Did Christ come to India to study Vedas?
Zeenews
       English        
Tuesday, May 29, 2012 
Search
Follwo us on: Facebook Follwo us on: Twiter RSS Mail to us Mail to us Mail to us
Nation

Did Christ come to India to study Vedas?

Last Updated: Friday, December 25, 2009, 12:48
Comments 10  
Did Christ come to India to study Vedas? New Delhi: The spotlight is back on Jesus Christ and his India connection as the world celebrates Christmas Friday. Some historians believe he spent 17 years of early life - from the age of 13 to 30 - in India learning Buddhism and the Vedas.

"There are references that Christ's family (parents) settled in Nazareth, but the next time he appeared in Nazareth, Jesus was 30. He was said to have been growing in wisdom and stature in the missing years," British film producer Kent Walwin told IANS.

Here to receive the Dayawati Modi Award for arts, culture and education in 2009, Walwin's latest project, "Young Jesus: The Missing Years", will explore early years of the messiah, which are not described in the Gospels.

According to Walwin, his movie is "on the Apostolic Gospels, which says Jesus was last seen in West Asia when he was 13-14 years old".

The first part of the movie will be based on Gospels and the second part of the movie will be "pure conjecture based on archival material", the filmmaker said.

There are several references to the India connection.

In 1894, a Russian doctor, Nicolas Notovitch, published a book called the "The Unknown Life of Christ" based on his extensive journeys in Afghanistan, India and Tibet.

During one of his journeys, he visited Leh, the capital of Ladakh and spent some time at the Buddhist monastery of Hemis when he broke his leg.

At the monastery, he was shown two large yellowed volumes of a document in Tibetan language, "The Life of Saint Issa". Jesus was referred to as Issa - or the son of god - by the Vedic scholars who tutored him in the sacred texts.

Notovitch noted down 200 verses from the document at the back of his journal which he kept during his travels. The document later created a storm in the West.

Monks at the monastery of Hemis, located 40 km outside Leh atop a hill, corroborate to the legend of Christ in India.

"Jesus is said to have visited our land and Kashmir to study Buddhism. He was inspired by the laws and wisdom of Buddha," a senior lama of the Hemis monastery told IANS. The head of the Drukpa Buddhist sect, Gwalyang Drukpa, who heads the Hemis monastery, also believes in the legend.

Swami Abhedananda, a Bengali spiritual scholar and seer, had journeyed to the Himalayas to investigate the "legend of Christ visiting India". His travelogue, a book titled "Kashmir O Tibetti", tells of a visit to the Hemis monastery in Ladakh. It includes a Bengali translation of 224 verses of the "Issa legend" which Notovitch copied.

In 1952, another Russian, Nicholas Roerich, a philosopher and a scientist, visited Hemis and recorded the legend. According to Roerich, "Jesus passed his time in several ancient cities of India such as Benares or Varanasi".

"Everyone loved him because Issa dwelt in peace with the Vaishyas and Shudras whom he instructed and helped," Roerich said in his account.

Christ's teachings in the ancient holy cities of Jagannath (Puri), Benares (in Uttar Pradesh) and Rajagriha (in Bihar) earned him the wrath of the Brahmins, forcing him to flee to the Himalayas after six years, historians and authors say. Christ, say archival documents, spent another six years studying Buddhism in the Himalayas.

German scholar Holger Kersten's book, "Jesus Lived in India", also tells the story of the early years of Jesus Christ in India.

"The lad arrives in a region of the Sindh (along the river Indus) in the company of merchants. He settled among the Aryans with the intention of perfecting himself and learning from the laws of the great Buddha. He travelled extensively through the land of the five rivers (Punjab), stayed briefly with the Jains before proceeding to Jagannath," Kersten says in his book.

An English version of an Urdu treatise written by the founder of the Islamic Ahmaddiya movement, Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (1835-1908), also tells of a "second visit by Christ to the subcontinent" after his "reported escape from the Cross".

Christ visited Afghanistan, "where he met the Jews" who had settled there to escape the tyranny of the Jewish emperor Nebuchadnezzar and then came to the Kashmir Valley, where he lived for many years.

