Parliament: Limits of Protest
On Monday, December 13, the last day of the winter session, parliamentarians thought of paying floral tributes at a chosen spot alongside Parliament House to the intrepid men of the watch and ward staff who nine years ago this day laid down their lives fighting a vicious militants’ attack on the complex. Inside the two Houses, members later stood in silence.
Gratefulness and solemnity of the occasion lasted barely two minutes, however. Hardly had the members sat down and the two Houses called to order when the trouble ---by now a habit – erupted. Slogan-shouting began from the opposition benches, and many members, some of them with placards, trooped into the well of the House to block the proceedings as they had been doing everyday during the session.
The Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, Mr Hamid Ansari, noted somberly at the end of what had become a daily drill, that peace prevailed in the session only when obituaries were read. The Speaker of the Lok Sabha also expressed similar anxiety about the way Parliament proceedings were being disrupted.
A strange kind of sullen mood descended as the members came out into the lobbies and then moved to the Central Hall. There was, however, little evidence of guilt about what they were doing to Parliament.
If those who think that they have scored a great victory by not letting Parliament function even for a single day in the winter session ought to introspect on what they are trying to achieve. Disruption can be self-satisfying, possibly a good visual on the TV channels, but sober people among the opposition parties must know that such victories may at best turn out to be pyrrhic in nature and not worth their while for the effort.
Whatever, the seriousness of the issues, no political party, -- ruling or in the opposition --- will stand to gain if Parliament is wrecked from within. The way things are going there is a danger to Parliament and the form of democracy it has come to represent. Political parties themselves, whichever side of the House they sit, will themselves stand to lose. Who gains, if everyone loses?
No one can underestimate the seriousness of the issue of corruption and the 2G scam. They need to be fully probed and the guilty severely punished. The government owes it to the nation that it will do so at the earliest.
But by using the scam for making Parliament dysfunctional, the opposition, led by the BJP and AIADMK and joined by the CPM, is not serving the cause. Whatever they do outside protest in Parliament has its limits.
Parliament has provided for ways allowing the opposition to force the government to give all the information it wants on the 2G scam. The Public Accounts Committee, which is headed by a BJP leader Dr Murli Manohar Joshi, is already at work following the CAG’s report on the 2G licences. The scope of the PAC”s inquiry can be easily widened. And now we find senior BJP leaders faulting Dr Joshi for not going slow when the party is agitating for a Joint Parliamentary Committee.
Previous experiments with JPCs have not been fruitful. They consume time. May be the BJP wants to stretch the exercise for a couple of years to place the entire UPA government in the dock and whip up a pre-election campaign. To the BJP the process is perhaps more important than the outcome.
The Opposition could easily move a no-confidence motion in the Lok Sabha to challenge the government’s continuance in office on the 2G scam, but apparently it does not suit its political convenience.
The Supreme Court is also seized of the question, and so has been the CBI. As the CBI’s credibility has often been questioned its investigation of the 2G scam placed under the supervision by the Supreme Court as also the PAC’s probe, should have satisfied the Opposition.
How Parliament is being prevented from doing its duty to the people for whom it is meant will not help it retain the respect of the electors. It is the respect of the people which ultimately lends legitimacy to a constitutional institution.
As the Chairman, Mr Hamid Ansari, in his valedictory remarks noted with anguish that no discussion on a matter of public interest took place, no special mention about the problems of the people was made, and not a single question was allowed to be answered in the question hour, which makes the ministers more accountable.
In a way, Parliament’s authority flows from its power to sanction money to the government and monitor how it is spent. In the winter session it passed four Appropriation Bills sanctioning money worth thousands of crore of rupees amidst the ruckus and without a wee bit of scrutiny. This is a serious lapse on the part of Parliament as an institution and decidedly a disservice to the people.
We project our democracy as India’s unique selling proposition and disruptions in the past as also the stalemate in the winter session, , are not going to be a great advertisement for our brand of democracy.
Successful running of Parliament will require patience, tolerance of the opponents’ view, a give-and-take approach, readiness to look for a way-out of the serious situations that are natural to a vibrant democracy.
It would also require readiness on the part of the leaders of all parties to reach a consensus on issues and the working of the institutions vital for the survival of the country’s democratic dispensation. Parliament is certainly one of them. Let the leaders of the parties sit together and come to an agreement that whatever the seriousness of the issues that may come to the fore, they will not let Parliament become a casualty of politics.
(The writer, a senior journalist, is now a Member of Parliament)
comments powered by Disqus
- DNA: APJ Abdul Kalam's last journey, India bids a tearful adieu
- DNA : Justice delivered; India hangs 1993 Mumbai blasts convict Yakub Memon
- Exclusive interview with Usman Majid, MLA, J&K Congress
- Four Indians kidnapped in Libya; Islamic State hand suspected
- Parties should be united against terrorism, says Rajnath Singh
- Why did you choose Smriti Irani as HRD minister? Congress leader asks PM Narendra Modi
- Yakub Memon: The two men who lead police to 'House of Memons'
- Rajnath slams UPA for coining 'Hindu terrorists', Congress accuses BJP of playing politics on terror
- Watch video: The epic battle between 'Machli' tigress and a 14-foot-long crocodile!
- Cristiano Ronaldo great, but Lionel Messi is greatest: Xavi Hernandez