Mullaperiyar dam safe, say SC panel experts
Zeenews
       English        
Tuesday, May 29, 2012 
Search
Follwo us on: Facebook Follwo us on: Twiter RSS Mail to us Mail to us Mail to us
Kerala

Mullaperiyar dam safe, say SC panel experts

Last Updated: Wednesday, January 04, 2012, 11:54
Comments 7  
Mullaperiyar dam safe, say SC panel experts Zeenews Bureau

New Delhi: An expert panel has after thorough evaluation found the Mullaperiyar and Idukki dams to be safe, reports said on Tuesday.

Two technical experts on the Supreme Court-appointed Empowered Committee submitted their report on the safety of the disputed structure to the panel yesterday and said the fears about the dams’ safety were unfounded.

The experts said in the report that the recent earthquakes in the Idukki district did not have any impact on the Mullaperiyar and Idukki dams.

CD Thatte, former secretary to the Union Ministry of Water Resources, and DK Mehta, retired chief engineer, Central Water Commission, had carried out inspections at all the dams in and around the Mullaperiyar catchment area to look for any damage to structures in the wake of the recent tremors.

The inspection followed a plea by the Kerala government amid fears that the earthquakes had taken a toll on the structure of the 116-year-old Mullaperiyar dam.

The report was submitted yesterday to the Committee’s head, former Chief Justice AS Anand. The other members of the Committee include retired SC judges KT Thomas and AR Lakshmanan.

The Committee yesterday evaluated the report and concluded the objections raised by Kerala do not hold ground and ruled the Mullaperiyar dam to be safe.

Kerala had pleaded that the water level should be reduced from the present level of 136 ft to 120 ft to make the structure safe.

The Committee is learnt to have taken the view that since the water level was decided by the Supreme Court, it could not take a decision to the contrary.

The Committee will again meet on January 24 and 25 to finalise the report which will then be submitted before the Supreme Court in February.

The other party to the dispute, Tamil Nadu has been contending that the dam was safe and can withstand pressure.

