New Delhi: HRD Minister Kapil Sibal was on Tuesday prevented from moving an amendment bill in the Rajya Sabha on
Copyright Act by the Opposition, which saw in it "conflict of
Even before Sibal could move the Copyright (Amendment)
Bill, 2010, for consideration, members from BJP, JD-U, AIADMK,
BSP and TDP rose on their feet saying the minister cannot
introduce it since his lawyer son represented Super Cassette
Industries, a market leader in the music industry.
"According to Rule 294 of Parliament`s Ethics Committee, a
member having direct or indirect interest in a matter cannot
move a bill... He has conflict of interest," Shivanand Tiwari
He was supported by BJP members including S S Ahluwalia
and Prakash Javadekar besides members from other parties
Though Parliamentary Affairs Minister Pawan Kumar Bansal
came in support of Sibal, the Opposition did not allow him
(Bansal) to speak despite Deputy Chairman K Rahman Khan`s
"His (Sibal`s) son is independent as a lawyer. This is not
in good taste. This is rather unparliamentary," Bansal said.
Amid the ruckus, Khan adjourned the House for 15 minutes.
When the House re-assembled, he adjourned it for the day as
the protesting members did not relent.
Khan said there was no logic behind their protest as the
minister has not even stood up to move the Bill.
The bill seeks to amend the Copyright Act, 1957 to
fine-tune it with relevant international treaties and to
introduce a system of statutory licensing to protect the
owners of literary or musical works.