Friday, December 13, 2013
Friday, December 13, 2013
'Anna should not be called a modern-day Mahatma’
Last Updated: Sunday, August 28, 2011, 15:37
He came to Delhi from a small village in Maharashtra. Within days, he had lakhs of supporters, followers and well wishers. Anna Hazare, who has become the leader of so-called India’s “second freedom struggle”, is now a youth icon, a brand, a ray of hope. He attracted such a feverish following that the politicians were left wondering.
In an exclusive interview with
, a political analyst, discusses the movement led by the 74-year-old civil rights activist.
Sanjay Kumar is a Fellow at the Centre for the Study of Developing Studies and deputy director of Lokniti, a research program of CSDS.
Anna Hazare is fondly called “modern-day Mahatma”. Do you think he should be given this tag?
While one cannot take away from Anna Hazare the credit of leading such a huge mobilisation, it is too much to call Anna Hazare a modern day Mahatma. We all know that Mahatma Gandhi had a way to put forward his demands; he always used to leave space for negotiations, always willing to concede a little and listen to others. Frankly, I do not find any of these qualities in Anna Hazare. I personally have objections to calling Anna Hazare a modern-day Mahatma.
Anna Hazare has risen from being a local activist to national anti-corruption crusader. How do you explain the Anna Hazare phenomenon that has gripped India?
Again, all credit to Anna for leading this movement and being able to mobilise people in huge numbers, unprecedented in the history of India after independence. Full credit to Anna, but much more credit to the issue - "corruption", which attracts all section of people - young, old, men, women, rural urban. Such is an issue of corruption that no one would like to be left out of this movement. It seems a moral responsibility of all to support the movement. The atmosphere is such that those who are not supporting the movement are seen as anti-national. The nature of the issue has captured the imagination of masses. I am sure many of them do not even know the provisions of the Jan Lokpal Bill.
In your view, what is the reason behind the youth coming out in such a large number to support the 74-year-old activist?
There are various reasons. First, the issue of corruption attracts all, so the young are attracted to this movement. Also, the youth are a more worried lot compared to others since they have to find their livelihood and there is a problem of increasing unemployment in India.
Do you find flaws in the tactics employed by Anna Hazare to force the government to pass Jan Lokpal Bill?
I support the cause, but certainly not the tactics employed by Anna Hazare. This is simply blackmailing the elected government by a few people taking help or finding strength by arousing sentiments amongst common people. When someone puts up some demand, he/she should be willing to negotiate, give space for dialogue and not just be rigid about one thing. It is important in this case, since this is about brining such an important legislation in the country. Legislation has its own process and it takes time, it can`t be done in such a hurry. There is a need for debate on such an important issue.
Do you think the Congress-led UPA will be out of power in 2014 due to this movement?
2014 is far away. If elections are held today, the present Congress-led UPA government would face huge difficulty. People`s anger is against the Central government. But I am not sure what may happen in 2014 if elections take place on time. The issue of corruption may not last that long, there may be new issues in 2014. Also, now elections have become much localised. Even in the national election, local issues dominate. There are hardly any national issues in elections now. While making choice, voters look at various issues, party, candidate, caste-community of the candidate (they would not say this but it happens). So, it is a little untimely to say anything about possible result of the 2014 Lok Sabha election.
(The views expressed by the author are personal)
`India desperate to break US-Pak ties’
Graft cases against babus on rise
CRPF officer arrested for leaking info to Naxals
CRPF officer arrested in Bihar for leaking information to Naxals
CBI constable convicted of graft, given 5-year RI
Ahead of Delhi Assembly polls, book maps voting patterns
comments powered by Disqus.
comments powered by
Most Popular in Exclusive
Apple iPhone 5S review: Bigger and better than before!
New HRA exemption rule: How it will affect you
Shoma Chaudhury Messes Up Batting for God Father Tejpal
Delhi Assembly Elections 2013: And the crown goes to…
My only encounter with the legend - Sachin Tendulkar
Triumph motorcycles ride into India: Models and price
My first inning has ended, second is about to begin: Sachin Tendulkar
State in Inertia: Nitish’s 8 Years in Bihar
Ajmal Kasab’s hanging could not act as a deterrent for Pakistan
More By Kamna Arora
Iran-US talks: Should Barack Obama fall into Hassan Rowhani`s trap?
`Al Qaeda threats will persist for foreseeable future`
LoC killings: `Pakistani soldiers joined with militants to attack India`
In India, even tragedies fail to make politicians act
Grow up Pakistan, Malala is not a CIA agent
Do Taliban really want peace?
Who owns Nelson Mandela?
Uttarakhand tragedy: Why was a disaster plan not ready?
Will Hassan Rouhani bring change in Iran?
Iran Presidential Elections 2013: Facts you must know
Manmohan Singh’s Japan visit: `India should remain unruffled by Chinese media`
Pervez Musharraf: From General to Prisoner
Will Imran Khan shine in Pakistan’s political innings?
Pakistan General Elections 2013: Facts you must know
Enjoy IPL with taste of Lebanon and Italy at `Spirit`
Will Arvind Kejriwal strike the right note with Delhiites this time?
`Sri Lankan govt not serious about resolving Tamil issue`
Sanjay Dutt convicted; hail Supreme Court
Another day, another rape; India unashamed
Will Hugo Chávez`s successor thaw ties with US?
Gaffe master Shinde. Oops! I withdraw my statement
`US gun laws significant challenge to Barack Obama`
Shut up Hafiz Saeed!
Ilyas Kashmiri still alive inside Pakistani troops
More rapes in India than in Bharat, really Mr Bhagwat?
Mr Rehman Malik, stop it!
Who is Xi Jinping?
Who is Li Keqiang?
What’s behind Narendra Modi-UK friendship?
Salute to Malala Yousafzai, shame on Pakistan
‘US consulate attack was planned to coincide with 9/11`
Indian govt, kindly react to China as well
The futility of engaging Pakistan
Should India ban Twitter?
Pakistan – A nightmare for Hindus
`Bollywood wants to be waxed abroad’
Will you vote for Team Anna?
`Politicisation of migration in Assam a problem`
Will Damascus Volcano burn Assad’s regime?
`China waiting for Dalai Lama to die`
Finally, Hosni Mubarak has been punished
New PM, but Pak remains the same
Happy Birthday, Aung San Suu Kyi!
US-Pak: An affair gone wrong
`US-Russia ties currently in a bit of flux`
US-China ties: Human rights suffer
Osama bin Laden is not dead
Is Pak Army falling in love with India?
Will Syria be at peace, ever?
China wins where India fails
Congress offers unconditional support to AAP to form govt in Delhi
Vasundhara Raje takes oath as Rajasthan Chief Minister
SC grants bail to Lalu Prasad in fodder scam case
more videos >>
Sushma Swaraj demands dismissal of Justice AK Ganguly
Nation remembers martyrs of 2001 Parliament attack
more videos >>
News from e-generator.com
Thank for your comment. Your comment will be seen by our moderator..!