NSA whistleblower - hero or traitor, US debates
Washington: Whistleblowers like Edward Snowden put everything on the line to unveil the most closely guarded government secrets in an effort to preserve cherished US freedoms.
Snowden`s explosive leaks last week of vast surveillance programs run by the National Security Agency that trawl through telephone and Internet records have triggered widespread consternation, gaining him admirers but also critics who denounce him as a traitor.
The 29-year-old government contractor is behind one of the most significant security breaches in US history, joining the likes of Vietnam-era Pentagon Papers leaker Daniel Ellsberg and Bradley Manning, who released US diplomatic cables and war logs to the WikiLeaks website.
"In my estimation, there has not been in American history a more important leak," Ellsberg wrote in The Guardian.
"Snowden did what he did because he recognized the NSA`s surveillance programs for what they are: dangerous, unconstitutional activity."
But intelligence officials and lawmakers from both major parties have labeled him a traitor, and called for his swift capture.
"I hope we follow Mr Snowden to the ends of the earth to bring him to justice," Republican Senator Lindsey Graham wrote on his Twitter account, casting the leaker`s action as "not as one of patriotism but potentially a felony.
Senator Bill Nelson, a Democrat, slammed the "act of treason," and called for Snowden`s extradition and prosecution.
Obama`s spy chief, Director of National Intelligence James Clapper, has described the leaks as causing "huge, grave damage" to US intelligence capabilities, and referred the matter to the Justice Department, which has launched an investigation.
The timing of the release is significant, coming not only as President Barack Obama battles controversies over the tax-collecting IRS, last year`s deadly Benghazi attack and snooping of journalists` phone records, but also as Manning is put on trial.
"It`s not something that you cautiously choose, it`s something you have to do," fellow whisteblower Peter Van Buren, a former State Department official who released classified documents, told AFP.
"I know it takes enormous courage to do what Snowden did, and the willingness to give up everything -- life, freedom, everything -- for a good bigger than yourself. If that is not a definition of patriotism, nothing else can be."
In a high-stakes gamble, Snowden has fled to Hong Kong, where he has hunkered down for the past three weeks, fearing retaliation from red-faced US authorities outraged at the revelations.
The term whistleblower itself is a contentious one, and applies to informants regardless of their own weaknesses or potential recklessness of their leaks.
For Van Buren, the decision to release previously secret information to the public is an "act of conscience."
"At the end of the day, you have to separate the message from the messenger," he said.
"We`re all miserable human beings. It doesn`t matter who releases the information, it`s a requirement for democracy."
Ben Wizner of the powerful American Civil Liberties Union noted that without whistleblowers, the public would not have learned about abuses at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq, CIA black sites or the NSA`s warrantless wiretapping under president George W. Bush.
"If government by the people is going to be real, the people need to know what the government is doing and if we rely only on the official version of facts, the people would be kept in the dark about very important issues," he said.
More from India
More from World
More from Sports
More from Entertaiment
- IAF Mirage fighter plane lands on Yamuna Expressway!
- Kejriwal accuses Centre of trying to rule Delhi through LG
- 'Maggi' under regulatory scanner for excess amount of lead, MSG
- Watch: Michelle Obama's 'Gimme Five' fitness video
- When Subramanian Swamy shocked people at a wedding!
- Expect that Rahul will be Congress president in 2015: Jairam Ramesh
- Mumbaikars join hands to save Pakistani teen with rare illness
- DNA: Analysis of Hurriyat chief Syed Geelani's passport issue
- DNA: Analysis of traffic system of Vancouver, Canada
- Mumbai: Diamond export company denies job to Muslim youth
- Aapke Sitare: Astro prediction for May 21, 2015
- Mirage 2000 fighter jet landing was part of capability demonstration: IAF
- DNA: IAF Mirage 2000 fighter plane lands successfully on Yamuna expressway
- DNA: Osama documents show 'Indian brother in Madinah' financed al Qaeda
- PM Modi's key campaign team member may join Nitish Kumar
- RBSE (rajresults.nic.in) Class 12th science and commerce results 2015: Rajasthan Board Class 12th XII exam results 2015 expected to be announced on May 21
- RBSE (rajresults.nic.in) Class 12th science and commerce results 2015: Rajasthan Board Class 12th XII exam results 2015 to be announced today at 4 PM
- JAC 12th Inter Arts Result 2015: JAC 12th Inter Arts Result 2015 (jharkhandeducation.net) likely to be announced on Thursday May 21 at 1 PM
- CBSE Class 10 Results 2015 to be announced today?
- IAF jet lands on Yamuna expressway
- Check Jharkhand Board jac.nic.in: Class 12th Art Results 2015 declared
- Andhra Pradesh EAMCET results 2015: Andhra Pradesh EAMCET results to be announced on May 21 at www.apeamcet.org
- Log on to apeamcet.org AP EAMCET Results 2015: Andhra Pradesh EAMCET Marks and AP EAMCET Ranks 2015 declared
- Fawad Khan doesn’t want intimate scenes with Sonam Kapoor?
- We hire only non-Muslim candidates, diamond export firm tells Muslim youth
- IPL 2015: Rajasthan Royals vs Royal Challengers Bangalore - As it happened...
- DHSE (dhsekerala.gov.in) 12th Result 2015: Kerala DHSE Class 12th XII exam results 2015 to be announced on May 21
- Is MSG in 'Maggi' noodles harmful for you?
- SSLC (tnresults.nic.in) Tenth 10th Results 2015: Tamil Nadu Board Class 10th X Higher Secondary exam results 2015 to be declared on May 21
- 'IAS officer DK Ravi possibly committed suicide, suffered big loss in real estate business'