Signed 2G report to avoid Vinod Rai’s ‘wrath’: Ex- CAG official RP Singh
Zeenews
       English        
 Follow Me on Pinterest Google Plus Ditto RSS Mail to us Mail to us
Saturday, May 18, 2013 
Search
Nation

Signed 2G report to avoid Vinod Rai’s ‘wrath’: Ex- CAG official RP Singh

Last Updated: Sunday, November 25, 2012, 14:31     A- A A+
Comments 9
New Delhi: Former CAG official R P Singh, who has stirred a controversy, has rejected the allegations that the Congress has put him up to defend the government on the audit report on 2G spectrum allocation which had estimated the presumptive loss of Rs 1.76 lakh crore.

"I don't think it has any substance," he told Karan Thapar in CNN-IBN's Devil's Advocate when asked about the charge that he has been put up by the Congress.

Singh said he has no connection with the UPA government nor he was having any interaction with it.

"Whatever I have said is not politically motivated and (my conscience) is very clear on that account," he added.

Singh said he would have earned the "wrath" of his then boss Vinod Rai if he had not signed the final audit report on 2G spectrum which pegged presumptive loss of the airwaves auction at Rs 1.76 lakh crore.

"I knew the content of the report... There was a written order. I had to comply. There is no scope for refusing. You would earn wrath," he said.

Singh said there "is no tradition of disagreeing or opposing orders of CAG in my department".

He said that he had deleted certain figures on presumptive loss from the draft report but they were later incorporated in the final report and he knew about it.

Singh also said that he was misquoted by a newspaper that PAC Chairman Murli Manohar Joshi sought to influence the CAG report on 2G whilst the report was being prepared.

"This claim has been made in newspaper report. I do remember that there is documentary statement where it is stated a member of PAC had asked to calculate loses using a particular formula. I cannot confirm the name, but I can confirm the content," Singh added.

He specifically said that he has been misquoted in the news report.

"I said a member of PAC... It has misquoted me," he said. The former official said that on one evening of July 2011, Deputy CAG Rekha Gupta summoned him and told him that that report needs to be delivered at 10 am to the Finance Secretary and Telecom Secretary.

"I came back to my office at around 7.30 pm or 8 pm. I ordered my team to prepare a prescribed format along with the set of complete supporting key documents... I signed it that very day at around 8 pm," Singh recollected.

On why he chose to speak on the issue after 14 months of his retirement, Singh said he was asked to comment on the presumptive loss figure in the CAG report following the just concluded spectrum auction which fetched "much much less" amount in comparison to the presumptive loss figures.

PTI

For Zee News’s Updates, follow us on Twitter , Facebook, Google+, Pinterest

First Published: Sunday, November 25, 2012, 11:56

Post your Comments

Name:
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Comments

G. Kannapiran - Chennai
Some IAS and IPS officers develop an intimacy and affiliation to a political party. When that party comes to power they are rewarded with good posts for their loyalty also ensuring covetous career after retirement in statutory or constitutional bodies – Service Commission, Election Commission, information Commission and Planning Commission, etc. we may correlate incumbents in Tamil Nadu and the centre. for this. Such a back door appointment of Vinod Rai as CAG ignoring expert-IA&AS has perhaps, back fired, as he shifted loyalty. R.P. Singh brings to lime light the facts with dates and events and incidents of CAG favouring opposition compelling subordinates too, for a report towards eruption of 2G-scam. Selection procedures for constitutional authority CAG need revision. The CAG could be multi-membered (with one expert IA&AS retired) as there is always a possibility of fallibility of human judgment and checks and balances are necessary. If one member is fallible, the others can correct
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Santosh - Hyderabad
RP Singh is indirectly saying that he is facing the wrath of Congress for not abusing Upright and honest Vinod Rai.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Ramaswamy.S.V. - BANGALORE
I am sure that after the CONGRESS gets wiped out , ie in 2014, all congress party fellows including the kinds of DIGGI will start saying , `` I WAS FORCED BY HIGH COMMAND TO SAY SO `` Dont give any respect to the statements of these characters , who are actually spine less worms .
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Devendra pal - Hyderabad
MUJHE LAGTA HAI KI RP SINGH KA BHI ACCOUNT SWISS BANK MEIN KHUL GAYA HAI TABHI RETIRE HONE KE EK SAL BAD IMANDARI JAGI HAI IS AADMI KE STATEMNET SE SAF LAGTA HAI KI YE BIK CHUKA HAI
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
roshan - ahmedabad
Jo inasaan apne imaan aur karm se jyada apni kursi ko pasand karta ho vo insaan par kaise bharosa kiya jaaye? aur sabse badi baat ye hai ki retire hone tak khamosh rehta hai aur retirement ke 1 saal baad achanak usmei imandaari kahaan se nikal aayi aur vo bhi ye kehte hue ki usne dabaav mei aakar sign ki thhi agar vo agree nahi thhaa is report se to usko saaf inkaar kardena thha ya kisi senior person ko inform kar dena thhaa koi kaise dabaav mein sign kar sakta hai kya kisi ne unke bivi bachhoo ko kidnap kiya thhaa? ya usei maarne ki dhamki di thhi?
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
bjp hi hi - patna
RPSingh had put his point very clear and all observations made are in record. bravo. beurocracy works exact like this and nothing wrong. now sri rai CAG should clarify why absurd fig of loss was included
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
A S Bagga - Udaipur
Mr R P Singh was influenced by congress, the only party to inculcate corruption in India. A coward person is Mr R P Singh, we saluate DG land of Haryana who withstand all the politicle pressures & trapped illegal deals by Robber Wadra. By his efforts scam by Wadra & DLF was exposed & he has no fear of his services, really he was a true person. & Mr R P Singh a ``Mohra of Congress party assisted in justifying their lies`` but congress will not succeed in imposing lies even if it repeated thousand times.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
r.v.ramani - 8977410119
R.P.Singh has done a great injustice to the post he has handled all these years. If he is so spineless to face the pressure he could as well come out of his service and work as liasion to some corporates. It is also to be investigated as to how sincerely he handled situations in his career right from the initial stage.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
R.L. Bangera - Mangalore
It appears that Mr. RP Singh is instigated by Congress and telling lies before the people of this country. If investigated, truth will come out with one more slap on the face of congress.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

View all Comments   

Most liked Comments

bjp hi hi - patna
RPSingh had put his point very clear and all observations made are in record. bravo. beurocracy works exact like this and nothing wrong. now sri rai CAG should clarify why absurd fig of loss was included



r.v.ramani - 8977410119
R.P.Singh has done a great injustice to the post he has handled all these years. If he is so spineless to face the pressure he could as well come out of his service and work as liasion to some corporates. It is also to be investigated as to how sincerely he handled situations in his career right from the initial stage.



roshan - ahmedabad
Jo inasaan apne imaan aur karm se jyada apni kursi ko pasand karta ho vo insaan par kaise bharosa kiya jaaye? aur sabse badi baat ye hai ki retire hone tak khamosh rehta hai aur retirement ke 1 saal baad achanak usmei imandaari kahaan se nikal aayi aur vo bhi ye kehte hue ki usne dabaav mei aakar sign ki thhi agar vo agree nahi thhaa is report se to usko saaf inkaar kardena thha ya kisi senior person ko inform kar dena thhaa koi kaise dabaav mein sign kar sakta hai kya kisi ne unke bivi bachhoo ko kidnap kiya thhaa? ya usei maarne ki dhamki di thhi?



Top News



latest

Delhi

1984 riots case: Court to hear Sajjan Kumar`s plea today


Read More »