best to no one.

I did an impromptu jig when he Jai Hoed his way to the Kodak theatre stage generally reserved for song-&-dance items, which aren’t really a part of the nominated films. We all lapped up the show and bathed in its glory. But the truth is that I agreed wholeheartedly when anyone said- with lots of hesitation- that they didn’t quite understand why the world and the Pussycat Dolls suddenly liked a ‘Bollywood’(its actually British) film which couldn’t have lasted even a single weekend in India, were it not for the international wah-wahs.

The worst part is this- I didn’t like the film and I am loathing what it has done to a bunch of kids.

The state of Slumdog Millionaire’s (real) stars- the slum kids- who danced their way o many hearts, reminds me of old Bollywood flicks with the following themes: bonded labour, evil landowners, endless debt, exploitation, no roof over head, strained personal ties in face of new found fame etc. It’s a Bollywood thing- tragic stories with lots of music, tears and blood.

Not that the current state of affairs has anything to do with little Rubina and Azhar not winning the Best Actor award- the shanties of these hapless kids have been bulldozed and they have nowhere to go and nothing to do apart from telling the world that this is what they face regularly.

For the kids, about 10-11 years olds, who were not even going to school before Lovleen Tandon cast them and paid paltry sums, it was all like in films. A Cinderella story- or some other fairytale-like. From the smelly by lanes of Dharavi to the heady curves of the Oscar Red Carpet- a perfect Bollywood plot.

But for them, the reality remains just like before. And it has left bitterness on our otherwise sweet-n-sour tongues. In the early days of glory, many quaffed at the suggestion that the West was back at showing India in a poor light- if not snakes and rope tricks, it is now the muck of slums bang in the middle of Mumbai.

But the way things have turned out for these kids who were promised the good life post their acting stint, there remains little doubt now that it was an ego massage that the wild west didn’t have for a long time as India rose to higher-ups. And now they have got an Academy Award for it.

It took the destruction of their houses to bring director Danny Boyle rushing to Mumbai and announce once again that the kids will get the promised roof. When the media picked on the issue, Maharashtra CM Ashok Chavan also jumped in the house-giving fray with conditions attached- the kids will have to choose between Danny Boyle's plush flat or Govt's housing scheme.

Where did the roti, kapda & makaan promised by our trustworthy netas and generous Hollywood studios vanish? Whatever happened to the life-long scholarships that the kids were supposed to get? Will Aamir and SRK not join their heads for this cause like they did for the ‘poor’ producers?

If an Oscar can’t better your life, what can?!

The fate of the kids is reflective of the way child artists are treated in an industry, where increasing number of prime time sops have children as their mainstay- Balika Vadhu, Krishna etc.

Being Bollywood, where logic matters little till it’s a tear-jerker, jhatak-matak of an affair, this tale too has its sad twists. Two mothers fighting over their newly popular prodigy of a son, the jhuggis coming alive with throbbing scenes of an undercover reporter bringing in wealthy Sheikhs shopping for children, the younger siblings being slapped around for they ‘were no good’ viz a viz their better-off sister- gosh I have suddenly realized why we like what we like on our silver screens. Our- or most of our- small lives are masala scripts for budding Danny Boyles!

It’s okay if you have missed the irony. It’s so much a part of our daily lives, really. But spare a thought for those kids- they thought they had made it big, early on. That the dream their peers could only dream of achieving was a reality already. But in one filmy wipe, it was dark again. The credits rolled up in dim lights, we clapped for the kind attention paid to our part of the world and moved on to the post-movie dinner.

P.S.: Good to know Rahman, Resul, Anil, Freida and Dev have grabbed plum offers abroad. At least someone’s a millionaire, because in The End, things tend to miraculously resume normalcy in the most ‘realistic’ of our films.
(The views expressed by the author in the blog are his/her own)
Kira - Chennai
Yeah.. i`m glad you said some thing against all the whoa wah for a film that in many many ways was n`t any better than many good Indian movies... not a movie buff though but, I`m sure this had no substance and life as the west claims....
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
sribatsa samal - bhubaneswar orissa
I appreciatethe candid comment of the author not swayed by the storm of publicity.Iam in complete agreement with views expressed
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Prashant - Pune
Well written friend, the movie was focused on negative part...but we can`t ignore the fact that it was written by an indian.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Always Indian - Mumabi
The post is well written and the view is quite subjective. If we comement on how much the movie was over-rated, doesn`t the awards speak for themselves. Our own people were rewarded. We at always indian have a different view and we have posted this on our blog. We don`t disapprove but we believe in facts and give our personal view.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Pradeep Singh - Noida
Very well written blog. Honestly I didn`t like the film that much but for the apathy of the Slumdogs the film director or the film makers cannot be criticised. Role of cinema is to entertain, this film Slumdog Millionaire is not about solving problem of the kids who live there lives is shati`s or jhuggi`s. But it is showing us the reality, reality which is bitter but so true. What this film has achieved is got people like us discuss the slumdogs. In our daily routines we are so busy or occupied that for us a kid ragpicker or a chotu at a tea stall are normal scenario. We don`t try or say don`t want to look beyond the torn shirt they wear. This films acts as media to higlight the issue, rest it is not the role of the film maker to provide house or roti for the actors or the charectors in the movie. During any bomb blast when have you seen any news channel picking up the victims and helping them by taking them to hospitals. Their role is to ignite the thought process and this is what this movie has achieved. We all see beggars on road but we never prefer to look into there lives as we know or assume it would be filled with myseries. This film takes you to the unseen, unimaginable lives of the slumdogs, which in a normal scenario most of us who are blatantly criticising the movie, would have definitely not liked to see.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sharique - New Delhi
Very well written blog!!! I share the same emotions about the movie!!!!
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sambasivam - Sambo
We need to get over it - an outsider made a film about India which is much better than most films made about India by Indians. Criticisms about lack of realism etc. are so bogus that it is not worth rebutting. So what? Suddenly, we are concerned about realism in our films? Give me a break
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Manju - India
The only positive thing about the movie is couple of slum kids got international recognition and were taken off slums.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
rohit - bangalore
very beautufully put blog..,slumdog is one of the most overated movies ever,the fact it is so popular, shows the ignornace of people in US,UK of how people live in third world countries like india.if they want 2 have pity and compassion for poverty,they should watch national geographic or somethin...
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sam Gurgaon - Gurgaon
interesting...
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Tanu - Noida
A very thought provoking and interesting write up!!
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Shreyas - Pune
Touche.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Priya - Meerut
If life is so tough for the slum kids why hasnt India done anything for them. Why dont the slum kids have access to good schools, 3 meals a day and a decent place to live with a functional bathroom. Why are 60 of indians defecating on the streets and open spaces. Whya are most Indian cities without any proper plumbing and water. Why do most indians live next to places with open drains that simply flow into rivers, heaps of garbage dumps and plastic bags and ``uncle chips`` packaging junk strewn all over the countryside. I have seen how most indians keep their houses sparkling clean but dump trash and human waste where ever they find it convenient.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Post your Comments

Name  
Place :  
Email :  
Comments :