Mamata Banerjee, Pranab Mukherjee, Mulayam Singh Yadav, Raisina Hills, President of India, Trinamool Congress, Manisha Singh
Zeenews
       English        
 Follow Me on Pinterest Google Plus Ditto RSS Mail to us Mail to us
Wednesday, June 19, 2013 
Search
Blogs

Mamata Banerjee’s <i>Kabhi Haan, Kabhi Na</i>

Last Updated: Tuesday, July 17, 2012, 20:03
Views 1600 Comments 17  
Uncut
a
Mamata Banerjee has done it again. The temperamental leader has taken everyone by surprise and come around to supporting Pranab Mukherjee for the top post of the country, swallowing her pride and being ‘pained’ along the way. Ditched by Mulayam Singh Yadav and former president APJ Abdul Kalam, the maverick Chief Minister of West Bengal was cornered from all sides and as she said she was probably left with ‘no choice’.

Bravely facing the media, Mamata announced that the Trinamool Congress will support the former finance minister in the race to Raisina Hills. However, Mamata should not feel too bad about it. Poor Pranab has been imploring her everyday to vote for him - calling her a ‘sister’ in order to woo her. In fact he said recently – “I appeal to her almost every day. It is for her to decide (whether to support me for Presidency).” (It is another matter that they hadn’t talked to each other for months. But after Mamata's declaration of support for Pranab, he called an
d thanked her.)

Is there anyone who can claim to know Mamata or understand her well? The woman who had left Atal Bihari Vajpayee in the lurch and walked out of the NDA and who had left the Congress to form her own party gave the impression this time around that she would hold her fort and not buckle whatever the compulsions may be.

Remember not too long ago she had the gumption to take over none other than the Congress president Sonia Gandhi on the issue of the presidential election. And in her brave attempt to do so, whom did she rely upon? – the wily politician from the Hindi heartland – Mulayam Singh Yadav. Mamata did the famous press conference with him after meeting with the UPA chairperson, giving a thumbs down to Sonia’s choice of candidates for the President (which incidentally included Pranab) and announcing the name of APJ Abdul Kalam, Manmohan Singh and Somnath Chatterjee as their choice. While the name of the Prime Minister coming from an ally embarrassed the Congress no end, Sonia Gandhi literally took her head on and promptly named Pranab as the UPA’s candidate.

It seemed then that Mamata had already lost the battle before it had begun. But what completely decimated her was the fact that before anyone could bat an eyelid, the former CM of Uttar Pradesh, Mulayam did a complete U-turn and promptly declared his support for Pranab. I guess Mamata must have learnt some new lessons from the Samajwadi Party supremo on how the game of politics is played. In fact Mulayam and Mayawati literally fell over each other to declare their love for the veteran Congress leader. (Both have a disproportionate assets case hanging over them and both have their pound of flesh to extract from the Congress. But that is another debate.)

Coming back to Mamata – What did the cornered leader from Bengal do – She wryly said that Mulayam was a ‘politician’ and ominously declared that ‘the game was not over yet’. ‘Wait and watch’ – she added.

In the interim wait and watch period what happened – Mamata went on to make her debut on social networking site Facebook garnering support for Kalam, who subsequently formally announced that he was not in the contention for the top post of the country and the West Bengal CM was once again left high and dry. Imagine the man for whom the lady had staked her prestige was not there in the offing at all.

Anyway, from then till now Mamata has been quiet – only to come out now and declare with a ‘sad heart’ that in a democracy it was not right not to vote and that if her party had to vote, then they might as well do it for the grand old man of the Congress party. “It was the only option. We did not decide to vote for Pranab to please anyone; in a democracy if we don’t vote then it would be betrayal of the people,” she said. We have to grant her one thing – she may be a politician who is ruled more by her heart but then at least she is honest.

Yes, Mamata was being honest when she said that she was left with no choice. With the coffers of her state empty and the economy in shambles, she needs huge financial support from the Centre to bring West Bengal back on track. And if she had on an impulse left the alliance at the Centre what would she have gained? A few more seats in the next Lok Sabha if the government were to fall and if the General Elections were to be held earlier than 2014. But that scenario was unlikely as there was always Mulayam and Mayawati waiting in line to extend support to the Congress-led government and help it survive. As it is both of them have been supporting the UPA from the outside. So in the end Mamata would lose the support of a friendly government at the Centre and there would be no surety as to where the TMC would stand in the next elections.

Also Mamata was pretty sure that her party people would cross vote in case she went against Pranab.

She could not go along with the NDA without quitting the UPA and going with Naveen Patnaik and Jayalalithaa was also not a viable and practical option.

