Friday, December 20, 2013
Friday, December 20, 2013
Of DRS and Runners
Last Updated: Wednesday, July 13, 2011, 20:26
It seems that ICC's appetite for controversies is growing on a daily basis. Being cricket's apex authority, it has perfected another art in addition to governance that keeps the fans amused. The art of hitting headlines courtesy confused and controversial decisions. The love affair keeps on growing. One after another, ICC is giving cricket's batting maestros a run for their monies with its own masterstrokes.
I won't go deep and limit myself to discussing two recent instances only that have generated much debate to the point of giddiness.
First, its vacillating view on DRS that pitted it against the member cricketing nations barring BCCI has led many to suggest whether it is becoming a slave to BCCI's economic might.
Its unequal attitude towards the implementation of the ball tracking technology raised many eyebrows that subsequently led to a variety of arguments and counter-arguments. The clause of ‘mutual consent’ that dictated as to whether DRS woul
d be implemented or not in a bilateral series created much confusion.
What that meant was in effect any bilateral series involving India would be deprived of DRS technology since it had reservations regarding the same.
Apart from this, the sensitive nature of technology owing to its military significance would also result in country-specific formalities and hurdles.
However, better sense prevailed when ICC's chief executive committee met in Hong Kong and unanimously agreed on mandatory implementation of technology sans ball tracing but with audio-tracking devices and infra-red cameras i.e. using ‘Snickometer’ and ‘Hot Spot’ technology respectively.
It seemed as if the monkey was finally off the back, but what ICC failed to take into account was the cost of implementing ‘Hot Spot’ technology. Not every cricket board in the world is blessed with the money that the top four or five cricketing nations have. Provided that the host nation agrees to foot the bill, the system would be put in place for a specific series.
BCCI did agree to the implementation of the technology in the meeting but it seems that it has drawn a lot of concessions in lieu of giving its approval.
Consider this; India won't be hosting Bangladesh or Zimbabwe for a Test or ODI series until 2020. It is another fact that India have never hosted Bangladesh in a bilateral series since they got their Test status in 2000. Maybe BCCI does not consider them to be a lucrative prospect in terms of money, sponsorship, eyeballs, considering their minnow’s status.
Who can dismiss this as not being a favour?
Future Tour Programme also provides a window for IPL in April and May along with Champions League Twenty20 in September that will allow most nations to make their best players available for both the tournaments, which again would be a least concern to anyone else but BCCI.
How much ICC is subservient to BCCI can be gauged by the recent comments that former West Indian great Michael Holding made against the influence of BCCI. “They (BCCI) have too much power. I do not believe that any country should be able to dictate to the rest of the world.”
In short, Holding called BCCI the real power that runs the sport that ideally, ICC ought to be.
No Runners Anymore
Another significant decision that resulted in one of the most endearing, often amusing but nevertheless, a distinguishing feature of cricket as a sport coming to an end was scrapping of runners.
The argument behind this was its abuse at the hands of batsmen. I agree with that. An on-field umpire is not in a position to judge whether a batsman is limping because of some injury or just making it out so as to get an advantage.
Well, apart from preventing potential unfair exploitation of rule; this has also deprived a genuine case with an option to fight even when chips are down. This is unseen in other sports be it football or tennis where once injured a player is substituted. But the option of not having a runner would rob a player to display grit in unfavourable times.
Some are suggesting it was unequal to bowlers. How? If a bowler gets injured, he can still bowl provided he is willing to do so but if he injures his leg or bowling arm then how in the world do you think he will continue? A batsman can continue so by taking the help of a runner if he decides to continue in the event of an injury. How can a bowler’s inabilities to bowl resulting from injury is comparable to a batsman employing the services of runners?
You would say it is unfair for the fielding side. But the fielding side gets an option to replace an injured fielder from reserves. Doesn't it? So how is this unfair?
At most, ICC could have limited the usage of a runner subject to an extraneous injury and disallowing it in the event when it was demanded because a batsman got tired after playing a long innings.
Abolishing it altogether was a bit harsh as Indian batsman Yuvraj Singh said in an interview.
