Ordinance on anti-rape: Enough for women’s safety?
Zeenews
       English        
 Follow Me on Pinterest Google Plus Ditto RSS Mail to us Mail to us
Sunday, May 19, 2013 
Search
Blogs

Ordinance on anti-rape: Enough for women’s safety?

Last Updated: Wednesday, February 06, 2013, 22:59
Views 2569 Comments 11  
Sushi's Musings
a
The President of India Pranab Mukherjee signed an Ordinance on sexual crime against women on 03 February 2013 just two days after the Cabinet recommended changes in the anti-rape law to improve safety for women which also gave approval to death penalty for rapists in some cases.

A giant step was taken in a short span of time. On December 16, 2012 a heinous crime was committed on the streets of Delhi. A young innocent girl was brutally gang-raped, beaten and tortured to the utmost level of barbarism before being thrown off a moving bus by a group of blood thirsty assailants.

The entire country was shaken by such a cruel act. The nation rose on its feet and thronged the streets in support of the 23-year-old girl. She finally embraced death after putting up a brave fight. But her death did not go in vain and was also not the end of the story. Rather it added fuel to the already accelerated anger of the entire nation demanding tough laws and harsher punishments for rapists.

The government took notice of the people’s fury and the need for change in the existing law for rape and sexual crimes against women.

Being brought against the backdrop of the Delhi gang-rape incident, the Ordinance entails changes in the criminal
law by amending Indian Penal Code (IPC), Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) and the Evidence Act.

According to the new Ordinance an accused in a rape case will be awarded death penalty if the victim dies or goes into coma. Here the Cabinet has gone beyond the recommendations of Justice JS Verma committee to strengthen the anti -rape law in India. The Ordinance has also enhanced punishment against offences like stalking, voyeurism, acid attacks, tonsuring, disrobing, stripping, indecent gestures like words and inappropriate touch. It also gives a victim under the age of 18 the option of not appearing before the accused. The path-breaking Ordinance is expected to see light of the day in form of a bill in the first half of the Budget session. The law minister Ashwani Kumar has remarked - “We believe that this is a progressive piece of legislation and is consistent with felt sensitivities of the nation in the aftermath of outrageous gang-rape in Delhi.”

Although government has gone ahead with the entire exercise with a sense of urgency, many women’s groups are not still satisfied with the anti-rape Ordinance. They are upset over government’s refusal to recognise marital rape as an offense, failure to hold command officers accountable for rapes by their subordinates and omission of rapes by Armed forces as a category. Maybe they have a point in saying that if the entire Ordinance was not going to affect the punishment being given to the culprits of Delhi gang-rape then the government could have taken some more time to discuss the matter to give it more teeth.

However, the journey of women’s safety and the right to live without fear and on an equal footing with men is a long one and many more things need to be changed in the country, specially the perspective of the society towards women.

For example in a recent incident, after online threats and hate messages, the only all-girls rock band of J&K ‘Praagaash’ faced the ire of the Grand Mufti of Kashmir, Bashir-ud-din Farooqi who issued a fatwa against the three girls, saying that they should stop what they were doing. In what sounded preposterous he advised them to imbibe moral values.

Hardline faction of Hurriyat Conference also expressed surprise over Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah`s support for the rock band, saying there is no room to nourish western culture and immoral values in the state.

Hurriyat spokesman Ayaz Akbar said - “As a matter of fact no noble family will allow their girls to choose their profession as a dancer so as to be a mere thing of pleasure for strangers.”

The girls came into glare of publicity after their sparkling performance at the yearly ‘Battle of Bands’ competition. Two days after their performance, they received online threats and abusive comments. The girls were ultimately forced to quit and tragically the beautiful voices from the valley were silenced, maybe forever. The band ‘Pragaash’ means ‘from darkness to light’ but now it seems that girls have gone into the darkness due to the patriarchal mentality of the society.

Is this how the women of this country are supposed to feel safe? We are in the 21st century but a lot of people still have not been able to digest the fact that women are now on the same footing as men. Communities like the ‘Khap’ have become self-imposing authorities who have no respect for the women folk. According to them women are just to be bounded in the four walls of the house. Such mindsets also give rise to atrocities and crimes against women. It appears that in a large part of our country a women’s progress and achievements hurt a man’s ego, in turn forcing them to commit inhuman acts against females.

