Thursday, December 05, 2013
Thursday, December 05, 2013
Non Alignment 2.0: India and Pakistan
Non Alignment 2.0
India`s foreign policy
Last Updated: Monday, April 09, 2012, 13:24
A bunch of Indian think tanks recently came up with a comprehensive paper called Non Alignment 2.0 after over a year of deliberations. The objective of this paper is to provide guidance to India’s foreign and strategic policy over the next decade. This paper is a must read for anyone who wants a snapshot of India, its strengths, weaknesses, challenges facing it, opportunities lying ahead, steps that it can take to strengthen its position on the world stage and so on. This article aims to outline the strategies suggested by the experts with regards to our endearing yet threatening neighbour, Pakistan.
This paper advises the government to convince Pakistan that the pursuit of cross-border terrorism will not do it any good but only harm. A good idea but the paper fails to address the issue ‘how’? How can one convince a country that thinks India engages with it only because of its concern with cross-border terrorism, a fact corroborated by the paper itself? How can one convince a country that flexes it nuclear muscle every now and then? How can one convince a country that gave shelter to Osama bin Laden, a fact denied by them till the Abbottabad incident caught them unawares?
The paper suggests making terrorist attacks impossible in India. How? By strengthening the police, intelligence and counter-terrorism capabilities. The lesser said about our failure on these fronts, the better. And, the paper too does not do justice to the topic.
Another strategy that the paper advocates is to condemn human rights violations in places like Balochistan to eventually provide an effective tool against Pakistan’s public posturing on Jammu and Kashmir. Again, a big ‘how’? India needs to clean its own backyard before pointing fingers at others. Kashmir is a very sensitive issue and any such mistake can do it more harm than good.
The experts have suggested making India so indispensable to the people of Pakistan that the latter become stakeholders in the former’s progress. This could be by way of trade ties, water and energy supplies and the like. So far so good. However, the paper goes as far as to suggest military-to-military ties. Really? Given the state and role of the Army in Pakistan, is this really plausible?
The paper also suggests some magnanimous steps like providing a more liberal visa regime to welcome Pakistanis with open arms and minimal checks and restrictions. As much romanticised as this idea may seem, it is fraught with dangers. With our abysmal levels of security and porous borders, would not such steps add to our compounding problems? And, to suggest such hospitality even without any reciprocation from the Pakistani side, is to expect too much from a country still fresh out of the 26/11 attacks.
To be fair to the paper, it does highlight certain practical steps. Whenever there is a terrorist attack in India, all dialogue with Pakistan is stopped. A few months down the line, the dialogue is resumed from the scratch, nullifying all past efforts. This kind of an emotionally charged reaction is counter-productive to both the countries. This paper rightly suggests keeping the communication lines open, especially when such attacks happen with a clear message that India will not tolerate this.
The experts have suggested some farsighted strategies as well. They suggest that India should continue to support Afghanistan in its nation building exercise, much to the chagrin of Pakistan. Over a period of time when America would lose interest in Afghanistan, Pakistan would not be in a strong position with its coffers drying up. Then, it would be advantage India.
This paper covers all that one needs to know about the challenges we face with Pakistan and the opportunities that it presents. However, all that the paper talks about has already been said before, time and again. If the strategies outlined were public knowledge and have not helped so far, what is the guarantee that they would now? The answer lies in one keyword, ‘intent’. Everybody knows what is to be done and why but, till there is a political will at the top, nothing can succeed. No paper, no meeting, no think tank, no article, nothing. Hope the government is listening. Hope the political parties can think beyond elections and do something for the country’s future instead. Hope Pakistan too is listening. Hope the international community is listening. Hope everybody who matters is listening. Hope this paper does not end up becoming yet another intellectual exercise that could not be implemented.
(Shobhika Puri is a freelance writer)
(The views expressed by the author are personal)
Myanmar on the path of democracy
Digitization of land, still a dream!
comments powered by Disqus.
comments powered by
Most Popular in Exclusive
Apple iPhone 5S review: Bigger and better than before!
New HRA exemption rule: How it will affect you
Shoma Chaudhury Messes Up Batting for God Father Tejpal
My only encounter with the legend - Sachin Tendulkar
Triumph motorcycles ride into India: Models and price
Delhi Assembly Elections 2013: And the crown goes to…
State in Inertia: Nitish’s 8 Years in Bihar
Ajmal Kasab’s hanging could not act as a deterrent for Pakistan
Campa Cola Compound society: The tale of a resident
More By Shobhika Puri
Google’s 11/11 Alert
Politics of Mixed Signals
India’s international image
Narendra Modi’s `Being PM` plan
The battles whistleblowers have to fight
Let’s have elections – now!
Is Manmohan Singh changing?
The Heavy Hand of Censorship
The Lobby Against Lobbying
Know Your Facebook
Give LK Advani a chance
The Compulsions and Repercussions of Compulsory Licensing
Hang me, if I am guilty...
The 1991 trio is back!
The Petroleum Politics
Another Test For Sachin
What if Congress had won in UP?
Brand ‘Anna’ getting diluted?
More than meets the eye
Ulta Pulta Nitin (Gadkari)
The Right to be forgotten
What was Modi thinking?
Singh Is King
Mahatma Gandhi for Gen Y
‘Power of Gandhi’ versus ‘Gandhi in Power’
What is Corruption?
Pranab gets a call and ‘I’ become happy?
Loss of Innocent Lives
Media’s Moral Failure
The Dying Spirit of Sportsmanship
Is death enough for Kasab?
Why single out Lalit Modi?
It’s Black. It’s White… It’s Black and White
The US for us
Passing the Buck
Exit polls: Landslide win predicted for BJP in Rajasthan; Cong routed
Delhi sees record voting; over 65% turnout
Top Headlines in 500 seconds @10pm
more videos >>
Top 10 News in 2 Mins @8pm
Gunfire on between 3 Lashkar terrorists, security forces in J&K`s Handwara
more videos >>
News from e-generator.com
Thank for your comment. Your comment will be seen by our moderator..!