Professor given 3 1/2 years in China swingers case
The case of Ma Yaohai has touched off national debate about sexual freedom.
Beijing: A college professor accused of organising a swingers club and holding private orgies in China was sentenced to 3 1/2 years in prison, officials said, in a case that touched off national debate about sexual freedom.
Ma Yaohai, 53, was convicted and sentenced on charges of group licentiousness for participating in group sex parties, said an official from the Qinhuai District Court in southeastern Nanjing. The official, who declined to give his name, refused to answer further questions.
Ma, along with 21 other people, was arrested and charged last year — the first time anyone has been charged under a 1997 law in a case that has snagged huge public interest with its titillating details. It also generated debate about sexual freedom in a nation trying to reshape its own modern morality.
The China News Service reported that the other 21 were given lighter sentences, ranging from probation only up to three years, because they demonstrated `good attitudes` by pleading guilty. The maximum sentence for the crime was five years in prison.
Ma`s attorney Yao Yong`an said his client, who was the only one to plead innocent, plans to appeal the verdict.
"It`s definitely not a fair case. It`s not based on the law. ... We can understand the reason behind it, but we can`t accept it," he said.
Prosecutors had accused Ma, a computer science professor at Nanjing University of Technology, of organising a swingers club, where members met online and gathered in private homes or hotels for group sex parties.
But Ma had maintained that he committed no crime, arguing that his activities involved consenting adults meeting in non-public places.
His defiance seemed to strike a chord in an era of relative sexual freedom, where extramarital affairs and prostitution are common — drawing support from those who believe the Chinese government should stay out of the bedroom.
Chinese have debated whether the country`s laws on sexual behaviour were outdated in a society that undergone stark changes in its attitudes toward sex.
Sociologist and sex expert Li Yinhe, who had been among the most vocal public defenders of Ma, said she was disappointed in the court`s ruling, adding "Ma Yaohai shouldn`t be sentenced at all”.
She acknowledged the sentence marked an improvement compared with 20 years ago, when displays of public affection and even dancing with members of the opposite sex could have punished.
"He could have been sentenced to death then. But the real improvement should be the complete abolishment of this crime," she said.
With rising prosperity and an easing of government controls on personal freedoms, China has moved toward a more progressive view on sex, though attitudes remain more traditional in the countryside than in urban centres.