Let us hope the women feel safe with the introduction of a new anti-rape law and let us also hope that it acts as a deterrent for criminals and rapists. But it needs to be reiterated that forming a law alone is not enough. A certain amount of sensitivity towards the female sex is what lacking in a large part of our society, which needs to be cultivated. The executive, the police and the judiciary also needs to change its mind set and come together and work for a larger cause. Swift action by the police and judicial bodies is the need of the hour.
(The views expressed by the author are personal)
mohan - chennai
3) you cant say, men`s attitude should change and ignore this crime and avoid steps to prevent this. the juvenile who was involved in this crime wouldnt have known about the punishments if he does such crime. so, making stringent punishment will not stop anything. give fair treatment to victims of such crime in rural areas as well. why did media make such a cry when a medical student is raped in delhi? every day women get raped and killed in rural areas. many a times, people ignore that becuase the victim is a dalit or lower caste. now when this impacts their likes, it pinches.. is this fair?
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
mohan - chennai
2) legalizing prostitution is something we should seriously think about. this will not only reduce the crime rate but also will empower the women involved in prostitution and get their share of money. we cannot continue to uphold tradition but in reality prostition exist in every city. as on date, major money goes to local politician, police and the intermediateries. if this is leagalize and a framework is provided for them to practice, sex workers will get major benefit and it will reduce women trafficking which is a major underworld business. this will divert those group from molesting general public.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
mohan - chennai
nothing will change with new law. i am not trying to be pessimestic, but realistic. i didnt mean to hurt any girl/woman, but hear me out. why do men get into such crime? there are multiple reasons. i will think of few and provide solution. 1) youngsters (unmarried) fall into sex attraction and use the unsecured environment we have in the soceity and commit this crime. having strict law is an after-crime justice. i am talking about prevention? we can ask girls/women to stay at home or always have men escort which puts liberty of women at risk. government should ensure a safe environment. this is possible only with reforms in police department. let there be women police who treat girls/women who give complaint about potential threat fairly. they approach of police should change. this is also an important suggestion given by verma`s report but no one noticed.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Mukesh Anand - Delhi
good observations. we need sensitisation about these laws so that be implemented by police and judicial officers in right spirit.
i am also looking forward to your musings on pocso act for protection of children from sexual offenses. carry on... cheers
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sanjay - Surat
implementation of law is more important, we could not get desire result till our police force not exhibit dedication, needless to say police reforms are intentionally kept on hold by our great politicians, this ordinance also comes due to tremendous pressure on government not by will, it`s true that lot of people in our society is not fair enough for women and discrimination exist but if our goverment determine to provide secure environment to women than khap, shriram sena or mullah can not prevent them.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
amit - ddn
dowry laws, ndps and sc harassment act have been widely misused, we have another set of harsh laws which can be misused. if conviction takes place in weeks time then we can not expect justice for innocent person. this only means reasonable opportunity of defense is denied to innocent person.
india may be having oldest living civilization, she may be having tajmahal symbol of love which was and still being copied by many husbands. india may be most considerate society, but we are governed by self criticizing people. these people are law makers and their voice is so strong, sharp and shrill they do not hear any dissent. from the roof tops we started shouting, we are dowry mongers, dishonest, corrupt and rapist. we ourselves are certifying us bad.
us did not change its gun law even after so many shoot outs. pakistan did not change its blasphamy laws. other countries have also not changed their laws on movement so quickly. then why should we change. during 90ies all the female prisons in panjab were occupied by inmates with charges of dowry. putting every one into jail did not stop the menace. then why these politicians are not hitting at root cause? we we commoners are guided by them? greed is root cause of dowry. and non availability of paid sex is one of the causes of sexual offence. europe and western world has permitted paid sex and they are not inferior to us in character. we should oppose to hastely introduced laws

Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Venky S Rao - Bad-Homburg, Germany
so long as the attitude of men towards women doesn`t change, i don`t think the situation would improve! may be that sounds a bit generalized but the fact i am referring to is the male chauvinism and egotism. as long as people like asaram bapu, fatwa mongering radical fundamentalists and khap panchayats are not contained, women’s plight in india would hardly improve. unfortunately women too have to change their attitude by resisting and fighting back against the unconditional subservience expected of them. i wonder how many mothers are really able to give courage and support to their daughters! anyways coming to the point, i agree when you say ``a giant step in such a short span`` but i am extremely pained by the fact that it had to come only after such a brutal incident and thousands of other equally brutal incidents in the past! i wonder why men need to be reminded that they would be punished if they committed such an act? talking of the new law, i think it’s also important to make provisions for punishing those who are caught in eve teasing and molestation, which i guess are two larger evils in our society that finally embolden morally corrupt men to commit this heinous act. that said, at least we have a law, which going forward must be suitably amended to make it more broad in scope and implementation
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
sivan - New delhi
we should kill you venky s rao. why take chances and wait to punish you till you commit any crime against women. kill you now will stop any possible crime against women altogether. what are you doing in germany? raping german women?
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Rohit Kumar - kolkata
by any ordinance on anti-rape we can not decrease the rate of rape bacause first we should change our mantality
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
C.Rao.Yellenki. - Nevada,u.s.
hang the women politicians who are in law making pocision which can set right law making system in india.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
sivan - new delhi
we should hang you to death if being born as a man.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Post your Comments

Name  
Place :  
Email :  
Comments :