Devendra Fadnavis gives point-by-point rebuttal to Rajdeep Sardesai's open letter – Read

Mumbai: Days after Rajdeep Sardesai took on Devendra Fadnavis on the controversial Mumbai meat ban and Rakesh Maria’s promotion to DG, Home Guards, the Maharashtra Chief Minister slammed the senior journalist's 'biased' views.

The BJP leader penned an open letter, published in Hindustan Times, in response to the one written by Sardesai a few days ago.

Saying that if he did not reply to the “open letter by ‘senior’ journalist, the Goebbels law — speak what is untrue several times over and it becomes the truth — may prevail”.

On meat ban, Fadnavis said it was not his government which took the decision to ban meat. “Not a single new order went from the government to any local body. The Congress government in 2004 took the decision to close a slaughter-house for two days in Paryushan Parva. It was conveyed to all municipal corporations then. Since then all municipal corporations including Mira-Bhaindar started implementing it. Additionally municipal corporations like Mumbai and Mira-Bhaindar adopted resolutions to ban it for additional days within their own powers, which in the case of Mumbai dates back to 1994. Surprisingly, none of you ever objected to it until we came to power. Obviously you were comfortable with the pseudo-secular image of the previous government, howsoever corrupt and non-performing it was.”

“It’s quite possible that you know this but it doesn’t suit your agenda,” Fadnavis added.

The Maharashtra CM further clarified on Maria's promotion in the middle of the infamous Sheena Bora murder investigation.

“In the case of Rakesh Maria, you seem to be confused. Your post-script says the Sheena Bora murder case should not have assumed the kind of importance it was accorded by the media. Then why did you choose to write on it, linking it with the transfer of the city police chief? A police chief is not an investigating officer but just a supervisory authority. I would like to tell you that the practice of promoting senior people, a few days in advance, is not new. Such decisions are taken keeping in mind the objective to let the new one who is going to take over understand the prevailing situation.”

“The months of September and October are full of festivals, including the Ganesh Festival, Eid celebrations and Navratri. If the government thought that instead of changing a police commissioner in the midst of festivities it was better to put a new person in place before the festive season started, what’s so wrong about it? Although I believe that officers have no caste and religion the point could also have been raised as to why Maria was made commissioner of police, Mumbai, sidelining two senior and equally decorated officers like Ahmad Javed, a person from a minority community, and Vijay Kamble, a person from a backward community. However, I would say that the government at that point of time thought that Maria was better suited for the situation.”

Fadnavis also responded to Sardesai's comment on a recent circular outlining guidelines for the police while making arrests on sedition charges.

“Your take on sedition can be termed a classic product of a biased mind. I want to ask you whether the state is expected to convey a decision given by the hon’ble high court to the police or not? Again, not a single decision has been taken by our government in this regard. In one of the cases in the high court, an affidavit was filed by the then Congress-led government and the court delivered a detailed judgment interpreting the scope and ambit of the applicability of sedition, and also directed to convey it to the police. The department made a faithful translation of the judgment in Marathi and conveyed it to all the police stations via an office circular. Every single item in the circular is just a translation of the judgment. Mr Sardesai, you may not want to go through such details to understand the issue just because you wish to pursue your leftist agenda vigorously and passionately.”

The Maharashtra Chief Minister also reminded the journalist of the initiatives taken by his government in various fields.

“It’s apparent how much pain it causes you to mention a word about the water conservation initiative of our government — the flagship programme of Jalyukta Shivar Yojna — to make Maharashtra drought-free. It is a programme that has become most successful. The generous contributions by people — more than Rs 300 crore — have helped us to execute nearly 100,000 works in 6,000 villages within six months. The results are evident. Despite the scanty rainfall, the villages are boasting distributed water storages and increased water tables. It was lauded as a game changer by the ‘Jalpurush’ of India, Rajendra Singh, at the Stockholm Water Conference. This programme will provide moisture security to the farmers and assure crop sustainability by mitigating the effects of climate change.”

Replying to Rajdesai's jibe that the agony of the farmer should give Fadnavis sleepless nights, the BJP leader said: “It’s really sad to see that people like you get disturbed by an imaginary situation that there won’t be a piece of meat in your platter for two days when my annadata is taking extreme steps because he has no food to eat. That is why the state has decided to implement a food security scheme for six million farmers by giving them wheat at Rs 2 per kg and rice at Rs 3 per kg. The infamous legacy of farmer suicides, which we inherited from 15 years of bad governance, is a challenge that doesn’t let me sleep. But the initiatives started by our government, I’m sure, will deliver results in due course.”

“Whether there is a ban on meat or not, a common man expects roti or rice in his plate. And I am more concerned about it than anything else. Mr Sardesai, the content of your letter can be part of your profession but the resolve in my reply is my mission and I will accomplish it. My mantra of life is ‘perform or perish’ and time alone would decide my destiny.”

The letter ended with - “Yours sincerely and without malice”.

The Maharashtra CM’s response led to the trend #DevendraSlapsRajdeep on Twitter.