SC refuses to stay spectrum auction
New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Sunday refused to interfere with the order of telecom tribunal dismissing the pleas of Bharti Airtel, Vodafone, Loop and Idea for a stay on spectrum auction which is starting tomorrow and extension of their licenses by another 10 years.
However, in an extraordinary urgent hearing on Sunday, a bench comprising justices A R Dave and S A Bobde admitted the appeals filed by Airtel and Vodafone challenging the January 31 order of the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT).
"The appeal is admitted and hearing is expedited," the bench said after the Centre opposed the appeals saying "any observation from you (apex court) can scare away other bidders and can take away the vibrancy of the spectrum auction".
Senior advocates Mukul Rohatgi and Abhishekh Singhvi, appearing for Airtel and Vodafone respectively, contended that the existing licences for the spectrum to them should be extended instead of putting them on auction.
While Rohatgi submitted that the apex court should ask the telecom department not to declare the result of the auction till it decides the appeals, Singhvi contended that Vodafone was having the licence for 20 years since 1994, so it has the right over the spectrum and the licence should be extended for another 10 years.
However, the bench observed that "it does not mean that you should have a monopoly".
Telecom companies made arguments in the apex court identical to those before the tribunal saying they have made huge investments ranging into several crores of rupees and hence had the legitimate expectation for the extension.
Any such denial was "illegal and unreasonable," they said adding that it would also result in the discontinuance of service to its subscribers.
The TDSAT had rejected their plea saying "the petitioners have failed to establish their right for extension in terms of the relevant provisions in their licenses, the matter ends there".
The tribunal had held that it was satisfied with the reason based on which the Department of Telecom (DoT) had denied extension and had asked telcom companies to participate in the spectrum auction starting February 3.
"Denial of extension of the licenses to the petitioners is based on good reasons as envisaged under clause 4.1 of the UAS license and the relevant provision in the CMTS license and the petitioners can claim no right for extension of their licenses under the aforesaid provisions of their licenses," TDSAT had said in its order.
It had further observed that "any extension of the expiring licenses is bound to undermine the implementation of the policy and that is justification enough and sufficient for the Government to decline the extension for the licenses".
Vodafone and Bharti Airtel are participating in the coming auction and are short-listed as eligible bidders.
Their licenses are expiring by November end this year on completion of the 20-year period as per license conditions.
However, their participation is without prejudice to their rights and contentions in the petitions pending before TDSAT as per the order passed December 20, 2013.
Loop, which operates in the Mumbai circle, has not participated in the auction process as it was waiting for the outcome of this petition.
Idea's seven licences would expire in December 2015.
Vodafone's licence is expiring for Delhi, Mumbai and Kolkata circles while for Airtel it is Delhi and Mumbai circles.
Airtel, Vodafone and Loop's spectrum belong to 900 MHz band and a relatively very small portion to 1800 MHz band.
However, tribunal was not impressed with it and had said: "We would only like to observe that the holder of a UAS license has no right of allocation of spectrum beyond 6.2 MHz.
"As against that, all the petitioners have been holding, for years, spectrum far in excess of the contracted quantum and that too in the most premium band and that on payment of entry fee at rates fixed in 2001.
"Hence, we are not impressed by this submission".
The telcos have also contended that their mobile services may be discontinued and may result in a complete break-down of the mobile telephone service in the country and would leave hundreds of millions of their subscribers in the lurch.
However, the government had said that the consumer can change their operator under the Mobile Number Portability (MNP).
As per TRAI's regulations, a subscriber can port to other operators within seven working days.
"We accept the averments made in the affidavit in the hope and trust that DoT has fully gone into the technological aspects of the transitional period and arrangements are in place to ensure that there is no dislocation in the mobile telephone service in the country," the tribunal had said.