India - The Republic Of Non-Thinkers
Zeenews
       English        
 Follow Me on Pinterest Google Plus Ditto RSS Mail to us Mail to us
Friday, May 24, 2013 
Search
Blogs

India - The Republic Of Non-Thinkers

Last Updated: Monday, August 08, 2011, 12:39
Views 2450 Comments 27  
Contrarian
a
We, the people of India - citizens and leaders seem to be on a long holiday from thinking. Consider any of the big ticket issues, economic reforms, inflation, price rise, corruption, the provisions of the Lok Pal Bill, the role of civil society, terrorism, how to tackle Pakistan, the Maoist menace, the secrecy surrounding Sonia Gandhi's illness.

White noise has replaced reasoned debate. There is a clamour for a silver bullet short-cut instead of the thoughtful discipline required for true nation building.

As a country we have always been proud of jugaad - our unmatched ability to patch things together and make them work. The problem is that this ‘take it easy’ policy is now the problem. Yes politicians are corrupt, seethes the middle class. They are not interested in building a great country, they do not care about issues that bother us, they are snug in the embrace of their vote-bank. All true. But, what is our solution? Hail Anna Hazare as a messiah. Shor
t circuit Parliament and democracy. Is that really workable? So if you don't like the present lot of politicians, is the middle class solution secession from democracy?

Why not actually follow Anna and make the same bums accountable?

Price rise and inflation is a huge problem, but have we given the politicians a mandate to make reforms attractive. Reforms are done by stealth. Has anybody paused and thought that in the thought-free mass that is the mass media that dole economics such as NREGA is actually creating a huge problem? So much so that even Congress ruled states are asking for its suspension in the sowing season. No. Instead, what we have is fevered speculation about chewing gum bugging in the highest echelons of government.

Is this really relevant? It helps a lazy government escape from its responsibilities. As China marches ahead, we keep putting down our growth targets as the world laughs. Punish the guilty in the 2G scam by all means, but remember that due process has to be followed and all the scamsters including A Raja are now in jail for six months. And Kanimozi, and even Suresh Kalmadi deserve bail. Let them be tried and sentenced for their crimes, but being in jail sans bail cannot be an alternative for conviction. Let the sun-rise sectors of telecom which put a mobile phone and undreamed of access in the hands of a billion Indians not be destroyed.

As the UP polls approach, divisive politics will hold sway. It’s the only way our politicians know. Reject it. Also politics over land. Don't believe them. They have kept a 200-year old land acquisition act on the statute so that they and their cronies benefit.

Fight for the abolition of discretionary powers. It is these entitlements that let our Netas live more opulently then the Maharajas of yore.

The Maoists and Pakistan are problems that cannot be wished away. And, no court can give a band-aid solution. There is no fevicol in the world for the festering sore that Pakistan is. It is a terrorist tourism centre and we need to stop dithering and playing politics with national interest.

It is quite puzzling in the 21st century that the Congress party still lives in its quaint world of palace intrigues and courtiers. Mrs Sonia Gandhi is the tallest leader of India and it behooves the party that India should be aware of what ailment her leader is suffering from as it impinges national interest. This is not a salacious plea dressed up as high minded interest, but a desire to follow all mature democracies such as the USA where the President's health bulletin every year is made public since it obviously impacts decision making.