IANS

First Published: Friday, December 25, 2009, 12:48

Comments

frez - india
dont talk rubbish ! I have a information to who agree that jesus came to india and study veda. That is jesus is also god. By him everything in this universe created.So are you telling that a god need teaching and help from humans ?
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Prranjal Shrivastav - Bhopal
yr comment frez, reflects that u`ve got a lot to learn.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Om - Pune
Why such big cry if JC came to India? Some ppl here wrote that it`s attempt of Hindus which is quite funny to read as report explicitly mentions names of Rashian & European scolars who have suggested this theory. It`s sad to see that in India ppl are not tolarant enoght to read new theaories. And that`s the reason movies like Da Vinci Code get banned in Punjab & other Indian states where christans are less than 2% & run without any harm in Europe & America where 90% belongs christanity. I think it`s time for us to learn from westerners. See history from third persons view & don`t put emmotions. History is not Bollywood drama. And other non christanes (Hindus & Muslims) should learn from this & should start to visit our roots. No harm in that. Finding truth will not make you `Kafir` or `Asur`.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
RAJAGOPALAN SUBRAMANIAN - CHENNAI
the posting shows arrogance. no one can redicule other religious faith and reports duly authenticated with transcripts. even if you dis agree instead of using slang rubbish reply, question with your own denial with proper documentation. if you believe vitgin mary -no one has questioned because it is faith. faith is beyond scientific
scruitiny, like you believe so and so is your father because you mother told you so. did you make an attempt to verify.many theories of darwin are proved wrong. there are more correction on einsteins theories. let us learn to respect every religious faith traditions, cultural heritage
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Indian - India
See the BBC documentry `` missing years of Jesus ``. He is Buried in Srinagar ( Khanyar Mohalla ) according to Jewish tradition. There are two persons buried in that place,at lower level Jesus and above him a Muslim Mulla. Lost tribe of people of Jewish faith lived Kashmir to escape persecution in their own country ``Holy land``.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
benny -
Where do you think Jesus was for 15 years?

If you are interested in history like the other writer`s are , you should read the books and come to a conclusion. The books are supposed to open your mind to new facts as they become available through research.

I hope you would watch the movie. It does not make any difference to a Hindu where Jesus lived but it does to a Christian. The research is done by Eurpeans becauase they are interested in history. Books are supposed to open the mind and close it. Why do you think the Churches have no answer if you ask them where was Jesus when he was 14 ? Wandering in the desert for 15 years?
Benny
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Raj - India
Who cares if JC came to India or if he studied Buddhism/Hinduism? Hinduism existed even long before JC and it will continue to exist for ever. Like the article itself says, it`s all wild guesses, just like JC himself is. The rich churches will ``make you dissapear`` if you say something against the beliefs unlike Hinduism where anyone can say any crap and roam freely.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
S. Mohabir - Canada
Did Christ come to India to study Vedas?

The claim that Christ came to India cannot go unchallenged. The consensus of the overwhelming majority of critical scholars today find no proof for the historicity of Jesus Christ. The so-called historians who grasp at straws to claim proof of the historicity of Jesus are to be found in the Christian religion – not independent scholars. The oft-cited Testimonium Flavianum, ``Testimony of Flavius`` and refers to Antiquities 18.3.3 §63-64, has been debunked as an interpolation by a Christian. I will refer the reader to the following for an introduction to the historicity of Jesus:


http://www.ebonmusings.org/atheism/camel2.html#himcalled

If Christ did not exist, how can he come to India? The stories, the books written etc are merely hearsay and were not subject to the rigors of historical proof. The Issa legend is just that, a legend! And even if this Issa is not a legendary figure, there can be no connection with a non-historical Jesus Christ.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
chanakya50 - PATNA`
It can make a good movie by hollywood which can create a storm in tea cup.Jesus was known as issa masiih in india since time immemorial.Jesus may have visited India as India was the only country which was full of culture and sosn of god like buddha nd jaina had born.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
ksd - India
Again Hindu`s claiming over another religion..LOL.....what a shamless people......dont hve any good ethics of their own......except sati system nd caste system..so trying to get good values from other relions in their own........LOL
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Prranjal Shrivastav - bhopal
why not move away & live with yr own then? won`t they except u? the problem is there is no other place in this worls where u can swear on a majority & then live without fear. try yr words in Arabia or Iran & then we`ll see authenticity of yr eithics & culture. until then just shut up!
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
guru - delhi
IANS has also started doing sponsored stories...what a pity....its like everybody would be happy the day they see the end of vedic religion like the greek an egyptian civilisations...on one hand the story says jesus was thaught vedas by brahmins on the other it says he used to live with shudras....plz dont contradict yourself while writing a paid story...leave alone being neutral
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

View all Comments   

Post your Comments

Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Most liked Comments

frez - india
dont talk rubbish ! I have a information to who agree that jesus came to india and study veda. That is jesus is also god. By him everything in this universe created.So are you telling that a god need teaching and help from humans ?



Om - Pune
Why such big cry if JC came to India? Some ppl here wrote that it`s attempt of Hindus which is quite funny to read as report explicitly mentions names of Rashian & European scolars who have suggested this theory. It`s sad to see that in India ppl are not tolarant enoght to read new theaories. And that`s the reason movies like Da Vinci Code get banned in Punjab & other Indian states where christans are less than 2% & run without any harm in Europe & America where 90% belongs christanity. I think it`s time for us to learn from westerners. See history from third persons view & don`t put emmotions. History is not Bollywood drama. And other non christanes (Hindus & Muslims) should learn from this & should start to visit our roots. No harm in that. Finding truth will not make you `Kafir` or `Asur`.



Indian - India
See the BBC documentry `` missing years of Jesus ``. He is Buried in Srinagar ( Khanyar Mohalla ) according to Jewish tradition. There are two persons buried in that place,at lower level Jesus and above him a Muslim Mulla. Lost tribe of people of Jewish faith lived Kashmir to escape persecution in their own country ``Holy land``.