Form panel to examine introduction of compulsory English test in civils: HC to govt
New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has directed the Centre to set up a panel to examine a plea against UPSC`s introduction of a compulsory English comprehension skill test in the prelims of the civil service examinations since 2011.
A bench of Chief Justice D Murugesan and Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw asked the Centre to set up the panel within three months and take a decision over the issue in nine months on a petition.
The petition filed by (Retd) Professor Dinanath Batra alleged that "the test of English Language Comprehension Skills adversely affects the Hindi and other regional language speaking candidates in taking the civil service exam."
"We dispose of this petition by directing the Union of India to, within three months, constitute appropriate committee, if not already in place, for examination of the questions raised by the petitioner and the representations of the petitioner...,in consultation with the UPSC, within nine months take a decision on the nature of the test of knowledge of English language in the Civil Services Examination.
"Whether it is to be only qualifying or competitive or mixture of both. We are confident that such committee, in its report will give reasons for its decision," the bench said.
The court recorded UPSC`s submission that superior knowledge of English gives a cutting edge to the civil servants who have to deal with global affairs and which would be a reasonable classification.
The bench said, "Though we do not find any merit in the challenge, on the grounds urged, but we still find an element of arbitrariness, also within the domain of Article 14, in the decision of the respondents (UPSC and Centre) to effect the change impugned in this petition."
The bench relied on court rulings which had held that every educational institution has right to determine its method of education and conditions of examination; such are matters of policy to be formulated by the state and the courts are not the forum to adjudicate upon such questions.
"We, though not inclined to quash or interfere with the impugned change, are constrained to nevertheless observe that the respondents (govt and UPSC) need to re-look into the matter....." the court said.
Batra, in his petition, contended the new test deprived a majority of Indian citizens, having Hindi or other languages as the language of instruction during their education, of a level playing field in the competition.
The petitioner`s counsel Jagdeep Dhankad and Monica Arora had argued that civil services aspirants till 2010 were required to answer two objective type question papers - one for general knowledge and the other on a subject of their choice, in the annual preliminary examination.
The UPSC, however, introduced a new Aptitude Test paper worth 200 marks in 2011 containing an English Language Comprehension Skill section worth 22.50 marks, to be answered compulsorily by all candidates, the lawyer said.
"Hindi is the basis of Indian culture and making English compulsory will strike a body blow to wipe off India`s rich cultural heritage from its roots. Hindi and other classical languages have to be given their rightful place in the educational system and in civil services," the petition said.
The petitioner also contended that the central government had not consulted various official committees on language, while implementing the new pattern.
More from India
More from World
More from Sports
More from Entertaiment
- One year of Modi govt: PM promises to fulfil aspirations
- DNA: Sikh man in New Zealand removed his turban to help injured kid
- Watch: Mumbai cops find new secret agents in housewives!
- Hundreds die as heat wave continues in India
- 2G scam: Ex-TRAI chief alleges Manmohan Singh had warned him to cooperate
- DNA: AIIMS doctor removes both kidneys of minor, claims she had only one
- Pranab Mukherjee defends Bofors scam, says it was just a media trial
- Salman Khan attends sister Arpita's wedding reception in Mandi
- Zee Media's mega survey on Modi govt
- Zee Media Exclusive: Vidya Balan chats about 'Hamari Adhuri Kahani'
- Para athlete Deepa Malik complains of callous service by Air India
- Smriti Irani visits Amethi, promises to pay insurance money to 25,000 women
- One year of Modi govt: Amit Shah addresses media
- Mathura rally: PM Modi's ten power-packed dialogues
- BBV: What challenges lie ahead of Modi govt?
- One year of NDA govt: PM Modi writes open letter to nation, promises to transform India
- World optimistic about India: PM Narendra Modi on 1 year of NDA govt
- MSBSHSE Class 12th HSC results 2015 to be declared at 1pm tomorrow
- Arpita-Aayush wedding reception: Salman Khan spreads love in Mandi, says `hum aapke hain`
- Bharatiya Janata Party lacks majority for Ram Temple, Article 370: Amit Shah
- Rahul Gandhi takes a dig at one year of Modi govt, wishes 'happy birthday' to 'suit-boot ki sarkar'
- AAP govt moves resolution against MHA notification: As it happened
- CBSE Class 10 Board Result 2015 (cbse.nic.in, cbseresults.nic.in) postponed?
- Heatwave kills 90 more in Andhra, Telangana; toll crosses 800
- UBSE Results 2015 (ubse.uk.gov.in): Uttarakhand 12th Result 2015 to be announced today at 11 AM
- Gujjars adamant on holding talks in Bayana; rail tracks remain blocked
- CBSE 10th result to be declared tomorrow
- CBSE Class X Board Results 2015 to declared tomorrow
- Check mahresult.nic.in for MSBSHSE Maharashtra Class 12 HSC Result 2015
- Maharashtra MSBSHSE HSC Result 2015 on mahresult.nic.in