Govt moots raising the bar for IIT exams, appoints panel
Zeenews
       English        
Saturday, February 11, 2012 
Search
Follwo us on: Facebook Follwo us on: Twiter RSS Mail to us Mail to us Mail to us
Nation

Govt moots raising the bar for IIT exams, appoints panel

Last Updated: Tuesday, October 20, 2009, 00:48
Views 3735 Comments 16  
Govt moots raising the bar for IIT exams, appoints panel New Delhi: Securing 60 percent marks in class XII will not be sufficient for those aspiring for IITs from 2011 as a revision in eligibility criteria could see the cut-off percentage go upto 80% or higher.

The government on Monday appointed a committee of IIT directors to suggest the revised entrance system under which marks obtained in class XII will be given importance along with the entrance marks.

"The present criteria is that students need to secure 60 per cent at class XII for appearing in IIT-JEE. This is not acceptable. The minimum marks required for IIT-JEE could be raised up to 80 to 85 percent," Sibal told reporters after a meeting of the IIT Council, the apex decision making body for the elite institutes, here.

IIT-Delhi professor M. Balakrishnan told IANS: "This proposal has been mooted for almost a year now. There is talk in the ministry and among IITs to take such a decision soon."

The move is aimed at ensuring that students take their class XII seriously and checking the growth of coaching centres, which are thriving on imparting coaching to students for IIT entrance, HRD Minister Kapil Sibal said.

At the same time he added that the decision about the required percentage will be taken by the committee.

"The coaching centres are giving training for the IIT entrance. As a result, the students are not studying seriously for class XII exam and giving more attention to entrance. We want to get rid of the coaching centres by giving more weightage to the board exam," Sibal said.

The IIT-JEE system was revised three years ago when the eligibility criteria was raised to 60 percent at class XII level for appearing in the entrance.

Sibal said a three-member committee has been set up to look into the curriculum and submit its report within three months, suggesting required changes.

"All proposed changes would be implemented by 2011," a senior ministry official said.

The committee comprises Science and Technology Secretary T Ramasami, Secretary Department of Biotechnology M K Bhan and CSIR Director General Samir Brahmachari.

The committee will deliberate on new age courses to be started by the IITs. Sibal has been insisting that the IITs could explore starting courses in Humanities and Medicine also. The committee will give its report by January.

Besides, the government has decided to change the eligibility of students for availing the merit-cum-means scholarship being given at the end of class XII. The income criteria, which was Rs two lakh per annum as family income, has been changed to Rs 4.5 lakh.

To attract more foreign students, the government will reduce the fee structure for students from SAARC and African countries, Sibal said.

However, coaching centres like Career Launcher, which trains students to face the competitive exam, said that doing away with the coaching centres or increasing weightage for the Class 12 exam marks was not the real solution.

"The coaching centres will not be affected if the entrance exams focus on Class 12 marks. Because we as an industry cater to what inputs are required, so we would train for the IIT-JEE and the board exams. Coaching centres exist because of the existing lacuna at schools. The thrust should be on raising the standard of board exams and to focus on application rather than rote learning," Gautam Puri, vice-chairman of Career Launcher, told IANS.

Sibal has also asked for setting up a five-member committee to make the IITs more competitive. Another committee has been constituted to look into the IIT curriculum.

Bureau Report with IANS inputs

First Published: Tuesday, October 20, 2009, 00:48

Comments

umesh - patna
thanx sir for your bad and poor dicission.

sir aapke bat se ye to clear hai, ab low and middle class ke student IIT me nahi jayenge. kya aap apne country me job krne wale low ND MIDDLE CLASS KE logo ko etna payment krte hai ki o DPS and kisi achhe convent me pdha sake. bilkul nahi ..... to yese famly ke bachhe ko 80% marks kaha se aayenge aap bta sakte hai.

