Nirbhaya's mother writes open letter to former Karnataka top cop who commented on her physique

Lashing out at HT Sangliana, Asha Devi writes that he did not just disrespect her but also Nirbhaya by advising women to surrender in face of physical threats in order to survive.

Nirbhaya's mother writes open letter to former Karnataka top cop who commented on her physique
Former Karnataka ex-DGP HT Sangliana on the extreme left (Pic courtesy: @D_Roopa_IPS)

New Delhi: Angered by the highly inappropriate remarks directed at her by former Karnataka top cop HT Sangliana during a function, Asha Devi - mother of Nirbhaya - wrote an open letter on Monday admonishing him for not just his personal comment but his supposed advice to women facing physical threats.

Sangliana had stoked controversy when he had said Nirbhaya's mother had a 'good physique' and added that he couldn't imagine how beautiful Nirbhaya would have been. Facing scathing criticism, he later clariefied that his comment was taken out of context. Asha Devi though has sought to put matters in context through her open letter, which is as follows.

When you commented on my physique, you did not think twice about the inappropriateness of it – in fact, you thought nothing of further associating it with the beauty of my daughter Jyoti, who is no longer alive, who died such a brutal death.

But after making these abominable comments, your advice to young girls is what crossed all limits, I feel. You said that if someone overpowers you, then what a girl should do in that moment is surrender, because at least that way, she will live.

Not only did you disrespect the fight that my daughter put up in those monstrous moments, you also displayed the sick, patriarchal attitudes of our society at large. My daughter’s rapists too had expressed a similar thought – how they could not tolerate the fact that she was fighting back. It is indeed a matter of great shame that the thinking of the so-called caretakers of society such as yourself and the thinking of the criminals, seem to me, to be exactly the same.

You are perpetuating the same regressive attitudes we’ve been living with all our lives as women, telling girls again and again, that they must remain weak, that no matter what, they must keep making compromises with the ugly situations they find themselves in. And when someone forces himself on you, you must make your peace with it, so that he deigns to spare you, your life.

In the end, I would also like to ask you if the same advice should be given to our Indian soldiers too? Shall we say to them, those who protect our borders day and night, that the next time you are attacked, you must throw up your arms, and surrender? At least our soldiers’ lives will be saved.

(This open letter was first published on Khabar Lahariya)

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. You can find out more by clicking this link

Close