Growth casualty of RBI`s efforts to combat inflation in 2011

Last Updated: Saturday, December 31, 2011 - 12:33

Mumbai: The RBI`s steely resolve to combat inflation by repeatedly hiking key interest rates despite opposition from industry and other quarters yielded results toward the end of 2011, with food inflation slipping below 1 percent and general inflation showing signs of moderation.

Thanks to the initiative taken by the central bank during the year, inflation would cease to be a major concern in the
New Year, though the government and RBI will have to deal with slowing economic and industrial growth.

The RBI raised the repo rate, at which commercial banks borrow funds from the Reserve Bank, seven times during the
year, by 2.25 percentage points to 8.5 percent.

However, it was a different matter that the efforts of RBI Governor D Subbarao to tame inflation did not soften inflation in the immediate run and instead pulled down the economic growth rate and industrial production.

Another issue that troubled the RBI was the declining value of the rupee against the US dollar.

The Governor reiterated the stated policy of non- intervention in forex markets to correct currency imbalances and looked the other way as the rupee fell to historic lows.

The same set of challenges will remain for the Governor in the new year in the back drop of moderating growth, weakening macro-economic fundamentals and a declining rupee.

However, going forward, if one were to go by the tone of the last monetary policy statement on December 16, it seems that Subbarao in the new year will focus on promoting growth, which has become the biggest casualty of his tight monetary stance in 2011.

In order to tame inflation, Subbarao opted to take only baby steps, ignoring the advice that he should "go for the kill".

Though food inflation declined from 16-17 percent in January to less than 1 percent in December, headline inflation remained near the double digit mark. Moderation was, however, witnessed toward the close of 2011 and there is a good possibility of it declining further in the new year.

Improvement in the price situation will make the RBI more receptive to the advice of India Inc. The central bank will
definitely contemplate reducing interest rates at its next policy review due on January 24.

Till the second quarter review (when he raised the repo rate by 25 basis points to 8.50 percent), Subbarao maintained
a hawkish stance, saying, "Low growth is better than high inflation and that unless growth decelerates to below trend (a word he often used during the year to reflect 8-plus percent growth), there will not be any change in the monetary stance."

With inflation under control, Subbarao, who got a two-year extension one month before his first term came to an
end, will have to focus on arresting the fall in growth and the decline in the value of the rupee.

During the course of the year, RBI was criticised for being directionless and its failure to come out with out-of- the-box solutions.

The worst remarks came from Chief Economic Advisor Kaushik Basu, who described Subbarao`s monetary policy stance
as "text-bookish" and devoid of any forward-looking stance.

For RBI, however, there was little option but to continue the tight money policy initiated in March 2010, to contain
inflation.

From January through October, Subbarao raised interest rates seven times to 8.50 percent, even at the cost of ignoring the advise of the technical advisory committee. A dovish stance, however, did manifest in December.

Significantly, RBI left both the bank rate (cash reserve ratio) and statutory liquidity ratio unchanged at 6 percent and 24 percent, respectively.

Today, the bank`s effective lending rate varies from 12 percent to 18 per cent, with the rates for unsecured loans even touching 20 per cent in the cases of some lenders, indicating effective monetary transmission.

As regards inflation, it declined to 9.11 percent in November after it had crossed 10 percent in September. It was
9.78 percent in October.

The saving grace, however, is the food price index, which slipped to a six-year low of 0.42 percent for the week ended
December 17 from 15.48 percent a year ago.

The inflation problem was aggravated by rising crude and commodity prices on one hand and increasing government
borrowings and a widening deficit on the other. The falling rupee, too, added to the worries of the government.

Growth, unfortunately, became the biggest casualty during the year.

While factory output barely managed to remain in the green zone in September, it nosedived to minus 5.1 percent in
October. Last week, the Governor admitted that the GDP will not clip above 7.6 percent this fiscal.

According to government data, economic growth in the first quarter of the current fiscal (April-June 2011-12)
slowed to 7.7 percent. It further slipped to 6.9 percent in the second quarter.

Despite the many challenges on the monetary management front, the RBI did not lose sight of the common man.

In fact, 2011 was one of best years for retail banking customers as the RBI unveiled a slew of radical reforms by
forcing bankers to give customers more by way of higher interest rates on savings deposits.

The Reserve Bank forced the banks to reduce charges on various services like pre-payment of loans and closure of accounts.

On May 3, RBI hiked interest rate on savings deposits by 0.50 percentage points to 4 percent. The masterstroke,
however, came on October 25, when the RBI freed the last bastion of the regulated interest rate regime -- savings bank interest rates.

Following the announcement, several smaller banks raised savings bank interest rates. The larger ones, however, have
yet to respond, but what is certain is that consumers will benefit as a result of the initiative.

In another customer-friendly measure, in October, RBI asked bankers to abolish pre-payment penalties on home loans,
a direction many lenders implemented. Banks charge 4-6 percent for pre-payment of loans.

After a long wait, RBI issued guidelines for new banking licences on August 29, allowing large corporates to enter the
sector.

The guidelines, however, remain on paper, as Parliament did not amend two crucial laws -- the Banking Regulation Act
and the RBI Act -- necessary to implement the proposal. The government had initially proposed to issue new banking
licences in 2004. The process is likely to take more time.

The biggest casualty of 2011 was the rupee, which declined sharply, especially toward the close of the year.

Although the year began with a stable rupee and a positive outlook, things took a turn for the worst after global agency Standard and Poor`s downgraded US sovereign debt on August 5.

The rupee started falling against the US dollar after the downgrade and the euro zone crisis only added fuel to the fire.

Moreover, foreign investment inflows of USD 922 million in April-October were a trickle in comparison to the USD 27 billion achieved a year ago.

In the backdrop of these developments, the rupee kept plunging to hit an all-time low of Rs 54.30 to the dollar on December 15.

The irony is that RBI largely remained on the sidelines for a long time, with the Mint Road mandarins vociferously
defending their inaction, attributing the rupee`s slide to the worsening global crisis. "Let`s not lose sight of the fact
that there is a global dynamic here," said RBI Deputy Governor Subir Gokarn, not once but many times.

The rupee, however, did stablise after the central bank took action to prevent speculation in the currency market and
opened the gates wider for inflow of foreign funds.

PTI



First Published: Saturday, December 31, 2011 - 12:33

comments powered by Disqus