2nd bat ye galt bichar chhor dijiye 80% wale hi talent hote hai. 50 and 60% wale v etane talent hote hai ki aap wese student dekhe v nahi honge.
talent hi puchhna hai to IIT ke proffesers se puchhiye, aaj telent jate hai ya jab 6 years pahle IIT pt mains tha tab jate the.
pahle iit ke quez me iitians top krte the or ab iitian ka koi position hi nahi hota hai.
aab bura mat maniye aap sidha bol dijiye ki privet colleges ko and aap ministrs ke colleges ki sito ko full krna chahte hai.
sir sayed aap talent ka diffinition or talent ko pahchanane ki charecteria nahi jante hai.
sayed aap log jante nahi aapki yese dicission se hamare countary me engineering ki study sirf proffesional ban kr rh gayi hai n ki science ki .
yese dicission hote rhe to hamare country me scientists ki kami bani hi rahegi,or nahi aa skta hai kavi NOBEL price hamare INDIA me.
THANX
umesh kumar yadav
BIHAR
Enginnering student final year
(+12 58% only)

Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
student - india
sir aap ye boliye na straight forward ki aap k khole gaye colleges aur school me bache admission nahi lete hai esliye aap ye 80% 70% ki baat karte hai saach ye hai 60 se jayada aap ke pass school aur colleges hai jinme sirf ghatiya teacher hai jinhe paradhne kuch nahi aata hai lekin sachhi jaldi hi saamne aayege bahut jaldi corruption k khilaf jung chirne wali hai.we live for india and die for india mind it jo bhi hamare india k saath khele ga uska anjam bura hoga
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
yash - aligarh
sir,

i think u r right.criteria shiuld increase but upto 70-75% & iit paper should also be prepared from 11&12th syllabus as most of the parents cannot afford fee for coaching & b/coz of this most of brilliant minds r lost only in acedmics rather than competetive.
so please inform us soon so that we can built up for 12th & iit exam.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
mpwlana - Colombo, Sri Lanka
sir,

please take away the jee and make sellection according to 12th marks for which we spent all our school life.give credit to our hard work which lasted for 12 years.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
kritika - delhi
sir,
the system u have been started is gud but i want ask one think that sir y have u start dis
actually iit-jee are diffrent part
sir can u do me a favour plz open maths book n iit level of maths there is a very very vast difffrence............just compare 4 a while
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
aradhya - agra
sir by this u actually loose so many talented brains bcz jitne bhi bachhe 80% above score kartein hein unmein se about 80% to ratta martein hein chahe vo chemistry ho ya physics.those students who score in between 70% to 85% are allrounder unko agar 80% aata hai to vo unhe complete achhe tarah aata hai wthout any ratta. and u know that iit want brainies not the kadduuus so tak decision wth remembrance of all the things and of us also. there might be some problems during their exam time for that they should not be punished for their whole life and carrier.i think education is for life not for living so give good education to all the students for their good lives.agar aap ye act karte hein to hum ko ek achhe education to milege lakin aap bahut saare acchhe brains kho denge trust me
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
gaurav chandak - pune
i think kapil sibal is out of his mind
what education system require , that every student should understand concepts whatever be the source .........
80% criteria will cause stress , tension . more sucide ,more prental tension .
kapil sibal is forgetting the real cause of iit jee .

Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
shashank - agra
sir , this is not a right act . u should take care of those who passed 12th with 70% or more. u said that ur im is to consider 12th xam before the iit entrance xam but is there any use of implementing this act to those who passed 12th meanwhile there is no other exam after 12th accept that of iit. i m sure that i can crack iit without coaching and better than those who r our school topper because i trust only on my mind. u know that this time there was two questions wrong in cbse maths xam but some students lk me got tensed and done extra 2-3 question wrong . u should take care of those students and i must say that i secure top 100 ranks in the next exam. so my advise is that u should raise it to 70% instead of 80 and this act should not be implemented to those who passed 12 bcz this is of no use it gives only tension and pressure on students as well as there parents believe me
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
dimple rana - chandigarh
m gonna to drop this year,so what happens if i didnt score above 80%?????????
u cant increase that much ,,,,just 60% to 80% its a huge increase ,i think u should increase upto 70%,and the great scientist had said that marks are not important ,the important is how u solve the problems,and that scientist was none other than it was einstien ,he was not the topper but he still remember by his work and knowledge....
and u should previously about this act as it was big problem for dropper batch............
it is just foolish act , coz only few students can score above 80%.......
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sundeep Gupta - Indore
This is a foolish solution to the existing problem.
Growing coaching centre can be checked by increasing salary scale of school teachers thus retaining good quality teachers with schools teachers should be trained properly in their subject they themselves provoke students to join coaching institute.
For a fresher candidate who cleared JEE in his first attempt XII board percentage should be completely ignored
While for droppers minimum eligibility for admission into IITs should be 65% in XII board.
From
Sundeep Gupta
Director, Gupta Tutorials, Indore.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

View all Comments   

Post your Comments

Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Most liked Comments