First Published: Wednesday, January 04, 2012, 11:53

Comments

krishnasamy - trichy
very pitty to see mr.alex-idukki anyway thanks to mr.alex to say tn people intelligent as iit..
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
jaidev - delhi
safety of the people living at that location ,and people who would be affected are the ones who should decide whether they need new dam.who will be responsible if something really happens and people lose their life. i think the experts whoever is commenting against the building of a new dam is not staying in the area which will be affected in case the catastrophe happens. it is very easy to give ideas and comments if you are not going to be affected by the results. Now all over the world every body is safety concious,companies are spending so much money for safety, EVERY BODY TALKS SAFETY SAFETY then why in this case so much fuss going on. take an example: kerala was my house. this dam is my neighbours BIG water tank and it is located in such a way that it may collapse and kill everybody at my home.now what do u expect me to do.BEG to the neighbour. if i care for my family i will take steps to protect them and not wait for peoples opinion.ITS MY HOUSE MY PLACE AND ESPECIALLY MY LOVED ONES
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Alex - Idukki
If the dam is as good as new why they want to strengthen the dam?. Are Pandies smarter than IIT Delhi/IIT Roorky and many other independent scientists/institutes which supported kerala`s claim that the dam is weak.Other than Mr.Thatte who supports tamilnadu? .Two weeks ago Mr.P.chidambaram told that the committe report is going to be in favour of Tamilnadu. Is he an astrologer?.This means that he influenced the technical committee.This was evident from thatte`s visit to the dam(They even insulted a lady KL Engr). They .bribed Prof.Roy and Kodandapani(AG ) to come against Kerala to weaken the case. Pandies are the most cunning/corrupted creatures on earth.Kerala has the right to reject this biased report. When kerala constructs a dam using its money and soil,KL should control it.Why should somebody else control our resources.And there is no nonsense of ``999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999`` Yr agreement.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
CHERAN - BANGALORE
Better consult any mental doctor
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
PANDI - VEERAPANDI
If u think that u have right to build new dam, then why the hell are u mallus in chennai, coimbatore and all over over tamilnadu. You first ask ur people to leave from my state and then build ur dam wherever u want
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Mahadevan - Pandi
paranoid. For your kind info there is a Pandi built earthen dam near Tiruchy standing and working for the past two millenniums. If you do not want to believe about something kindly understand if the dam is broken then it is one day problem for Kerala, But it will be an eternal opportunity lost for Tamil Nadu especially yours hateful pandies. Do not get jerked be objective. in your crowing too
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Mallu Batter - Chennai
Mallus are spineless creatures.Want to talk ,talk and talk and live and earn thier livlihood some where else.They cannot stand anybody progressing.These are the proofs of their so called intelligence.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
muthu - namakkal
Better you consult a psychiatrist. You are an absolute paranoid personality. If you think that you can do what ever you want in your soil, then why there is indian constiuency. just think rationaly. If other states says that train carrying malayalis should not enter our territory, then malayalis will beg for food. there is no job there.. begging every where for job. If you dont believe anyone then why we shoud believe IIT ROORKEE which was paid by kerala to do investigation. but other committes are appointed by Supreme court. You know the millions of malayalis (30 lakhs) living in tamilnadu using trillions of gallons of water per year from tamilnadu soil. Are you bringing water in a bucket from kerala when u come to tamilnadu. dont talk rubbish. COnsult psychaitrist.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
D.RAJAGOPAL - CHENNAI
It`s as if Tamilnadu and Kerala are two different countries like India and PAakistan.A total shame for we Indians to fight in the name of w(h)ate(v)r issue.we have to think logically for a unified approach.whichever is the best solution as per the experts to be accepted by all.Infact we have to think universally as everyone is a God bestowed gift to the world.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Rajan - Changanassery
EC is impartial and technical. Kerala and TN should abide by the decision the SC takes. After all, it is the apex body. If TN or Kerala violates SC order, then by law, that government should be held in contempt of court order and be duly dissolved. There is no higher appeal.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Alex - Idukki
Nobody doubts supreme court.Especialy justice A .S anand who is famous for his humanitarian considerations( he was the chairman of HR commission).But it is the credibility of the technical committe members that is being questioned .I believe Justice Anand will consider all aspects and give prime priority for the life of people.Everything else is secondary.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
muthuraman - sattur
technically safe, but politically unsafe
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Praveen - India
None can be believed or trusted on this dam issue. Everybody seems to have hidden agendas, both TN and Kerala! The reality is never brought to light by media, even if they know the truths! Such a pity state of affairs!
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

View all Comments   

Post your Comments

Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Most liked Comments

Alex - Idukki
If the dam is as good as new why they want to strengthen the dam?. Are Pandies smarter than IIT Delhi/IIT Roorky and many other independent scientists/institutes which supported kerala`s claim that the dam is weak.Other than Mr.Thatte who supports tamilnadu? .Two weeks ago Mr.P.chidambaram told that the committe report is going to be in favour of Tamilnadu. Is he an astrologer?.This means that he influenced the technical committee.This was evident from thatte`s visit to the dam(They even insulted a lady KL Engr). They .bribed Prof.Roy and Kodandapani(AG ) to come against Kerala to weaken the case. Pandies are the most cunning/corrupted creatures on earth.Kerala has the right to reject this biased report. When kerala constructs a dam using its money and soil,KL should control it.Why should somebody else control our resources.And there is no nonsense of ``999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999`` Yr agreement.



muthuraman - sattur
technically safe, but politically unsafe



D.RAJAGOPAL - CHENNAI
It`s as if Tamilnadu and Kerala are two different countries like India and PAakistan.A total shame for we Indians to fight in the name of w(h)ate(v)r issue.we have to think logically for a unified approach.whichever is the best solution as per the experts to be accepted by all.Infact we have to think universally as everyone is a God bestowed gift to the world.