Vote bank politics! Really?
Zeenews
       English        
 Follow Me on Pinterest Google Plus Ditto RSS Mail to us Mail to us
Thursday, June 20, 2013 
Search
Blogs

Vote bank politics! Really?

Last Updated: Saturday, July 16, 2011, 13:43
Views 1298 Comments 19  
Common Man
a
Yet another serial blast and that too in Mumbai! Like every other time, the government announced compensations, police is suspecting the hand of LeT and other terror groups, media is speculating the hand of Indian Mujahideen amidst talks about the much hyped ‘spirit’ of Mumbai.

I mean isn’t it ironical to call the ‘lack of choice’ as their ‘spirit’?

The politics over the blast is in full flow, with government finding it difficult to defend itself and opposition leaving no stones unturned in highlighting government’s failure in controlling the law and order situation, calling it a ‘policy failure’ rather than an ‘intelligence failure’. That too, like every other time!

Amidst these oft repeated happenings, the opposition yet again attributed the blasts to weak anti-terror laws calling the repealing of POTA (Prevention of Terrorism Act) as an act of minority appeasement and vote bank politics.

Nothing new in that also, but if you thin
k about such attributions closely, it makes you feel disgusted about the way our political leaders think of the minorities, especially if you are the one belonging to the community.

My outburst is not unjustified. There is a deep-rooted sense of insult preceding this very public rebuttal of the charges against the minorities.

The first allegation is that the Congress repealed anti-terror POTA as an exercise of minority appeasement and vote bank politics. This, in itself is an insult to the patriotic minorities of this country.

The allegation suggests that an anti- terror law was repealed to appease the minorities as if they are the one who were affected by it. Isn’t it an allegation of being terrorists on the whole community? I am not a terrorist and I find it utterly disgusting and humiliating.

Moving on, the right wing often suggests that the ‘Madarsas’ are breeding grounds of terror. Isn’t it demeaning for a certain kind of educational institution to be branded as ‘terror school’. Generally people have no idea what these Madarsas teach, but since it is an Islamic educational institution, so it is easy to associate it with terror.

Madarsas are run with the contribution of the community where poor kids, often those who couldn’t afford a formal education go. I am not denying the fact that there might be some Madarsas promoting hardliner ideology, but not all.

The point is, rather than alleging that all Madarsas impart ‘terror teachings’, the government can bring them under its purview by constituting a Madarsa Board. This way they will also be eligible for government grants and also the allegations of being ‘terror school’ will be wiped off. But I am sure even this move, if it happens, will bring brick-bats from the right-wingers as another example of minority appeasement.

Coming back to the terror point, it is almost a ‘sin’ if anyone supports an alleged Islamic terrorist, as we saw in Batla House encounter when Digvijay Singh doubted the whole exercise on his Azamgarh visit. But when it comes to saffron terror, it is okay to say that since it’s a Congress government at the Centre so these are all false allegations. Point to notice- the Aseemanand confessions.

I am not saying that what Digvijay said was right or wrong, but the point is, if investigations are on then we must not form an opinion about an alleged ‘terrorist’, let alone a whole community. Also, an act of terror has no colour. Neither ‘Green’ nor ‘Saffron’.

Any act of terror and any loss of innocent life are equally condemnable and this should not be linked with any particular community.

And finally, saying that Congress is a ‘pro-minority’ party is nothing more than an insult to the sensibilities of the minorities.

If we count merely the historical facts, the Congress’ claim of being a minority friendly party stands exposed.

When idols of ‘Ram Lala’ were first placed inside the Babri Masjid premises, there was Congress government at the Centre with Pandit Jawahar Lal Nehru at the helm.

When the ‘Shilanyas’ of the Ram Mandir took place, again Congress was in power with Rajiv Gandhi as the PM.

When Babri Masjid was demolished by the Kar Sevaks, it was again a Congress government at the Centre with PV Narasimha Rao heading it.

The count doesn’t stop here. Be it Bhagalpur riots in 1989 or 1993 Bombay riots, it again the Congress government in the power. Yes, one of the exceptions is the 2002 post Godhra riots.

But India continues to be a secular country. Not because we have great leaders or efficient bureaucrats, but for one simple fact that the 80 percent populace of this country, ‘the Hindus’ are by and large secular people.

This is the reason why minorities in India still have all the liberties and opportunities. The significance of a secular majority community can easily be ascertained if you look at the condition of minorities in our neighbouring Pakistan, Bangladesh and even Sri Lanka.

