Nativity scenes at Guantanamo spark protest

Some troops at Guantanamo Bay want the US Navy to remove Nativity scenes and Christmas decorations from two base dining facilities, saying they improperly promote Christianity over other faiths.

Guantanamo Bay Naval Base: Some troops at Guantanamo Bay want the US Navy to remove Nativity scenes and Christmas decorations from two base dining facilities, saying they improperly promote Christianity over other faiths, an organisation that advocates for religious freedom in the military said on Wednesday.

A group of 18 service members from several faiths contacted the Military Religious Freedom Foundation for help in removing the Nativity scenes and decorations because they figured they would be ignored and feared retribution, said Mikey Weinstein, the president of the organisation. The troops, he added, also prefer to remain anonymous because of a possible backlash.

"They are terrified," Weinstein said. "Right now, there is a witch hunt going on to find out who did this." Eleven of the troops who complained are Protestant and Catholic and the rest are Muslim, Jewish, agnostic or atheist, Weinstein said.

A base spokeswoman, Kelly Wirfel, said she was meeting with the commander, Captain John Nettleton, yesterday to discuss the issue and had no immediate comment.

The naval base, located in southeast Cuba, has a population of about 5,500 military and civilian personnel. Outside the coils of razor wire surrounding an area where nearly 160 prisoners are held, the base has set up many exterior displays of Christmas lights and other decorations along wide streets, creating the feel of a typical suburban American town in December.

At issue are decorations inside two dining facilities, including one used primarily by people who work inside the prison, including guards and translators. An e-mail sent to the Military Religious Freedom Foundation from the troops says the Nativity scenes went up in late November in the centre of the eating area and no other religions are represented despite the presence of other faiths on the base.

"By placing these displays in prominent common areas, the impression is that one faith is better than others and that the military institution singularly promotes Christianity," says the e-mail, provided to a news agency by the organisation without the names of the senders.

The e-mail goes on to say that prominent members of their command have shown

"Christian religious undertones," which leads them to believe they could not complain directly to them about the decorations. The senders point out in the email that they put up with a great deal of hardship, including having bodily fluids hurled at them from prisoners, and should not be made uncomfortable on their time off.

"We would prefer to not have a large deal made out of this situation and only ask that these clear violations of military policy, and the Constitution, be removed immediately," the e-mail said.

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. You can find out more by clicking this link

Close