So can we move on from the silly season and actually get on with the business in hand.
(The views expressed by the author are personal)
Todd - Orland Calif USA
a truly well written and lovely written, not only would i support her in an election, but ask her to marry.now, will the people support her and keep safe and keep her from being killed?
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Archit Anand - Kolkata
few days back mamta banerjee organised a huge rally saying it is to display grief for the martyrs of singur what is the truth everyone knows??? loads of money is spent in beautifying mid way lanes at various sites across kolkata but why??? i think it would right if they make the infrastructure basic need strong or requirement?/
few days back or whenever if it rains in kolkata the high profile area forget about other areas of kolkata park street is full of water the walkways which were renovated few days back gets filled up with water??? all beautifactions is washed away in just few mm of rain why??? you want to make it london than first work on basics:-\
1.drainage system
2.road
3.electricity
not that you directly jump on beautification its utter foolishness and waste of money.......i dont know when people of bengal or rahter people of india will understand the joke....make polliticians walk in drain waters on walkways than only something concrete is going to happen....
question:is raja ,kalmadi,manmohan singh ,rahul gandhi,sonia gandhi, pranob mukherjee a tax payer if not than how will they understand our pain who work for 12 months and get paid for 11 only we unitedly fund their living expense and emi`s for toyota fortuner???????lolzzzz
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
alok kumar verma - delhi
i think ,in this time congress party live only congress not ,congress+swaraj .he goes to his actual agenda of congress .........
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
prithvi raj - mumbai
swati ji ne likha bahoot achcha likha hum sub apke sath hei.sooner or later volcano will errupt through our blood,aaj kal serial chandra gupt mourya bahoot achcha lagata hei.jab jhansi ki rani aour chanakya milanei ki deri hei, bus dekte raho, tab kahan bhagege woh log.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Mkg - Bglr
there is no point saying the obvious things. the whole country knows it. when we discuss india is a republic of non-thinkers we should first find the answer why do people here don`t want to think. then the question will arise what will they do when they start thinking. the answer is not much because the chances of succeeding are least than 0.1%. then again the question arises why they wont do anything. the answer lies in the fact that india is used to live under suppression since the start of its civilization basically. so the genes are slightly muted. but then what can we do about it? then again the answer is spread education, spread awareness. how will we do it? by economic development. that is why i have said for the next 10 yrs congress party has to rule and the bjp has to stick to its agenda and sit in opposition.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
COMMANDER KINRA - DELHI
the article is brain shattering because we are passing through an age where money matters more then morals . we know the cost of things but have forgotten their values. it appears the whole nation is on fire put by the looters to take advantage of situations and in process keep looting. woh kahan hai , kahan hein jinhe hind pey naz tha. god save my country at a time when there is politics without principles, business without morality. education without character and wealth without work.hurray to swati
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
vikram - jaipur
rather than non thinkers it seems we are a republic of morons!
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Archit Anand - Kolkata
@anil koli
my dear friend if you dont agree with swati you live in fool`s paradise, our engineers r toppers till college everything is on top, but after college what happens when they are recruited by maharatna company`s see the condition of drainage system i guess cwg sites were built and designed by indian architects but what is the condition. thing is that we have set our brand value which comes with offer in pick season periods like (cwg,@g etc...)high time dont see how many of us have achieved there is a queue of non achievers which other a grade countries don`t have??????
i would like to say this will continue to happen if unqualified people clinch victory in lok sabha and other elections??? eg, silly and reluctant steps of lalu has made bihar fall 1000 steps back ??? what is the fault of people there? it was one step of t n seshan which brought in the change....
what did an overnight decision of vp singh give us on mandal commission
bring educated people of high morale value and self respect in parliament and difference could be seen.........
why not anna be given bharat ratna if we can give rajiv gandhi who led boforce scam and helped dow chemical`s anderson to escape and people of his own country to suffer than why not anna be nominated for bharat ratna or next president`s election?????
thanx
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
siva - chennai
good your analysis is true, that is the existing one. persons like and me to do so are there every where. but who want to act and how to act upon our politics is the main thing. following anna hazare may prove good. but these dyas we have keep our surroundings clean,obey traffic rules and what else a sense of commonness is necessary. then a moment for good governance and good and progressive politics follows until then not.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Girish - Gurgaon
swati heres the 7 course political corruption menu ,
its high time all get to there toes and not only start thinking but doing too , i admire anna and his team for doing what they can do , ,, however the people are angry , not only cause of a lok pal bill ,half of supporters may not even understand how its going to work for them i guess its thanks to the 7 course political menu of our elected reps , the dinner which is being served to the public by our elected representatives starts with the highest level corruption exposed of unimaginable amounts with endless zeros as the starter, then add the petrol lpg and diesel , vegetables daily necessities price hikes 7 or 8 times in last 2 years as the soup , for the entree a lathi charge on innocent people sleeping including senior citizens, ladies and children around midnight at the ramdev camp , for legume you can be served with a common wealth scam adarsh or now even eyebrows being lifted on shiela dixit, for roast police running after farmers and shooting them on there backs just cause they were peacefully protesting or the land aquisition on top for dessert impose section 144 and stop people from the one option of protest available to people, a fast or a annshan , the policy is crush and rule , govt cannot offer jobs , understood , but this government has failed in even giving a reply to its people , the hearts of the country are burning but it takes weeks before the people get a reply from the hon prime ministers office ,, is that too much to ask ?
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Devendra Tripathi - Lucknow
