"Foul" play in Army promotion procedure
A case of illegality in Army promotions has come to light where a Brigadier`s career records were erased in a "foul" manner.
New Delhi: A case of illegality in Army
promotions has come to light where a Brigadier`s career
records were erased in a "foul" manner which had almost cost
him his elevation to the rank of Major General.
The matter surfaced in the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT)
which was hearing the petition of Brigadier V G Gole, who had
alleged that a portion of his Annual Confidential record (ACR)
was erased, which was illegal, arbitrary and without
The officer had approached the Tribunal for expunging
the effaced portion of his ACR and considering his case afresh
for promotion to the rank of Maj Gen after he was denied
elevation by an Army promotion panel in September last year.
Allowing the petition, the Tribunal head Justice A K
Mathur said, "It speaks volume that such kind of illegality
can be committed against an officer. This is a serious matter
and we are constrained to observe that it requires deeper
consideration by higher authority.
"They should pinpoint the officer responsible who has
played foul thereby affecting the career of the officer. We
allow this petition with cost of Rs 10,000 and expunge the
effacing of the ACR of the Brigadier from January to June
The AFT said marks of the officer should be restored
back and he should be considered for promotion to the post of
Maj Gen in accordance with rules.
The Tribunal directed the authorities that the impending
retirement will not come in way of consideration of the
petitioner for promotion to the post of Maj Gen.