Estranged wife can live in husband`s house: SC
Zeenews
       English        
Tuesday, May 29, 2012 
Search
Follwo us on: Facebook Follwo us on: Twiter RSS Mail to us Mail to us Mail to us
Nation

Estranged wife can live in husband's house: SC

Last Updated: Sunday, February 12, 2012, 11:29
Comments 11  
New Delhi: An estranged wife has a right to stay in her husband's house and is entitled to maintenance from him under the Domestic Violence Act even if the estrangement had occurred prior to the enactment of the law, the Supreme Court has ruled.

A bench of Justices Altamas Kabir and J Chelameshwar passed the ruling while dealing with a matrimonial dispute of a couple who are senior citizens of the capital.

The apex court concurred with the findings of the Delhi High Court that provisions of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, (PWD) can be invoked by a woman or other victims even if the alleged violence was perpetrated prior to the enactment.

"In our view, the Delhi High Court has also rightly held that even if a wife, who had shared a household in the past, but was no longer doing so when the Act came into force, would still be entitled to the protection of the PWD Act, 2005," Justice Kabir writing the order said.

VD Bhanot and Savita Bhanot, who were married on August 23, 1980, chose to live separately from July 2005 due to certain differences.

The apex court further said that the husband shall provide a suitable portion of his residence to the wife for his living together with all necessary amenities to make her stay habitable.

"The said portion of the premises will be properly furnished according to the choice of the respondent to enable her live in dignity in the shared household."

On November 29, 2006, Savita filed a petition filed a petition before the magistrate under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.

