Age row: Army chief slammed Defence Min
Zeenews
       English        
 Follow Me on Pinterest Google Plus Ditto RSS Mail to us Mail to us
Friday, May 24, 2013 
Search
Nation

Age row: Army chief slammed Defence Min

Last Updated: Thursday, October 06, 2011, 16:30     A- A A+
Comments 4
New Delhi: On the basis of media reports, Army Chief General V K Singh had levelled the allegation that the Defence Ministry "lacked objectivity" and was "biased" on his age issue, the Defence Ministry has said.

"It is little odd that Chief of Army Staff has chosen to come to a conclusion that the reference made by the Defence Ministry to Attorney General (AG) lacked objectivity, was biased and designed to procure a particular opinion," the Defence Secretary had said in a note sent to Defence Minister A K Antony in June this year.

The then Defence Secretary Pradeep Kumar had made these remarks on the petition submitted by Army Chief to Defence Minister A K Antony on his age issue after the AG had opined that May 10, 1950 should only be considered as his date of birth.

He said the Army Chief had arrived at this conclusion without even going through the reference made to the AG "merely on the basis of the reports appearing in the media and calls made to him by some journalists."

The Defence Secretary said the Army Chief has given his "misgivings" about the first reference made by the Defence Ministry to the AG to seek opinion on his date of birth issue.

"In order to address his concerns about his point of view not being projected properly, it would be best if his petition (submitted to Defence Minister on May 25) along with enclosures is forwarded to the Law Ministry and the AG again," Kumar said in the Ministry noting accessed through RTI.

In the review opinion also, the AG had stuck to his previous view that Gen Singh's date of birth could not be changed to May 10, 1951. If 1951 was accepted, the army chief would have got an extra ten months in office.

PTI

For Zee News’s Updates, follow us on Twitter , Facebook, Google+, Pinterest

First Published: Thursday, October 06, 2011, 16:30

Post your Comments

Name:
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Comments

Hav/PA SB SINGH - Pune
what a nonsence comments made by Wg Cdr. I think he is thinking from foreign mind of indian hart. sit
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Rommel - Germany
@Wg.Cdr.(Rtd).S.Sugunakumar Please get a life. I really pity your mind and character. It just you who know from day 2 General VK Singh was creating a problem. You called General Singh as irresponsible, immature and inappropriate wow that’s what seems like you got in your entire service & so you retired as a Wg Cdr and General Singh is still serving. Your words are more attached towards the MOD India rather than having a Military Corps de spirit. This dynamic General fought war for the Republic of India and is an expert commando from US ARMY RANGER School. I am quite sure he is more qualified than you in both Military and civil courses, still you have said he has no bearing & dignity. I pity your mind once again, really I feel sorry for you how come the Indian Air Force made you as an Officer when you did not posses any officer like quality till date though. Regarding the harm on the strategical plans please be open what he has done and don’t fire hilter schilter. Last but not the least your baseless comment on removing him is like you have lost your mind as in a batch of 500 to 600 officers only one becomes a general with at least forty years of service. You can’t get a more refined and well deserved person after thee so many long years. It is a shame to call you as a Wg.Cdr for every citizen of this country, so please us MR S.Sugunakumar. Rommel
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Paramdev Singh - London
I would say that Anthony and his masters want Singh out, as he had opposed involvement of Army in curbing Naxals and also refused to play their game during Anna`s fast. All this is now ploy to see him off as early as possible.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Wg.Cdr.(Rtd).S.Sugunakumar - Chicago
All of us knew from day 2 after his assuming this most responsible job in this nation ,as to how irresponsible this individual was. With every passing day he used to be making some or other comments that were irresponsible,immature and inappropriate, leading to most of us wondering as to how the Defence Ministry in its wisdom could have made such a terrible choice. This individual had no bearing,dignity or professional demeanor to go with the poistion he was holding. V.K Singh simply loved talking to the media out of turn irrespective of the consequences or the harm he was causing to the strategical plans & needs of the Nation. Had V.K.Singh accepted with outward grace the decision og the Defence Ministry on his cooked up date of birth atleast a semblance of dignity could have saved for him. The immature person that he is ,instead continued to rail & rant against the Govt apart from his open political comments is also guilty of creating disaffection in his troopsfor the Govt.In fact V.K.Singh needs to be removed and tried for mutious behaviour & conduct unbecoming of a serving Military Officer.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

View all Comments   

Most liked Comments

Wg.Cdr.(Rtd).S.Sugunakumar - Chicago
All of us knew from day 2 after his assuming this most responsible job in this nation ,as to how irresponsible this individual was. With every passing day he used to be making some or other comments that were irresponsible,immature and inappropriate, leading to most of us wondering as to how the Defence Ministry in its wisdom could have made such a terrible choice. This individual had no bearing,dignity or professional demeanor to go with the poistion he was holding. V.K Singh simply loved talking to the media out of turn irrespective of the consequences or the harm he was causing to the strategical plans & needs of the Nation. Had V.K.Singh accepted with outward grace the decision og the Defence Ministry on his cooked up date of birth atleast a semblance of dignity could have saved for him. The immature person that he is ,instead continued to rail & rant against the Govt apart from his open political comments is also guilty of creating disaffection in his troopsfor the Govt.In fact V.K.Singh needs to be removed and tried for mutious behaviour & conduct unbecoming of a serving Military Officer.



Rommel - Germany
@Wg.Cdr.(Rtd).S.Sugunakumar Please get a life. I really pity your mind and character. It just you who know from day 2 General VK Singh was creating a problem. You called General Singh as irresponsible, immature and inappropriate wow that’s what seems like you got in your entire service & so you retired as a Wg Cdr and General Singh is still serving. Your words are more attached towards the MOD India rather than having a Military Corps de spirit. This dynamic General fought war for the Republic of India and is an expert commando from US ARMY RANGER School. I am quite sure he is more qualified than you in both Military and civil courses, still you have said he has no bearing & dignity. I pity your mind once again, really I feel sorry for you how come the Indian Air Force made you as an Officer when you did not posses any officer like quality till date though. Regarding the harm on the strategical plans please be open what he has done and don’t fire hilter schilter. Last but not the least your baseless comment on removing him is like you have lost your mind as in a batch of 500 to 600 officers only one becomes a general with at least forty years of service. You can’t get a more refined and well deserved person after thee so many long years. It is a shame to call you as a Wg.Cdr for every citizen of this country, so please us MR S.Sugunakumar. Rommel



Top News



latest