Thursday, December 05, 2013
Thursday, December 05, 2013
Deal or no deal, debt drama is not going away
US debt crisis
US debt deal
Last Updated: Tuesday, August 02, 2011, 00:34
Are you tired of all the stories on Europe’s financial crisis and American politicians’ endless bickering about debt and deficits? Are you tired of weekends of hectic negotiations as policymakers rush to cobble together some agreement before markets open? If you are, you are not the only one.
Millions of people, including stressed-out policymakers on both sides of the Atlantic, wish to put these issues behind them. Unfortunately, despite many announcements, they are unable to do so decisively, and for good reason.
So we better understand why, if we want to minimize the risk of collateral damage and unintended consequences.
To do so, you need only remember one rather clumsy phrase: “safe de-levering” (also known to some as “safe de-leveraging”), or the lack thereof. Consider please each word, starting with the second one.
De-levering refers to the rehabilitation of balance sheets that have gotten over-indebted to such an extent that they are unsustainable going forward. The contributing causes are usually numerous and many years in the making.
In Europe, three peripheral countries face immediate and significant de-levering pressures. Greece and Portugal are two of them. They had too many years of irresponsible government spending, inadequate taxation, weak public administration, and insufficient economic growth. The third, Ireland, was fiscally responsible but made the big mistake of using what was a relatively healthy public balance sheet to assume the massive losses of its irresponsible banks.
These three countries now face a buyers’ strike. Lenders have been resisting the renewal of their credit lines and, needless to say, have no appetite whatsoever to provide incremental funding. No wonder interest rates have soared and financing has dried up, other than official bailouts from neighboring countries, the European Central Banks and the International Monetary Fund.
The result is not just a liquidity crisis; but also a solvency one. With government gross debt burdens ranging from 100 percent of GDP in Portugal to 156 percent in Greece, these countries are now embarked on an unpleasant, forced de-levering process.
America’s case is different. Yes, it has a high budget deficit (over 10 percent of GDP) and has experienced a dramatic increase in its debt-to-GDP ratio since the global financial crisis. Yes, the fiscal outlook gets cloudier as a result of a structurally weak budget. But unlike peripheral Europe, it is nowhere near an immediate liquidity crisis.
America’s creditors are more than willing to fund the country at historically low interest rates. Rather, it is political squabbles that have dramatically brought forward medium-term fiscal challenges, and have done so through the use and misuse of the debt ceiling, an arcane but, as we have all found out, a rather lethal legislative weapon.
We should all accept that Europe and America — the former for fundamental reasons and the latter for self-inflicted ones — are now in a de-levering cycle whose consequences will be with us for many years.
The actual process of de-levering can play out rather quickly. Indeed, too fast a de-levering can be catastrophic in terms of its impact on growth, employment and poverty. So you can be sure that policymakers will do their utmost to deliver a safe, gradual process.
The best way to do so is through high economic growth. This maintains living standards and generates incremental income to pay off debt, thus providing an orderly path to medium-term debt sustainability. Unfortunately, this option is not available today to either Europe or the US as both are stuck in what PIMCO has been describing for over two years now as the bumpy journey to a new normal.
Other than some short bursts, Europe and America are unable to sustain the sort of economic recovery that would make a meaningful dent in their debt dynamics. They will remain in this regrettable situation until policymakers become more serious about a comprehensive and coordinated set of measures to remove structural impediments to sustained economic activity — including steps to improve the functioning of the housing and labor markets, better worker retooling and retraining, enhanced education systems, even more bank lending, improved productive infrastructure, etc.
If they are unable to grow out of their debt problems, countries have four other options. Two of these are also available to us as individuals: we can default, and let restructuring lower our debt burdens, albeit in a rather disorderly fashion; or we can implement austerity, spending less in order to generate cash to pay off our debt.
Because countries control the printing presses and write regulations — things that the rest of us do not have or cannot do — they have two additional alternatives. They can try to inflate their way out of the debt, or they can reduce it through years of “financial repression,” that is, paying millions of depositors and creditors much less than they deserve in order to divert funding to debt payments.
Judging from what we have seen so far, governments are opting for different mixes.
The three peripheral European governments are imposing harsh austerity on their populations — remember the riots in Greece? — and also benefiting from the willingness of their European neighbors to financially repress their citizens in order to provide additional official funding. At least one (Greece) is having to go further by also partially restructuring its debt.
America is talking about austerity, including this past weekend’s compromise fiscal framework, but using financial repression. So far, this has taken the form of the Federal Reserve maintaining interest rates at extremely low levels for an exceptionally long period of time — so much so that savers and creditors are paid interest rates that are below inflation, and in some cases, well below inflation.
This will not suffice. Look for America to intensify financial repression through regulations that forces banks and other regulated entities to hold low yielding government securities. Also, it will attempt to generate unanticipated inflation. Ultimately, it will be forced into more painful austerity involving both spending and tax measures.