PTI

First Published: Sunday, February 12, 2012, 11:29

Comments

Megha - Mumbai
wro9ng decision!!!!!!!!!, if the woman had suffered DV in her husbands house, y dos she want to take risk to live there again. physically it shud not be advised because DV can be repeated again. if the woman looses her life, then whose responsibility will it be, even if the culprit is sentenced to jail, still one life is lost? apart from that mentally, the woman needs to make a clean break from her past abusive relationship because since she has gone to court a reconcilliation with her husband is not possible and divorce is inevitable. so why torture u r self with all the bad memories associated with the husband`s house. she wud be better off living in another home, where she can form ogg memories relevant to a better future.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Payal Gagneja - Delhi
Not Agree dear with ur comments. As after marriage, women is having the full right to stay in her matrimonial home. why alwaz women leaves the house. that such house is also belongs to the women. why anybody leaves her/ his own house. the relation are meant for togetherness not to break the relations. Husband - wife relation is just like all other blood relations so we have always try to maintain the relation & try to make the other person a Good Human Being. with the true efforts we will change the other person & continue with the same relationship. No person is by birth a wrong person the circumstances or atmosphere in which he is in makes a person bad or good. I myself was thrown out by my husband after almost 1 and half year of my marriage. As my husband is mis lead by his friends & influnced by his friends. His friends provide him so many drugs so that he can not understand the actual things. Today even i am fighting for my rights & try to make him a good human being & responsible husband. From the day of my marriage i love my husband unconditionally, i am trying & confident that one day he will realize the Facts & start loving me, caring me. we should always try to maintain the relationship.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Suraleen Sarkar - Bangalore
Women should understand that how they are spoiling their own life after leaving their husband........they will not understand this immediately by today but they will realized this in later stage.......by simply filing false cases they are doing this.......these are all not make it join the two life just destroying the Indian family welfare. Men are now losing the trust from women after this kind of incidents.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
nisha - Pune
I don`t agree with suraleen`s comment,,,,by willniglr no one girl leave husband`s house when her life will become hell bez of inlaws and husband ,,, then last option is left with her to leave that house and save her own life ther are many incidents happen when girl`s life completely ruined by inlaws and husband`s ,,, and now gilr`s are more educted they can earn,,, by instead of tolerating mental torture,,, abusive language twards girl and her family ,,,no one girl will tolerate all this thing,,,, I know by leaving husband`s house is not a good thing for a married women ,... when husband`s huouse is not safe for a women ,,,,, then there is no harm to leave husband,s, house,,,
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
suraleen - Bangalore
I don`t agree with ur comment sister (nisha), u don`t know how women are torture their husband and their in laws by filing the false cases, and abuse them by scolding very bad languages, don’t compare with the current society women and 50 years back women, there are no abala nari in society, but the real fact is men are suffering more now a days, do you know the married men suicide rate in 2010 just check the NCB report publish by home ministry.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
nisha - pune
Still I don`t agree with your comment ,,,, if husband is
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
nisha - pune
Still I don`t agree with yur comment ,,, as I am with supreme court`s decision,,,, still there are abla nari`s in the society ,,,, who tolerate mental torture by inlwas just for sake for her parents respect in the society ,,, and if husband is staying abroad and girl stays with inlwas and tolerate all the abusive language against her parents and for her what doed it means,,,, you can find still abla nari`s in the society,,,, men are not suffered a lot bez they have the option of second marraige,,, but girl`s don`t have the option of second marraige when they have childrens,,, no one is fool whol ruined own life by filing false case against inlwas i think it is the duty of court or police whether the case is genuin or false ,,,,, it is the duty of inlwas and husband to treat the daughter in law a humand being not a as a door mat or and ATM machine or a child machine,,,,, i know many cases where I can prove that there are abla nari`s in the society ,,, what if inlwas file a false case against daughter in law for mutual consent divorce and what if they tried to prove daughter in law a character less lady,,,, what I can say is govt has passed many act and provisions but still there are womens in the scoiety who tolerate torture from inlwas,,,,
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
suraleen - bangalore
Read this book if u have time, search internet for``Equality for Men - Myth or Reality``There are good statistics given in that book. Might help you get a bigger picture.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
nisha - pune
I have already read this book ,, men should know the right of women ,and treat his wife as human being not as door mat,
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Jayashree - Pune
Thanks for the support for the Girls. You owe my respect.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
jui - Bangalore
As a women i agree with you, current days women are not understanding the role and responsibilities of the family and they are doesn’t know and realized the bonding with a hubby, this is best relation even better then what a women are getting from their parents. Any real women who believe in this thing they never go for such kind of thing, now a days women are misuse the law and the women organization making this family breaking law in the name of women empowerment, as a successful women and family maker and thinking about the family welfare, I always protest this and support men for that. Because if you see who are talking about the women development and check their background history they never lead a successful matrimonial life, either they are never married, separated, divorcee or trouble their husband because they want to leave and go, then what way they will talk about the women development. Because of them women are getting the bad name in society everyday.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
aditya - kolkata
Two truth of women “women doesn’t ve common sense always they do mistake and repeating the same” and “one women is a enemy of a other women” so if women realized their mistake they should not argue on that. they should try to change themselves for future.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
anjali - delhi
Women are filing the false case against their husband and thinking they are achieving lot from law and after granting the maintenance they feel that are the real winner, they don’t understand the few feminist lawyer and the women commission are using them for achieving their goal, and like a foolish they are breaking their family and going out. First they should understand the hidden fact of it, as a women till today I personally realized that women commission never work for the women development just they make the money for them self and made their political carrier growth, and make fight between husband and wife by making this kind of laws and spoil the society and name of the women and the welfare of the family. And they use the general women on the society for get success in their goal. They never try to make such kind of law which can join the husband and wife, they always talking about family breaking law. There are number of area where women are suffering every day other then the making the family law women commission never concentrate about such areas till date.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
aditya - kolkata
If women understand their mistake and realized that they are spoiling their life, they should change them and try to reconcile with their husband not with arrogant attitude only with love, caring and lot of bonding should be bring out in their changed life forever.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Men Right - Bangalore
Women in age of 50-60 start prostitution, grt, whom to believe next, now a days women are getting married for 2-3 months maximum 1 year filing for money extortion. how she is doing after 31 years of marriage. its a clear picture NCW is pushing the women towards prostitution in the name of family welfare. they are the law maker for women who never lead a good matrimonial life.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
kamal - delhi
Bakwas hai..........marriage is a crime 4 men....which is again proved by this.......shame
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
nisha - pune
thanks to the supreme court,,,, thanks for solving my problem as I am also going throght the same situation,,,,now I can go back to my husband,s house and live respectable life once again thanks suprme court,,,,
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Jayashree Sarkar - Bangalore
This is a right decision by the Bench of Supreme court, India.This decision directly given a message for every women not to get scared of the society .. Fight till you do not get the justice and believe in God. I Salute Savita and Congratulate her.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
DEEPAK DUBEY - BHOPAL
This is right decision taken by supreme court. Because my sister suffered from the domestic violence.right now the case in the district court and they are not come in all case so this is good news for my sister to living the life.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
DEEPAK DUBEY - BHOPAL
This is right decision which were taken by supreme court.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Alok Ghosh - Allahabad
Non-sense...When husbands are sends jail by courts, at that time why wives are not right to live with husband`s house...
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sukhdeepak - Patiala
If a person marries another women then how it will be possible for husband to adjust two wives in same home.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

View all Comments   

Post your Comments

Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Most liked Comments

Men Right - Bangalore
Women in age of 50-60 start prostitution, grt, whom to believe next, now a days women are getting married for 2-3 months maximum 1 year filing for money extortion. how she is doing after 31 years of marriage. its a clear picture NCW is pushing the women towards prostitution in the name of family welfare. they are the law maker for women who never lead a good matrimonial life.



D.N.MAKHIJA - DELHI............INDIA
WHEN THE HUSBAND HAS NO ROOM IN HIS HEART FOR HIS ESTRANGED WIFE SO HOW CAN HE LIVE WITH HER IN THE SAME HOUSE.........



nisha - Pune
I don`t agree with suraleen`s comment,,,,by willniglr no one girl leave husband`s house when her life will become hell bez of inlaws and husband ,,, then last option is left with her to leave that house and save her own life ther are many incidents happen when girl`s life completely ruined by inlaws and husband`s ,,, and now gilr`s are more educted they can earn,,, by instead of tolerating mental torture,,, abusive language twards girl and her family ,,,no one girl will tolerate all this thing,,,, I know by leaving husband`s house is not a good thing for a married women ,... when husband`s huouse is not safe for a women ,,,,, then there is no harm to leave husband,s, house,,,