So, as a member of the minority community, I expect everyone not to associate the minority community with the terrorists. A terrorist is just a terrorist. He doesn’t belong to any community, just like when a bomb explodes, it kills everyone irrespective of his or her religious beliefs.
(The views expressed by the author are personal)
BAPTY.S - CHENNAI
sad the present govt separates people under reservations,minorities, vote bank politics etc.under garb of secular all this is happening.only ``hindu country in the world with 100cr hindus.``left alone muslims are all good barring a few younger crowd wrongly instigated & bribed heavily to turn as terrorists. mr sandhu-pune congrats for starting facebook,people of india cannot depend on such politicians,we have to move forward in a homgenous way.we dont need politicians to preach to us.we need to elect the right people.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
SUBRATA - KOLKATA
the ruling party making pm as a shelter saying that `honestttt` ! they all are looting and more dangerous than the english and the muslim invadeors in india in the history !! the shameless pm (should not be a punjabi)making attempt that he does not any thing when the saree of daupradi - `india` is torned up !! shame to him !!
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Nagesh Shetty - Mumbai
hi,
your edit is well intentioned, but i feel you deliberately are not looking at the minority appeasement angle.
first lets begin with the place of attack. its zaveri bazar for the third time and bhendi bazaar not once.. now is there a message you fail to see.
pota is a draconian law not needed to tackle terrorism, but then why do we need a communal violence bill? the same political party feels that one is unnecessary whereas the other is?
skewed priorities and reeks of minority appeasement.
its a sin to visit a framed islamic terrorist? no ofcourse not. then he must show the same courtesy and visit a framed hindu one. why give the benefit of doubt to only the muslim one. is this not appeasement?

