Scarlett Keeling's death caused by external forces, claims defence

Two Goans are facing trial for allegedly drugging, sexually abusing and leaving British teenager Scarlett Keeling to die on Anjuna beach in 2008.

Panaji: The final arguments in the charge sheet filed by the CBI in connection with the death of British teenager Scarlett Keeling began on Wednesday with defence counsel claiming her death was caused by "external forces".

Scarlett's mother, meanwhile, expressed hope that the judgement in the case would be pronounced by next week.

CBI's Special Public Prosecutor Ejaz Khan and defence lawyer Marvin D'Souza argued before Goa Children's Court in the case where two locals Samsung D'Souza and Placido Carvalho are facing trial for allegedly drugging, sexually abusing and leaving Scarlett to die on Anjuna beach in 2008.

The 16-year-old's bruised and semi-nude body was found at Anjuna beach, following which the police had claimed it as a case of drowning, but later registered it as a culpable homicide after second autopsy report by doctors from Goa Medical College and Hospital.


While defending the accused, D'Souza claimed that the investigations have been marred by high pressure diplomatic and media trial and what should have been a normal death by drowning has been changed to a high profile case.

He submitted that "death of Scarlett was caused by external forces and not due to the accused".

Even as the defence claimed a contradiction in the statement by witnesses when the case was moved from Goa Police to CBI, Khan argued that the statement of witnesses remained unchanged when the central agency started a fresh investigation.

Khan argued that injury marks on the body were evidence that Scarlett had a scuffle with Samsung D'Souza, who was then working on the shack, near which her body was found.

The defence counsel said the death could have been a result of external forces. The injuries could have been during shifting of the body from the accident site (beach) to the hospital, he said.

The arguments will continue tomorrow as the court said the case would be heard till Friday.

Scarlett's mother Fiona Mackeown, who was present in the court, said she hopes the case concludes by next week.

"If it is extended this week, it is fine, but if it is extended for a month, then I would be a bit disturbed because, in month's time, memories fade. I would like to see it conclude as the final arguments are likely to be finished in three days," she told PTI outside the court premises here.

"That would be enough time. If I can, it is not too much time, I would wait for the order. I have a job, I have children back home to look after, but I would like to see the final order," she further said.

The case had grabbed international attention as Britishers used to be the largest number of tourists visiting Goa. 

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. You can find out more by clicking this link