The appellate authority in RTI matters at the Law Ministry on March 10 has upheld the initial answer given by the Central Public Information Officer to the RTI application
by activist S C Agrawal, saying that no such list exists with the Ministry.
The President's Secretariat had forwarded the application to the ministry to provide answers pertaining to the list of judges whose files for the elevation to the Supreme Court or as chief justices of high courts have "at least once" been returned by it.
Agrawal sought replies on a 16-point application seeking details of such judges in the light of elevation proposals of the Karnataka High Court Chief Justice and the Allahabad High Court Chief Justice being sent back by the Law Ministry to the collegium.
"The Central Public Information Officer informed the applicant (Agrawal) that no such list is maintained by this department and therefore, no information could be furnished,"
First Appellate Authority and Joint Secretary Ramesh Abhishek held.
"I am not aware of any other public authority which might be having information sought by the applicant," he said.
New Delhi: The government has given a final no to an RTI application seeking details or list of judges whose elevation to the Supreme Court or as Chief Justices of High Courts have been objected to by the President, leaving the matter to be decided by the Central Information Commission.
First Published: Friday, March 12, 2010, 14:37