Varying verdicts for same evidence disturbing: Ex-CBI chief
New Delhi: The Priyadarshani Mattoo case
should come as a "food for thought" for the judiciary since
the same set of evidence is being seen differently by courts
leading to inconsistent verdicts, says former CBI Director
Shankar, who was instrumental in the appeal and
pursuing the case in Delhi High Court as CBI Director,
today said he was "sad" with different verdicts being
pronounced right from the judgement of the trial court.
"Sessions Court acquits the accused on benefit of doubt
and the Delhi High Court convicts him to death penalty and now
Supreme Court finds some merit in his plea...All these
verdicts are based on the same set of evidence," says Shanker,
who has been associated with the case as Additional and
Special Director before becoming the Director of the CBI in
Shanker, a 1969 batch IPS officer of UP cadre, remembers
the day when the father of the victim had approached him with
tears in his eyes after the Sessions Court had acquitted the
"In such a gruesome crime of murder of an innocent young
woman, Apex Court`s ruling of today is at best only some sort
of justice (to the family) as justice has been already delayed
for nearly 16 years.
Such varied standards of criminal justice leading to
varied conclusions at Sessions court, the High Court and the
Supreme Court `are disturbing`," he said.
Elaborating, he said "on the same set of evidence,
Sessions court preferred to give benefit of doubt
acquitting the accused, the High Court decided to order him to
be hanged to death treating it as a rarest of rare crimes and
now the Apex court finds some merit in the plea.
"This is a food for thought for all those who have a
belief in rule of law and particularly to those who are
responsible for dispensing justice."
More from India
More from World
More from Sports
More from Entertaiment
- I eat beef, can somebody stop me?: Kiren Rijiju hits back at Naqvi
- Zee Media's mega survey on Modi govt
- Delhi: Visually impaired boy scores 91.4% in CBSE 12th Board exams
- MP: 14-year-old boy works as bonded labour since 2009
- UP: Man chops off wife's nose, hair for dowry
- Zee Media Exclusive: The plight of yoga expert Tejaswi Sharma
- Woman denied flat in Mumbai for being a Muslim
- 4 Indians in Forbes' 100 most powerful women list
- BBV: What challenges lie ahead of Modi govt?
- DNA analysis of rising water crisis in India!
- Gujjar stir: HC asks Rajasthan govt to clear rail track, roads
- DNA: Delhi shop owners express their plight through Zee initiative 'My News'
- Watch: Zee Media mega survey on Modi govt- Part 2
- Gujjar stir: HC asks Rajasthan govt to clear rail track, roads- Part II
- AIB: The 'Third Gender's right to dignity'
- Arpita-Aayush wedding reception: Salman Khan spreads love in Mandi, says `hum aapke hain`
- CBSE Class 10 Board Result 2015 (cbse.nic.in, cbseresults.nic.in) postponed?
- CBSE Class 10 Board Result 2015 to be announced today
- Check mahresult.nic.in for MSBSHSE Maharashtra Class 12 HSC Result 2015
- Maharashtra MSBSHSE HSC Result 2015 on mahresult.nic.in
- Rahul Gandhi takes a dig at one year of Modi govt, wishes 'happy birthday' to 'suit-boot ki sarkar'
- I was misquoted, says Kiren Rijiju on 'beef' remark
- mahresult.nic.in updated with MSBSHSE Maharashtra HSC Class XII Result 2015
- First look: Salman Khan steals thunder in `Bajrangi Bhaijaan`
- Manmohan Singh defends himself on 2G charge, slams Modi govt for 'carbon copy' schemes
- Sonia Gandhi 'unconstitutional authority' during UPA: PM Narendra Modi
- Reservation stir: Five percent job quota to Gujjars unlikely, hints Rajasthan govt
- Hours after attacking NDA govt, Manmohan Singh meets PM Narendra Modi
- Check cbse.nic.in, cbseresults.nic.in for CBSE Class 10 Result 2015
- CBSE (cbse.nic.in ) Class X results 2015: CBSE Class 10th Board results likely to be declared tomorrow on cbseresults.nic.in