In the world of Formula 1, drivers get opportunities to replace their corroded tyres, so that they have a fresh set and can continue their race. ICC's decision to do away with runners is like barring the drivers from changing their tyres, forcing them to continue on the eroded ones.
The time that a driver takes while changing tyres can make differences in his race timings. ICC could have taken a leaf out of Formula 1 and could have modified their rules for using the runners. But instead of brainstorming, they decide to do away with it altogether.
Like they say, life is not perfect and neither is the game of cricket and its governors. Maybe better sense prevails but till then, hope that ICC does away with amusing us with its topsy-turvy decisions.
(The views expressed by the author are personal)
Retirement- Newest joke in town
The Great Harbhajan Singh?
Proud father Fardeen Khan can`t stop smiling
Fardeen, Natasha blessed with baby girl
Change is the sign of growth: Mithun
Now enter `DID` through online platform
comments powered by Disqus.
comments powered by
Most Popular in Blog
Gautam Gambhir: Once India’s captain-in-waiting, now awaiting comeback
Outcome of election results, or AAP`s message to politicians?
Delhi gang-rape: One year on, women still not ‘Nirbhaya’
Another overseas demise as India fail to acclimatize
The Ashes: Gabba Test lives up to its hype!
Reality and reality television
India vs South Africa: Post-Tendulkar era begins, Virat Kohli shines
The Ashes: When Australia bat for fair cricket…
The Ashes: Captaining an Ashes side, not a mean feat
More By Feroz Khan
Champions League T20: Chennai Super Kings look firm favourite to lift title
The Ashes: Australian team needs to answer a few tough questions
India vs Zimbabwe 2013: Amit Mishra - Slogging his way up the national side
Manchester United should allow Wayne Rooney to leave!
2013 ICC Champions Trophy: India vs England - A battle of equals
Farewell Sir Alex Ferguson!
Luis Suarez is at it again!
India vs Australia: The joy of watching Test cricket live from the stands
South Africa’s summer of dominance
Hyderabad Test: What Australia need to do…
Australia in India: A litmus test for the new generation
Time for Shane Warne to `dial it down`
Andy Murray’s golden year
When Manchester saw red
Of Bertrand Gachot’s absence and Michael Schumacher’s arrival
India vs England: Alastair Cook - 22 and counting
Lance Armstrong: From Livestrong to Liestrong
F1 World Championship: The race is not over yet
ICC T20 World Cup 2012: Team Profile- Bangladesh
U-19 World Champions: Lost in transition
India vs New Zealand 2nd Test: How long will Raina be persisted with?
The No. 6 conundrum
US Open 2012: Will Murray finally end his Grand Slam duck?
India at London Olympics 2012: Heartbreaks
Lord’s will be lucky for us: Rahul Banerjee
Euro Cup 2012: 'Boring' Spain are champions yet again
Euro 2012: Time for Cristiano Ronaldo to crank it up a notch
Biggest flops of IPL 2012
IPL 2012 final: Trump cards for Chennai Super Kings
IPL 2012 final: Chennai Super Kings -- How strong is their bid for a third title?
Controversies in IPL
Top performers of IPL 2012 so far
IPL dream come true for Kevon Cooper
Will Ganguly-magic work for Pune Warriors?
Interesting season ahead for Formula One 2012
Give Dhoni the freedom he wants
Dhoni and Cook on a road to redemption
From Independence to Ranji, Kanitkar has seen it all
Top contenders for the Australian Open 2012
Wish to see India qualify for the World Cup: Indian coach Savio
F1`s tryst with India and the `Raging Bull` Vettel`s 2011
ICC should practice what it preaches
The poor state of Indian hockey
Spot fixing: A disgrace for cricket
Formula One weekend: A class apart
What is wrong with hockey in India?
End of `City` road for Carlos Tevez
ICC Test Championship
ICC Test Championship
Tour Diaries: What really happened after India’s Test Defeat
No plans to drop charges against Khobragade: US
Indian merchant ship captain Sunil James reaches India
Mind your langauge, Congress tells AAP
more videos >>
Lieutenant Governor Najeeb Jung recommends President`s rule in Delhi
Delhi Congress chief JP Aggarwal resigns
more videos >>
News from e-generator.com
Thank for your comment. Your comment will be seen by our moderator..!