While Tim Paine will no longer lead his team out as Australia captain in the wake of a 'sexting' scandal, selectors have yet to decide whether he will take the field at all during the Ashes. Being captain was the one thing that guaranteed the 36-year-old selection and he now faces a challenge to prove he deserves a spot behind the stumps.
Paine is the only specialist wicketkeeper in Australia's 15-man squad to face England but selector George Bailey confirmed he is no lock for the first Ashes test starting in Brisbane on December 8.
Tim Paine speaking after confirming he'd stand down as the Australian Men's Test captain. He will be available for the Ashes. pic.twitter.com/PdwPIvfHXl
— Chloe-Amanda Bailey (@ChloeAmandaB) November 19, 2021
Paine, who has not played a first-class match since April, only made his return to competitive cricket from neck surgery on Monday, turning out for Tasmania's second XI against a South Australia side in Hobart.
As fellow Tasmanian Bailey looked on, Paine took six catches and moved well behind the stumps. Bailey, however, said he would recuse himself from a vote on picking Paine, a friend and business partner if there was no consensus on the selector's panel. "If the panel was not in agreeance on Tim's position going forward, and it was going to come down to a vote, then I would step aside and leave that to Tony (Dodemaide) and Justin (Langer) to work through," Bailey told the Cricket Etc podcast. "They're both aware of that," he added.
The panel will be expected to consider Paine's match fitness along with his glovework and batting when weighing candidates. Paine was dismissed lbw for one batting for Tasmania's second XI on Tuesday in a minor setback.
He is regarded as one of the country's top keepers, though his glovework came under heavy scrutiny during the India series early this year when he dropped three catches on day five of the drawn third test in Sydney, helping the tourists avert a potentially decisive defeat. While lacking a test century, Paine has a solid batting average of 32.63 from his 35 tests, which compares favourably with past Australia wicketkeepers Brad Haddin (32.98 from 66 tests) and Ian Healy (27.39 from 119 tests).
His main rivals include Alex Carey, who Paine beat out for the position when recalled for the 2017/18 Ashes, and another uncapped player in Western Australian Josh Inglis. White ball specialist Carey boasts a marginally better first-class batting average of 35.66 versus Paine's 30.16.
Inglis, named in the Australia 'A' squad with Carey, is also seen as a potential test prospect after racking up 585 runs, including three centuries, in the last Sheffield Shield season. Neither Carey nor Inglis have scored many runs in recent domestic matches, so the door may be ajar for a dark horse like Queensland wicketkeeper Jimmy Peirson.
— Short Leg Cricket (@shortlegcrick) November 19, 2021
Peirson's glovework is rated exemplary and he is averaging 53 in the Shield season to date, though his omission from the Australia 'A' squad may hurt his chances. While form is important, Paine's hopes of retaining his spot may ultimately rest on whether selectors feel he might be a major distraction amid the pressures of an Ashes series.
The sexting scandal will not be forgotten by Brisbane, and Paine would be an easy target on and off the field. Former wicketkeeper Healy supported Paine's retention but said he would need to be ready for the heat coming his way.
"He's going to be a distraction if he plays, if he doesn't want that distraction he shouldn't be playing either," Healy told radio station SEN.