Minority sub-quota: SC blow to Centre
Zeenews
       English        
 Follow Me on Pinterest Google Plus Ditto RSS Mail to us Mail to us
Sunday, May 19, 2013 
Search
Nation

Minority sub-quota: SC blow to Centre

Last Updated: Wednesday, June 13, 2012, 14:14     A- A A+
Comments 14
Minority sub-quota: SC blow to Centre Zeenews Bureau

New Delhi: In a blow to the Centre, the Supreme Court on Wednesday refused to stay the Andhra Pradesh High Court order quashing 4.5 per cent sub-quota for minorities, carved out from the 27 per cent reservation for OBCs, in the central educational institutions such as IITs.

While admitting the government’s Special Leave Petition (SLP) against the Andhra HC order, the apex court questioned the grant of 4.5 per cent reservation to minorities on religious ground.

It also issued notices and sought response from petitioners who had challenged the 4.5 per cent sub-quota.

The SC decision leaves the fate of 325 candidates hanging in balance, as they had cleared the IIT-JEE 2012 test under the 4.5 per cent sub-quota.

On Monday, the apex court had rapped the Centre for the way it had handled the "complex" and "sensitive" issue of reservation for minorities, while hearing its plea against the Andhra Pradesh HC order.

The Supreme Court had on Monday expressed its "unhappiness" that the Centre was blaming the High Court when it had itself failed to produce documents to support its case.

As directed by the SC, the Centre had yesterday placed before it the “relevant” material and documents on the basis of which it carved out 4.5 per cent sub-quota for minorities.

The SC Bench was critical of the Ministry of Human Resource Development rushing to the apex court with the appeal against the May 28 order of the High Court without documents to justify the policy of carving out 4.5 per cent sub-quota within the 27 per cent OBC reservation.

The Union government had moved the apex court challenging the HC order quashing the 4.5 per cent sub-quota for minorities.

The December 22, 2011 Office Memorandum for the sub-quota for socially and educationally backward classes of citizens belonging to minority communities in central educational institutions and jobs was announced by the Centre ahead of the Assembly Elections in five States including Uttar Pradesh and Punjab.