The de-levering pressures will be with us for years, and governments will mix and match from the menu of options. Accordingly, periodic debt dramas and crises will not go away any time soon. Debt is simply too high and there isn’t enough economic growth to painlessly de-lever. Each response that governments decide to adopt has different implications for us, as savers, investors, debtors, home owners, and business people (the topic of a future piece).
Unfortunately, none of us have the ability to fully insulate ourselves from the collateral damage and unintended consequences. The best we can do is to understand the process, including what governments will do. In this way, we can try to minimize, though never eliminate, the adverse impact of de-levering.
(The views expressed by the author are personal)
India is high on a liquid diet!
Positioning Brand India
House Republicans offer to lift debt ceiling through December
US debt crisis can cause global financial turmoil: IMF
US CEOs optimistic after meeting with Obama on nation’s debt crisis
Rise in US exports brightens outlook for economy
comments powered by Disqus.
comments powered by
Most Popular in Exclusive
Apple iPhone 5S review: Bigger and better than before!
New HRA exemption rule: How it will affect you
Shoma Chaudhury Messes Up Batting for God Father Tejpal
My only encounter with the legend - Sachin Tendulkar
Triumph motorcycles ride into India: Models and price
Delhi Assembly Elections 2013: And the crown goes to…
State in Inertia: Nitish’s 8 Years in Bihar
Ajmal Kasab’s hanging could not act as a deterrent for Pakistan
Campa Cola Compound society: The tale of a resident
More By Miscellaneous
Manchester United are back on track!
Shoma Chaudhury Messes Up Batting for God Father Tejpal
The bhartiya mahila “vote” bank!
Helicopters for VVIPs: India must act decisively
Is this Arsene Wenger’s chance to finally end Arsenal’s trophy drought?
In David Moyes’ Defence…
Truth be told, India is a minnow for Twitter
India, US - A false partnership
The Lion of Nairobi
Criminalising Poverty - An Equal Law?
Live from Kenya: `If I die, you take care of the kids`
Live from Kenya: London, Mumbai, Nairobi - what is the link?
Importance of pursuing recreational activities in senior years
Agni V and the South Asian Balance of Power
CLT20 needs to find its relevance and build a fan base like the UEFA Champions League
Yuvraj Singh`s century highlights his immense run-hunger and much-improved fitness
Helicopters for VVIPs - a Highly Convoluted Deal
Viswanathan Anand, Sachin Tendulkar and Leander Paes: Three legends without parallel
Whose Kashmir is it anyway?
Ranji: Prince of a small state, king of a great game
Eoin Morgan: Explosive, exciting and innovative
The spurious case against Sonia Gandhi
Where prices rise and the value of women declines
The actual cost of the Food Security Bill is the dignity of the rich
BCCI vs CSA: The implications of the standoff
Will you return to your career after 10 yrs` gap?
Will shift our focus to middle class: Jurgen Klanert
Fitness is important for fast-bowling and I am working on it: Ishwar Pandey
Sachin Tendulkar`s 200th Test: A testimonial match could have saved the BCCI a lot of trouble
Sachin Tendulkar`s 200th Test: The West Indies series could tarnish the last days of a fantastic career
Arjuna Award is evidence of Virat Kohli’s character
India A’s success is a stepping stone towards building a confident national team
Sourav Ganguly should have named VVS Laxman instead of himself in his all-time best India Test XI
Captain Cook has been astute, unfazed and often brilliant
Don Bradman scores a second-ball duck in his farewell Test innings
The legendary Alfred Hitchcock and the 1938 Ashes series in England
Seven women redefine independence
My wife was sure I was the Fake IPL Player: Murali Kartik
Rahul Dravid and Paddy Upton’s tips have helped me develop confidence: Sachin Baby
Safe in 21st Century India? A Tale of Four Cities
Acid attacks - The caustic truth
Chauvinism at Centre Court and beyond
Serena Williams, a symbol of “Victory and Courage”
Here is why Holi is celebrated
Market not delighted with Chidambaram`s eighth Budget
‘Beyond the tipping point, climate change consequences will be difficult’
`Cities should be hospitable and resilient`
Delhi Police tries some reforms to assure women safety
M&M VP talks on symbiosis of business mgmt
‘No country wants foreign aid in perpetuity’
Asaram`s son Narayan Sai may undergo potency test in sexual assault case
Hit-and-run case: Mumbai court orders fresh trial against Salman Khan
Mumbai: Husband kills wife, hides body parts in fridge
more videos >>
Top 10 News in 2 Mins @8pm
Gunfire on between 3 Lashkar terrorists, security forces in J&K`s Handwara
more videos >>
News from e-generator.com
Thank for your comment. Your comment will be seen by our moderator..!