No closure for Aarushi’s parents

CBI filed a closure report in Aarushi double murder case on grounds that there was no evidence.

Zeenews Bureau

New Delhi: The parents of teenager Aarushi Talwar, who was murdered about two and half year ago, have decided to file appeal against the case closure report filed by CBI.

"This is not the last and final as far as we are concerned. We are the complainants in the case. They (parents) are being left in no position to even ask for the actual killer of their dead daughter being brought to book because of the manner in which their rights were compromised," lawyer of Aarushi’s parents`, Rebbecca John, said.

“I had huge hopes on CBI. Now the killers walk free, not something I can bear...As Aarushi`s mother I am completely broken,” said Aarushi`s mother, Nupur Talwar.

“I am going to see what my options are. Everyday I promise Aarushi that I will get justice to her. I promise this every day when I talk to her,” she said, adding, “This is the only purpose of my existence to get justice for my child”.

“I won’t let this happen; I have to give her justice. I will fight to the finish, examine the closure report, find legal options. One thing is for sure I am not letting it go like this,” she said.

Her husband Rajesh Talwar too expressed disappointment and said they had been asking the CBI to conduct a highly-sensitive DNA test, termed Touch DNA, which could throw some light on the possible killers.

“I have been telling CBI to do a touch DNA test for the last one and half can get to know who was there. This is a test they should do,” said Talwar.

He said he got to know about the CBI filing a closure report from a news channel.

“I was treating a patient when I got the news. After that, obviously, I could not work,” he said.

“We will talk to our lawyers on what we can do. I think everybody should support us, as if any person does such a thing and walks free, then it is not worth living in this country,” he said.

A forensic expert involved in the case said crucial evidence were destroyed allegedly by the probe agency and accused CBI of cover-up.

"They had sent us some blood-stained bedsheets from the bed of the victims. Using that and the blood of the parents of the Aarushi, we were able to establish that the blood stains were indeed that of the girl...

"We were also sent some slides which were the vaginal swabs taken from the victim to check whether there was sexual assault. What came out was surprising: that they were not of the victim. That has been a very clear case of swapped that has taken place and that was something we had communicated to CBI. That indicated that there were some interest in ensuring that evidence has been tampered with," said Dr J Gowrishankar, Director, Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics, Hyderabad.

The forensic expert also raised doubts over the investigations handled first by Uttar Pradesh police before handing it over to CBI.

"There was one law enforcement agency before it could be transferred to CBI...In all crime-related cases, there was something called chain of custody, which should be maintained and that was broken. That gave certain indication that vested interest was involved," he added.

CBI on Wednesday filed its closure report in a special court in Ghaziabad in the two-and-a-half-year-old Aarushi murder case in which a teenager and her domestic help were killed at their residence.

14-year-old daughter of dentist couple Rajesh Talwar and Nupur was found dead with her throat slit at their house at Jalwayu Vihar at Noida on May 16, 2008.

CBI had arrested the three suspects -- Raj Kumar, Vijay Mandal and Krishna -- in the case. Defence Counsel Naresh Yadav expressed unhappiness over the closure report and accused CBI of shielding the accused.

"CBI is acting under the influence of certain politicians and wealthy people. CBI knows about the accused involved in the case. Since they (accused) are well off, they are trying to save them. The closure report is also filed in connivance with them," Yadav claimed.

With agency inputs

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. You can find out more by clicking this link