For Zee News’s Updates, follow us on Twitter , Facebook, Google+, Pinterest

First Published: Wednesday, June 13, 2012, 08:55

Post your Comments

Name:
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

Comments

ggggg - yyyyyyyy
don`t ask for 4.5% obc sub quota, ask govt for overall reservation quota like 33% ladies reservation, overall reservation of all minorities is better
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
ALAMGEER - delhi
I urge to all our national brother including BJP/RSS brother should be amend the constitution for minority as well as muslim Reservation.It can uplift the weaker section of india.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
satyamitra - noida
Muslims have ruled this country for 800 years,they were rulers,not opressed,as now they claim,Hindus were the sfferers,Muslims have already got 25% reservation by way of dividing India.Now Muslims wants more.CHIT BHI MERI,PAT BHI MERI ANTI MERE BAAP KI. . .
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
karim - abad
you talking abt which 25 % reservation ? Dear Satya among 25 % atmost 5 % seats hardly get filled by muslims, all other by Hindu, just google and find list of recruited and admitted students and employees, whr u can see it!!! Expand your knowledge buddy dont make such a ppost without any prior knowledge...
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Vijay - Chandigarh
What a shame, the congress is now Luring voters in the states in which it has lost the elections by biasing religion.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Sawood anwar - delhi
Thats shame over 50 per cent reservation is going on to Hindus by the mane of ST,SC and OBC for 65 years.I think it is not justified in our nation.Is Muslim population reserved for gaining neglagible ratio of resevation that our brothers dont want to do so.How nation will prosper without upheaval of one section.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Annonomys - Jharkhand
Well Hindus are not ST,SC . The whole ST section except 3 communities rest communities worship thier anseistor(Grand Parents) they do not follow any hindu religious book as well tradition , they also eat cow and other animals meat (Eating Cow is Prohibited in Hindus ) . So at no codition there are hindus but they seriously need the reservation just go to jharkhand,orrisaa and those place the are like tribal they struggling to get a place in current society . And SC is also t same they are not hindus only 7-8 communities who follow hindu tradition like women having sindur and some but they not following the religion at all also they have the same condtion as ST but they live village where ST lives in HIlls and remote areas . Only majority of Backward Hindu which we called Dalits and some minority Medium Level Hindus but OBC also contain backward Muslims and Christians . It is a balanced reservation for all communities .
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Karimkhan - Ahmedabad
If all believe that 4.5 % is for muslims only, then they should also look for SC ST quota of 25 %. Only hindus are getting benefit of it! If they just passed any exam then they will benefited like getting 99%. I also believe that all 100 % seats should be common no quota. But if you want to follow it then dont bring any partiality...(25+20[45] , 2.5 % may be muslims in 27% OBC) 45 % hindus getting benefit of quota then nobody will make is issue, but if there`s matter of giving 4.5 % seats to minority (I know majority is muslim) then every one will take interest to oppose it.....why nobody raising voice to remove all quota ????
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
IBsika Munda - Bihar
I belongs to SC community belives me excepts 1-2 community in SC amd ST rest are not Hindus . We are Pagans , we worship our Ancestor and Lords , we can also eat any animal we are not restricted like Hindus . We are proud of it . Muslims have good condition in India just come to our village and you will say thats this 25 % is not enough . well i agree that 10% more quto form OBC be given us or govt shoild add that quta to genral . Hindus have also good condtion in socitey .
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Nayan - USA
Reservation based on Cast is pure Discrimination ... Anybody educated should demand to favor in NO RESERVATION rather than asking for it... Concept of Reservation was for limited time only after Independence... But Selfish Congress and Other Parties Kept adding more to fullfill their agenda....
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
karimkhan - Abadd
@IBsika Munda : Actually till day i saw only hindus in this quota, my intention is not to hurt any partucular community! Other then Minority religious and Hindu there`s not any other religious in India then to which religious you belongs???? I saw that all general category ppl getting 95% even they will not get IIT or something that they want, and if SC ST ppl get 35 + they can easily think for that!! I am also took admission in general category, above post i mentioned bcoz all our brothers dont mind if >40 % of seats are given to other, but they do if 4.5 % is given to Minority (Not only muslims)
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Karimkhana - Abad
I agree Nayan with no reservation system, I wrote above post just bcoz here everyone enjoying quota and whn Muslims getting 4.5 % seats then they making it major issue...
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
MD SHAHBAZ SALIM - gaya
i qualified iit this year and i belong from minority category,,,,i was sure i will get iit this year but now my future is in dark,, i may not get iit,,, i dont know what is right or what is wrong,, but logo ko sapne dikha kar todna nai chahiye,,,,,,,na minority reservation hota na hum sapne dekhte aur na hi koi sapna chakna chur hota,,,,,, who will help me now????? na to court ka kuch jaa raha aur na hi sarkaar ka,, jata to saala hum jaise students ka,,, agar kuch banate ho yo woh karo warna sapne dikho hi mat
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
ritesh khan - anonymous
wat rank did you got dear
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
ravi - motihari
bhai dnt worry. if u belong to OBC minority, then u wud get seat in OBC quota. however tmhr branch thoda gadbad hoga bt it wont affect u too much.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Muslims - India
Dear Muslims & Minority : Keep in your mind, we are not going to get any benefit from any government in India, either Congress, SP or SC & HC. They never let us grow, just trying to let down since 1947, so we should think for our future, don`t depend on them. We should go for higher study and seek jobs in abroad or concentrate on business, let them do jurm, see how many years. They always blame Muslims king in the past, if they did wrong, so what now they are doing with us. Indian Government and Courts just for one community.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Anti Reservation - India
see brother, if u hav the talent and calibre, compete as a general candidate. Why depending on quota to get success. The entire reservation system should be abolished first. Govt should help only the poors and needy people. Others should compete on their merit.
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
Nayan - USA
I can understand your feeling but Reservation is for Losers !!! So If you not getting reservation then feel good... I am Hindu but I feel sad that these corrupt politicians fool people for vote bank and introduce cast based reservation... If we absolutely need reservation then go by Need based rather than Cast .......
Reply

Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
TCS PRASAD - Bhilai
Present quota system is a glaring example of misuse of a good cause. Actually quota benefits are not going to the real needy. This is garnered by a hand ful of creamy layers. Why ministers ,IAS officers engineers should get the quota benefits as this is only for the under previlaged? This is only to appease vote banks. If the govt is sincere on its approach, it should eliminate the creamy layer or restrict availing quota benefits only once in a family. there should not be qupta in promotions as they are already at par with others.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
shikhar - New delhi
@ Neha - I guess you didn`t get it. In a blow to the centre, Supreme Court has dismissed the stay applied by the government. In other words, supreme court has reinstated the fact that the sub quota sytem is absolutely wrong.This decision should be welcomed!!s
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 
K Deva Prasad - Kundapur
What is meant by Minority. Is there any criteria for this. Only muslims are not minority. Why our political class doen`t think about other minorities.
Reply



Post your Comments

X
Name
Place :
Email :
Comments :
 

View all Comments   

Most liked Comments

Neha Rathore - New Delhi
sc should not divide India on basis of religion as for muslims ,because there are other religions also which will also fight for it.minority sub quota should not be passed



satyamitra - noida
Muslims have ruled this country for 800 years,they were rulers,not opressed,as now they claim,Hindus were the sfferers,Muslims have already got 25% reservation by way of dividing India.Now Muslims wants more.CHIT BHI MERI,PAT BHI MERI ANTI MERE BAAP KI. . .



Anti Reservation - India
see brother, if u hav the talent and calibre, compete as a general candidate. Why depending on quota to get success. The entire reservation system should be abolished first. Govt should help only the poors and needy people. Others should compete on their merit.



Top News



latest

Archives

Aarushi-Hemraj murder case: No respite to Talwars in Supreme Court


Read More »