Post Script: Well, after all, we will have a Mamata looking on when Pranab is anointed King (which seems most likely as of now). But will she smile or will she look pained...just ‘wait and watch’.
(The views expressed by the author are personal)
raju naik - hyderabad
i like didi for admant decision taking pattern,she did right by not supporting pranab,who totally failed reacting positively towards black money being finance minister
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sumana Bose - Jalandhar
i recently came across your blog and have been reading along. i don`t know what to say except that i have enjoyed reading what you all have to say.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
LAMBA - DELHI
good to read your at large article, ms.
i was expecting dd will bent later for the intrest of her state/india only & dd is soft by heart also.this type of situation will also be occurs during 2014. now govt. to take care inline with gift given to up after pres. elec.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
indian - AUE
it was almost decided but she (mamta )is attention seeker nothing else
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Aditi Bakshi - Calcutta
mamata had no option but to support pranab mukherjee.her own party members would have cross voted in favor of shri mukherjee.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Randhir Kumar Yendrembam - Imphal
in the long run mamata will become an untrustworthy leader.nobody will beleive her.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
S.Francis - Mumbai
Wow! Gr8! Aamir show is already working inside us!
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
punit patel - patan- gujarat
thanks rahulji... ap samj gaye.. amir khan tu si great ho ji..
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
sumeli das - kolkata
its really good
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Menz - Calgary, Canada
good to read your at large article, ms.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Rajkumar Singh - Mumbai
such debates are held or conducted to divide the people (similar to the clarifications or statements given against and for the accusations, allegations, etc., of anyone), and it is never in the interest of the public, but the vested interests of the conductors and the participants of the debates!

it is a part of the problem under a ploy of divide and rule, but never a part of the solution only to enlarge or enrage the issues!

``wake-up citizens, jaago duniya, understand the reality & facts``!
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
mahendra - vadodara
atleast mamta had guts to eye contact sonia, others just can`t see above her foots.

constitution writesr forgot to include right to see as fundamaental right of citizens, had it been there, these coaxing stars of congress could see her by face.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Suvash - Aurangabad
jab yahi karna tha to itana natak kyo. asal me bengali manush ke chalate sabse pahle inhe support karna tha.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Steve - Australia
i love india & indian people so much, travelling there every year to help the people who are struggling the most. mamata is doing some great things in west bengal. i`m sure i`m not alone in hoping and praying that those in leadership in india would all pull together and get on the same page for the common good and best outcomes for all indians. yours is the most wonderful nation on the earth with the most precious people - come on leaders, please lead your great nation with one voice and one heart, let every dollar go where it is needed most, lead with intergrity, transparency, compassion, vision, and love.
best regards to you all.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
J Kumar - Muscat
yes, people are laughing now seeing the actions, but without knowing the compulsions perhaps. i feel she is doing everything for core of heart, which had gone absent since long years. all the corners are polluted with the reign of the last government, who basically have no right to say anything , excepting constructive things / suggestions , and that is what wanted from those educated people. the cash level has fallen , no job oppertunities have been created over the years, bengalis are migrating to other states / countries for their livelihoods. if you visit kolkata , you will find the houses once constructed by their parents, have been getting sold out to promoters, to get money , and managing expenses from those. because , during the period , neither they got education properly, nor they can go and secure jobs , competing with other state students, and confidence level has gone below zero level. once we found our ex -ruling group had compared ourselves with jharkhand people, what you expect out of them. do you think these group of people who have shattered our lives , displacing ourselves, torturing ourselves, and forcing us to sell off our parental land , deserve ``security`` ( through our paid tax money), you people to decide. please don`t be biased and allow her to do a good job.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Biswanath Das - Kolkata
mamtadi took right decesion and gave a very good lesson to pranab and cpm.as a chief minister she should think for the state first and for the interest of the her decesion is absolutly right.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
C SUNDARARAMAN - MUMBAI
as the congress government is playing a double game with mamta didi & mulayam singh, didi has no option but to support the pranab mukherjee as president of india though she is very adamant in taking decision. initially she thought whatever she try to behave, the congress government will obey to her, but the situation has dramatically changed once mulayam singh of up has gone against her wishes with promise from the upa government that his own state will get funds. this is a good play by the congress president mrs. soniaji in compromising a person by her money power and to ditch other.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
D.N.MAKHIJA - DELHI.........................INDIA
mamta badly insulted.....this time
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
m k mishra - pakur
mamta did the right thing by supporting pranab and thus not hurting the bengali pride of having a president from bengal. or she would be equated with the cpm who prevented jyoti basu from being the first bengali pm
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Post your Comments

Name  
Place :  
Email :  
Comments :