Probe lapses not fatal to case if guilt proved: SC
New Delhi: The Supreme Court has said lapses in investigation cannot be exploited by an accused to his advantage if there is sufficient evidence to nail him for a crime.
"It is well settled that remissness and inefficiency of the investigating agency should be no a ground to acquit a person if there is enough evidence on record to establish his guilt beyond reasonable doubt," said the apex court bench of Justice Surinder Singh Nijjar and Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai in a recent judgment.
"Irregularities or deficiencies in conducting investigation by the prosecution is not always fatal to the prosecution case," the court noted.
Justice Desai said: "If there is sufficient evidence to establish the substratum of the prosecution case, then irregularities which occur due to remissness of the investigating agency, which do not affect the substratum of the prosecution case, should not weigh with the court."
The court said this while upholding the life sentence of Kashinath Mondal who was convicted for raping and murdering his niece. The incident took place in West Bengal`s Hooghly district Oct 30, 1997.
The convict took the defence that he was held guilty on the basis of circumstantial evidence only. He said no finger-prints were lifted from the crime scene and no scientific evidence was presented by the prosecution to establish his guilt.
"We have no manner of doubt that had the investigating agency obtained the samples in a scientific manner and promptly sent them to the serologist that would have lent further support to the prosecution," the court said.
The court rejected the contention that had Mondal been guilty then he would have run away instead of coming to the spot upon hearing the voices of the people who had gathered.
"In the facts of this case, if the appellant (Mondal) had run away, that would have, in fact, weakened his case and strengthened the prosecution case. The decision to remain at the spot appears to be a calculated one," the court said.
On the prosecution`s claim that the victim and her uncle Mondal were the only people on the first floor and the house was locked from inside, the court said: "The only conclusion which can be drawn is that it is the appellant who was responsible for the murder."
This conclusion was irresistible and supported by the admitted strained relationship between Mondal and the victim`s father and his brother on account of a property dispute, the judges said.
The court held that though there was no witness to the crime it could rely upon the testimony of Mondal`s mother.
"It is true that there is no eye-witness to the offence. But, what persuades us to agree with the courts below is the fact that the mother of the appellant deposed against him. No mother would ever falsely involve her son in such a ghastly crime," the court said.
More from India
More from World
More from Sports
More from Entertaiment
- Vadodara: Policemen seen dancing with bar girls
- PM Modi speaks at Golden Jubilee celebrations of poet Dinkar’s works
- Zee Media Exclusive: Kangana, Madhavan talk about their film 'Tanu Weds Manu Returns'
- DNA: Harmful chemicals found in Maggi, Nestle India still in denial mode
- Coal scam: Naveen Jindal, Madhu Koda and others get bail
- One year of Modi govt: Arun Jaitley addresses press conference
- ISIS executes Syrian fighter using anti-tank rocket launcher
- CM Kejriwal shortlists 39 'unwanted' IAS officers in Delhi
- Zee Media Exclusive interview with Congress leader Kamal Nath
- DNA: Modi-led NDA govt's hits and misses in one year
- Columbia student takes rape-protest mattress to graduation
- Rajasthan: Gujjars revive reservation agitation, block rail track
- Mumbai: One injured in shootout at Film City
- J Jayalalithaa sworn-in as Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu
- Delhi: Car catches fire after crash, one dead
- IPL 2015, Qualifier 2: CSK vs RCB - As it happened...
- Tanu Weds Manu Returns movie review: Brilliant execution, superb performance!
- India to soon have its own space shuttle!
- Kejriwal slams notification on LG's powers, says Modi running Delhi govt through back door
- PM Narendra Modi graces Digvijay Singh's son wedding reception
- Rahul Gandhi to pressurise govt to act on one-rank-one-pension issue
- CBSE 12th Results 2015: CBSE Board Cbse.nic.in & cbseresults.nic class 12th XII board exam Results 2015 date announced
- Businessman shot next to Amitabh Bachchan's shooting location in Mumbai Film City
- ISIS close to buying nuclear weapon from Pakistan?
- Goa Board SSC Exam Results 2015 announced
- Manohar Parrikar visits forward areas along LoC, reviews security situation
- West Bengal Board Class 10th Madhyamik Pariksha Results 2015 announced
- RBSE 12th Science & Commerce Board Result 2015 declared
- RBSE rajresults.nic.in & rajeduboard.nic.in 12th Results 2015: BSER Ajmer Rajasthan Board Class 12th XII Senior Secondary Science & Commerce Exam Results 2015 to be declared shortly
- There will be no delay in appointing CIC, CVC: Jitendra Singh