‘Ex-ISRO chief thrown out like garbage’
Zeenews
       English        
 Follow Me on Pinterest Google Plus Ditto RSS Mail to us Mail to us
Nation

‘Ex-ISRO chief thrown out like garbage’

Last Updated: Sunday, January 29, 2012, 01:00     A- A A+
Comments 8
Bangalore: Former ISRO chief G Madhavan Nair and three fellow space scientists against whom Government has taken damning action in the controversial Antrix-Devas deal were "thrown out like garbage", said Prof C N R Rao, Head of the Scientific Advisory Council to the Prime Minister.

Mincing no words, an angry Rao while putting his weight behind Nair also slammed V Narayanasamy, Minister of State in the Prime Minister's Office, for his stand on the ISRO row.

"People who have served the country, served the organisation for long, you cannot throw them like garbage. That's what they have done. They have literally thrown them out of the window like garbage", Rao told PTI today, voicing outrage at the action.

"They have not treated corrupt persons in politics, in public life like that. Why only scientists have been picked up?", asked Rao, also Honorary President of Bangalore-based Jawaharlal Nehru Centre for Advanced Scientific Research.

"Is this the way to treat anybody? Nobody will work for these (government) organisations if this is the way they are treated", Rao, a renowned scientist, said.

Nair said he appreciated Rao and other scientists for their support to him and was happy they voiced their concern over the developments in public.

"I really appreciate persons like Prof C N R Rao....they have understood the issue and I appreciate their concern," he added.

Rao targeted Narayanasamy for his reported comments that the government decision was taken to send a strong message to the scientific community that no wrongdoing would be tolerated. The Minister's comments came while he defending the action against Nair and three others.

"Minister of State saying this will be lesson...warning to scientists...it's not the way to talk about scientists. I don't know where he (Narayanasamy) got his basic education. I am shocked by the way he was on TV and talking like this about scientists in general," he said.

The government on Wednesday had barred Nair and three others from any re-employment for their alleged role in the deal on allocation of scarce S-band space segment to private firm Devas.

PTI

For Zee News’s Updates, follow us on Twitter , Facebook, Google+, Pinterest

First Published: Saturday, January 28, 2012, 18:39

Post your Comments

Name:
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Comments

saurabh singh kathayat - lucknow
mr. nair was not just like a garbage because garbage nevers makes missiles iam completely disagree with this heading..................i think in our india we call the diamond(mr. nair) garbage and garbage treated as the ministers due to this reason or i can say our weakness some thifes get chance to rule on us this one of the funny thing that my country have.....................
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
GARRY SINGH - USA Redmond
First of all, throw this PM out of the office who has no control over his Ministers. he is just wasting his time and others.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Premanada - Kollam
How foolish it is for Madhavan Nair, the former ISRO chief to compare him with Galileo! He became ISRO chief on the basis of seniority and not because of his scientific skills. His idiotic statement that water on the Moon was first discovered by Chandranyam and even the American astronauts who landed on the Moon could not discover exposes his stupidity and disqualifies him from any claim to be a scientist. For one thing the Moon is a vast planet and the astronuts who landed on a different site could never see water. For another their mission was not to find water. The entire space programme of ISRO is copied from NASA. Even the Chandranyam discovery of water was not due to the skill of Madhavan Nair but because of M3 of NASA attached to the satellite. If Madhavan Nair can tell such lies, there is no doubt he would have embezzled. Even the CAG reported that the loss to Govt. by ISRO is greater than 2G scam.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Diva - Delhi
Dear Premananda. Kindly do not comment unless u are 100% sure of the actual facts. Forget about your comments about ISRO chief, it is really bewildering to make a statement like ISRO is copying NASA. For your information NASA had its experiments on board Chandrayan, not other way round. Discovery of water may not be due to the skill of Madhavan Nair but it was due to the skill of a team of scientist who worked on the mass spectrometer flown by India which was the first to detect water on moon and not M3. M3 did detect water but much after that by the Indian payload. So do assess your comments before posting that. Being from Kollam, you must have first verified about Chandrayan from your friends at VSSC who have actually worked on this project, so as to get your facts right. Really sorry to get your inaccurate and factually incorrect comments on the abilities of Indian Space Scientists.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
R.K.Sharma - New Delhi
The way science and the scientific community is being treated by the political class ,the country will face the consequences in next two decades or so.When excellent Doctors,Engineers,Scientists,Educationists leave the country,they call it brain drain but they do not mind putting the brains in the drains.Most of the decisions in Public Sectors and undertakings are taken by politicians and beaurocrats and these people go scot free.Well this is all about the big democratic country.Shameful.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
sumit - usa
the same with doctors ,thats the reason I left india .I used to work in a government hospital too .
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sandeep - kolkata, india
thats not the stuff to justify why u people left india. if u r found guilty,whether it is usa or india u will face the same.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Lemon - West Bengal
Objectively If Dr. G Madhavan Nair had done wrong and that is proved in appropriate authority, then punishment according to procedure or code is justified. If he is not guilty and proved then can the current treatment restore the dignity or faith of whole scientific community?
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
umesh - bhubaneswar
This Govt has systematically destroyed the credibility of all institutions. This is not the way to publicly humiliate a top scientist. Prior to that they humiliated the army chief. But when dealing with politicians they have all the pretences to exonerate them.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Great Indian - Kumbanad,Kerala
Well said, Sir. You hit the nail on the head.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
sadhu vedant muni jain - bhopal
IN OUR COUNTRY SPECIALLY IN GOVT`S ORGANIZATION you will do dedicated duties will not appreciated by the government . if some irregularities may occur your whole carrier will be ruined.appreciations are not in the the govt but punishment is ready. all officers are interested to punish the rising person. departmental inquiry and official diplomacy are the major factors to harass any one. we know that these are senior persons so take decision mildly and use them for the development of the nation. they are qualified they will be absorbed any where. we know the laws are like a swords no body is spared by the sword who touches it.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

View all Comments   

Most liked Comments

R.K.Sharma - New Delhi
The way science and the scientific community is being treated by the political class ,the country will face the consequences in next two decades or so.When excellent Doctors,Engineers,Scientists,Educationists leave the country,they call it brain drain but they do not mind putting the brains in the drains.Most of the decisions in Public Sectors and undertakings are taken by politicians and beaurocrats and these people go scot free.Well this is all about the big democratic country.Shameful.



umesh - bhubaneswar
This Govt has systematically destroyed the credibility of all institutions. This is not the way to publicly humiliate a top scientist. Prior to that they humiliated the army chief. But when dealing with politicians they have all the pretences to exonerate them.



Top News



latest