thanks for your writings upon the current situations in our country, why are we having nehru gandhi family still to dominate & destroy our country, aren`t there other leaders in india like atal ji.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Arun Berry - New Delhi
no doubt india is puling on juggads but i dont know who were the innovators of juggads in this country may be simple and quick system to achieve goals. one great personality told me if u k opens visa for one week most of indian youths will run there, ``why`` to work and earn in healthy political system, while if you work hard and honestly earn in india you have to share more with corrupt system and less to taxation for development of country along with mental and physical harasments.may be corruption comes in our blood through atmosphere as we find most of rakshas were born in india and god appear again and again for removal but again the same happens.i also think when corrupts read these sort of massages they feel proud that they are highlighted and their business are on high sky.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Kavita Lal - gurgaon
swati, you read our minds. so well articulated article. could you also advise some your other competitor reporters not to waste primetime with hollow discourses but join the band wagon ``team india`` nee team anna to fight this menace of corruption by acting as true citizens of this country. we owe it to this great nation . dont let anybody forget `duty comes before the rights`
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sarbjit - Mohali
one thing you must understand is that worse things than london riots are going to happen in india. we the general class is on the verge of major mental and social break down because of the reservatiom system. if i want to apply for a govt job, i have to pay 4 times more than an sc candidate. i am unemployed still i have to pay. `all are same` must be written mars constitution, it sure does`t apply in ours.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Satya - Angul
chalta hai yaar.. take it easy.. i am proud of jugaad !!
as a great man once said ``out of all this chaos n confusion.. emerges the perfect & most beautiful pattern !!``
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Ajay Gupta - Rajgangpur-770017
not exactly republic of non-thinkers there are hell lot doing the thinking but just thinking never acting or speaking `what` that too as a result of thinking on its outcome first -who will take the pain after speaking. truly to it some who try to speak or act face consequences and threats beyond imagination,one getting killed can be less painful but apart from it there are other humiliating facile, fear is what holds a common man from it. but things have changed and one anna stepped one and it is the voice of india now wait and watch........
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
dashrath singh rathore - balotra, rajasthan
i like your comments & thanking you for write article with honesty.i feel this medea house is fourth `` khambha`` is our ``loktantr`` . i wait next article.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Himanshu - Surat
swati ji namste
swati ji first i want to thank you to write the right article. second i want to say if media will write this type of real article which is directley concern with problem & will give the clearity to public so aisa lagege ki kam se kam media to nahi bika hai. other wise i am saying to you frankly ki aaj kal media bhi lagta hai sirf or sirf bik gaya hai koi cong. ka hai to koi bjp ka .
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
ANIL KOHLI - NEW DELHI
i donot agree with swati. it is wrong to generalise that we all are non thinkers. we have the best talents in the world. but yes the political system needs to be changed. had it been true then the citizens of this great nation would not have achieved what we are today. the citizens are trying their level best to achieve best in their life but it is the political system which makes them fail. see the number of scams being discovered these days. in absence of all such illegal activities , if the government money is spent in a right manner for right/deserving people the scene can be changed. it will be a new , self reliant, prosperous india. may god bless india.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sudhir - Hyderabad
hi swati, you are marvellous! i see a reflection of my thoughts in every word you have written. thank you for bringing this out.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Archit Anand - Kolkata
its really true that india is a republic of non thinkers
if not said so people descending from gandhi pariwar not star pariwar hah would have won....
what will say thinkers of india realised that rajiv gandhi and indra gandhi were apt candidate for bharat ratna award even before sardar patel and maaulana abul kalam azad, what a joke right? its not wrong to predict not only rahul gandhi but his son will also some day get bharat ratna today or tomorrow?????
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
deepak - ranchi
hi swati ur comments are absolutely surreal.even if 5% of our people think ur way our country will nt remain a laggard instead it will be the table topper.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
PRASHANT R. UPADHYAY - MUMBAI
swatiji,
thousands of congratulations!!!
zhansi ki rani is born again. you are like her. watan ki raah (sachchai ki raah) per chalte chalte apna sar bhie katwa sakti hain. zhansi ki rani born once in a thousand years!!!!
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
BRIJ - NEWYORK
your article is excellent,india as nation right now is lame duck,what we need a good starter to ignite this desire of change,from current life style of thinking it is going to be ok.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Pramod Chaturvedi - Gurgaon
dear swati,

i complimnet for writing such a bold article.
but consider following,
1] a person refuses to give bribe in any govt offices is harrased.no effective redressal for grievance .
2]people know their rights but fails to fullfill their duties.
3]any person who is after corrupt is killed or threatned so much that he becomes scared.

4]doesn not participate in election.

untill we adress all issues our jugad culture will flourish.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
S.D.Solanki. - Mumbai.
namaste swati,

every indian should read and act after reading your article. i wish more articles like this intellectual learned writers. we have to wake our countrymen. my request keep it up. result may be slow but do not get disheartened.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
AJ - Blore
one of friend had written a line that said for the people of this nation that ``???? ????? ?? ?????? ???? ?? `` . you are absolutely right. there are towering issues in front of this nation and we still live comfortably without asking the politicians , upa , state governments to be accountable!!! i think there can`t be a nation with people more numb than india. the nation which revolted hardly a hundred years ago today sits like a lame duck!! thanks for posting this and keep writing.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Post your Comments

Name  
Place :  
Email :  
Comments :