Hillary chides NATO ally Turkey on rights curbs

Hillary Clinton said the curbs placed on religious freedom were inconsistent with Turkey`s progress.

Istanbul: US Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, chiding a NATO ally whose support is critical to American goals in the Mideast, said on Saturday that Turkey must act on concerns about backsliding on human rights and its secular traditions

Speaking politely but firmly about the moderate Muslim nation, Hillary said the recent arrests of dozens of journalists and curbs placed on religious freedom were "inconsistent" with Turkey`s economic and political progress.

She said Turkey should recommit itself to the course of modernisation and embrace the democratic institutions of statehood. By doing so, Turkey could serve as a model for Arab nations now in the midst of revolt or transition, America`s top diplomat said.

"Across the region, people in the Middle East and North Africa are seeking to draw lessons from Turkey`s experience," she told reporters at a news conference with Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu. "Turkey`s history serves as a reminder that democratic development also depends on responsible leadership."

She called on the Turkish people to use their constitutional reform process to "address concerns ... about recent restrictions on freedom of expression and religion" and boost protection for the rights of minorities.

Those concerns have stalled Turkey`s bid to join the European Union and further cement ties with the West. Hillary noted that the US long has backed Turkey`s EU membership.

At a town hall event earlier where she took questions from young Turks, Hillary criticised the arrests of journalists. She said the detentions have fed fears about threats to press freedom in the majority Muslim nation.

"I do not think it is necessary or in Turkey`s interests to be cracking down. It seems to me inconsistent with all the other advances Turkey has made," she said.

Turkey`s institutions should be able to withstand the scrutiny and debate that a free press brings, Hillary said.

Turkish media groups say more than 60 journalists are in jail. The groups accuse authorities of using flimsy evidence to bring the charges.

Government officials said in April there were 26 journalists jail in Turkey for activities unrelated to journalism. Officials have cited the role of some media sectors over the decades in fanning support for coups led by the Turkish military, a staunch supporter of the secular system.

The Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe, of which Turkey is a member, says 57 journalists are in jail in Turkey, mostly on anti-terror charges. That includes people with alleged ties to Kurdish rebels and extremists.

Hillary`s comments were likely to encourage more liberal Turks but irritate Turkey`s leaders, including Davutoglu and Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

A small group protested Hillary`s visit outside the US embassy. In Istanbul, one man holding a Turkish flag staged a protest as Hillary met Orthodox Patriarchate Bartholomew, accusing Washington of "killing millions of Muslims”.

Erdogan, long seen as a vital bridge between East and West, has worried some by taking steps at odds with US and Western policies.

He insists that his ruling party, which has Islamist roots, is committed to secularism. But since President Barack Obama took office, Erdogan has clashed with Israel and opposed UN sanctions on Iran over its nuclear program.

During George W Bush`s administration, Turkey opposed the war in Iraq and refused to allow troops to enter Iraq from its territory, creating additional divisions over the conflict within NATO.

At the coffee house, Hillary also urged Turks to continue to embrace inclusive traditions and serve as the East-West bridge, without choosing one or the other.

"I don`t think there is any reason for Turkey to shift from West to East," she said. "As an outsider, I have always thought the debate is a debate without real meaning to it because why would you give up one for another? You can look both ways and to me that is an incredible advantage."

Bureau Report

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. You can find out more by clicking this link