look closely my friend. its not too difficult to find. unless you deliberatly turn a blind eye.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Rutwij - Mumbai
great observation. i liked you article. even i feel disgusted about the political games that played over human life an sentiments. i completely agree with you that at times minority groups are treated humiliatingly. as a matter of fact i agree on almost all points except the one about madarsas. may be all of them are not hardliners, but their teachings dont exactly help the people mix with mainstream population. there are many boards in india for people to learn from. if madarsas are formed by the people to help poor who cant learn, then they could help those people by forming schools affiliated to one of the many mainstream boards. madarsas create a rift between those who learn there and the mainstream population.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Basant - Rourkela
dear dr. das.I am sorry to say that instead of giving courage you are harashing the noble thinking. good personility should ve constructive mind instead of destructive. but here, very bad thinking which comes in lazy minds.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Anoop - USA
a lot of people are mentioning the name of aseemanand in diffrent comments. i have a legal background. i can guarantee that not a single charge against aseemanand will hold up in the court of law. this is all 3rd degree in the ps. police were investigating other people for those same blasts for few years. suddenly when corruption cases started coming out against congress, every terrorist attach in india was done by hindu outfits. i am surprised dogvijay singh have not blamed 26/11 on rss yet.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Albert - London
i have a simple question to all muslims.in islam its been taught that those who don`t follow islam are kafirs and they are not humans.there is nothing like this in any other religious teachings.how can a muslim live in peace with followers of other religion unless they don`t accept followers of other religions as humans and not as kafirs.why only muslims all around the world have problems with jews,christians,hindus,sikhs,buddhists ?
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Shri - nag
well when we go back to history, we find that ram mandir was demolished by babar to make babri masjid, did hindus turned to terrorist by then? auranzeb demolished number of hindu establishments in mathura, did hindus turned towards terrorism? 1947 hindus also lost thier loved one as did the other side, did hindus turned to terrorism then? or else throwing kashmiri hindus out of thier home made them to turn terrorist. neither of it. as far as godhra is concerned, who burnt the whole train carrying kar sevaks, and was it not a enough reason to spark riots? the fact is that in a country where 80% of population is hindus (as you say) ifa hindu is going to bomb a place who will die the most? hindus, also terrorist are not from our own land they are operating from cross borders,, n rather calling them islamic terrorist, we should n as we previously did is cross border terrorism,,, its a sad fact that few people are misguided on the name of religion. its congress who said islamic terror and now trying completely to zero down to the hindus,, who are only found in bharat and nowhere in the world. you can find a country be islamic officially or christian officially, but bot a single country in officially hindu in the world,,, this shows the secularist face of hindus. we condemn any action of brutality,,, but there still few people who love it. its only india which have a islamic population which is growth oriented and patriotic and we respect them and are proud of them... but criminal minded people can be from any background and we should only term them as criminals,,, its politics which is communal but not the common man of india...!! jai hind jai bharat..!!!
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Wakeel Ahmad - Gaya
good idea,mr.sharique.muslims and madarsas are in limelight only for the wrong reason.at myriads times biased reporting in the media vis- a- vis muslims are always on the card.even as media is considered to be fourth estate of the democracy,it has lost its ethics.it is the media which can make any people saint or sinner over night.propaganda is of course a good tool of media which acts as catalysis- either increases rate of reaction or decreases it witout being involved.the writer has rebutted the opinion or perception of those ill- informed or those who are out to tarnish the image of mdarsas and muslims.has any madarsa ever been found guilty of being indulged in to such subversive or hate mongering activities across the country? a big no.some cheap or yellow journalims has taken birth in to our country only to create schizm and hostility among people of the country.those who receive education in the madarsa are the poorest of poor family,who somehow making both ends meet,cannot be dubbed or called terrorists.not only this fake encounter,concocted report is yet another tell-tale which more often than not make all muslims pass sleepless night.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Prajod - Kannur,Kerala
hi friend.nice to read articles from common people and not some right or left leaning ``intellectuals``.but i have to tell a fact here.while u say that all madrassas are not breeding hatred isnt it true that many of the ``teachers`` there actually teaches hatred to the kids?? i am fror kerala where 25% population is muslim.of late there is an increase in terrorists from kerala, something which wasnt there before.also the muslims in kerala are the most educated,well off and safest in india. yet why is there an increase of terrorists??? one of the reason i feel is influx of wahhabbi ideas from arab nations especially saudi which is a reason why kerala muslims are becoming more arabised and getting rid of the unique malayali muslim identity. now many people do say that terrorism amoung indian muslims is a result of babri masjid,gujrat riots etc. but isnt that a kind of excuse?????? i mean before babri masjid there was partition,exodus of kashmiri hindus...but there wasnt any hindu terrorism untill recently.wont it be absurd to say that hindus are into terrorism coz of the above said reasons?? i personally feel that people dont become terrorist just one fine day. they are encouraged by some section. if the communities choose to not report these individuals fearing backlash..im sorry nothing can change...lol a long lecture huh?????but i want my voice to be heard too :d ,)
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
hari - usa
who is the majority in bosnia,chechnya ,kashmir ,albania ,malaysia .
history tells us muslims in any country in majority does not or will not allow others to live peacefully.this is not me saying ,it is history.either they want independence or throw other religious people out of their country .why middle east does not allow other religions .why other religions allow muslims to pray ?so i don`t need to say answers .you can get answers by your self .
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Premal - Ahmedabad
why muslims can not gather and raise their voice against terrorism. because it is hard but true that many muslims(not all) support fanaticism of islam. and even islam religion supports terrorism directly or indirectly because islam has loopholes. terrorists can misinterpret islam and can make quran a weapon against innocent people.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Shireen - Bodh Gaya
@ albert: kafirs are those who think there are more than one god or no god. kafirs in islam are the culprits of allah. only he will punish them on the day of judgement. kafirs are not culprits of muslims, so a muslim can`t kill or punish a kafir. we are allowed an eye for an eye, it means we can`t take a limb or anything for an eye. killing innocents of any religion is forbidden in islam. hope u got the answer for your query.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Shireen - Bodh Gaya
insult has been used many times in the article. there is nothing wrong if we have a pota like thing in our country. govenment is expected to take strong action if innocent working people are getting killed like animals. i don`t know what babar or aurangzeb or aseemanand or modi did. what i know is we are not living in monarchy but in democracy, whoever does wrong must get punished. we don`t need a temple or a mosque, i am fed up of people asking for money everyday to build a mosque in their locality. we need schools, a safer environment, progress, even if it comes with a cost of some innocent people dying due to heart attack during interrogation. and aren`t we muslims taught that our fate has been written beforehand by allah. why are we afraid then that a pota can harm us?
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Prashant Prabhakar - Delhi
well said...
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sandhu - Pune
we are starting a facebook campaign to stop giving special status to minorities and the government should treat everyone equally.why do they have special obc quota for muslims and why discount for going to mecca.its time to treat everyone equal.help us to make this campaign success and we bring a revolution like tunisia and egypt.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Pradeep - New York
first of all, all the benefits that only minorities get in india should be removed - like discounts for going to mecca, etc. govt. should treat everybody equal. in the same breath, let me also tell that no incidence like babri masjid demolition or godra train burning or post train burning should be allowed. a sense of equality should be brought in. even muslims and christians in india were hindus before. you converted. so, you should accept it and not relate yourselves to other muslims around the world. indians should behave like indians - including muslims. we will accept you warmly if you do these.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
debashis bhattacharya - uae
excellent observation. i want to add in every class there are people who are bad element. bad police hindu and muslim. educated bad element muslim and hindu. there fore our main enemy is corruption. we all must unite now under one umbrella that is under anna hazare campane. this is the occation to finish corruption in india. we need to do big sacrifise. look at egypt they changed a person like mubarak due to public anger. but we should not stop now , the protest must be all over india. let us find out the terror element ourselfs. dont wait for police. only issue is proverty . due to this this terrorest can do such act repeatedly. due to proverty this crook politicians get vote in every election and reach parliament which is suppose to give us justise and protection. we need to change this mess and clean our social system . the whole nation must perticipate with anna for the fight against corruption.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
BRIJ - NEWYORK
terrorism is terrorism proactive or reactive,islamic or any other,always govt use the words for their own convenience.some how in india we govt of no action regardless,action only in promoting these elements than using them and their dirty income for elections only.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Arup - Guwahati
please teach the above lines to digvijay singh and rahul gandhi, because at one point when islamic terrorist groups hands like in the case of afzal guru and ajmal kasab are found in the attack they will say ``terrorism has no religion``. but when swami assemanand, sadhvi pragya was caught they said it is right wing (hindu) terrorism. neither hindu or rss or bjp is saying terrorism has religion but these two guys are saying so. but pakistan, bangladesh, afghanistan (all islamic country) sponsors terrorism and u cannot deny that.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Post your Comments

Name  
Place :  
Email :  
Comments :